Yeah its a bit of a bait question as there's a few on this board that hate Selwood.Selwood and it's not close.
Scooter was a BnF winner in a semi-final finishing side, genuine up and coming star and a future captain before he ruined his ankle.
Scooter also had no trouble playing on ball(actually won his B&F as an on baller) and if he was still in the side, Simmo would easily chuck him on ball if we are getting slaughtered at contested possessions and/or clearances. Hutchings offensive game at AFL is pretty poor.
Deep down i wanted Scooter to stay but that injury ruined him and he wet from being one of most promising mids in 2013 to pure depth in 2015. Its a bit like whats happening with Emac now.