Player X v Y v Z

[Andrew Birch]

Jelwood based on rum home

What Tox said.

Thanks guys. Jelwood it is.

 

[Huttabito]

Jelwood based on rum home

Yes please!

 

[DaveyBoy123]

Jelwood or Gola for mine. Don't trust GAJ.

Just as a matter of interest, any reason why you didn't even mention/consider the player who has the best season average of the 4?

 

[Andrew Birch]

Just as a matter of interest, any reason why you didn't even mention/consider the player who has the best season average of the 4?

Personal bias I suppose. Have never owned Duncan in any fantasy format. He didn't breakout as a SC premo until his 8th year. Has been very good this year and last year though. I just prefer other players even though he's an excellent POD pick.

 

[Hava Alle]

Macrae v Jelly?

 

[bbco49]

Best mid + defender combo for Gaff + Savage replacements, with $26,900 in the bank (and a must win final this week):

Jelwood + Hurn
Mcrouch/Duncan/T Adams + Crisp/Tuohy
Macrae + Salem/Doedee

 

[Hai_Newman]

Best mid + defender combo for Gaff + Savage replacements, with $26,900 in the bank (and a must win final this week):

Jelwood + Hurn
Mcrouch/Duncan/T Adams + Crisp/Tuohy
Macrae + Salem/Doedee

First option.

 

[JohnChainz]

Hurley, Webster or Alir Alir?

Alir Alir surprisingly averaging decent over the last 5

 

[tubes82]

Crisp or brayshaw?

 

[toxic]

Crisp or brayshaw?

Brayshaw

 

[Andrew Birch]

Rd22 forced trade for Heater (RIP). Go with experience or play the kids?

Simpson v Witherden

 

[Hai_Newman]

Rd22 forced trade for Heater (RIP). Go with experience or play the kids?

Simpson v Witherden

 

[gh172]

Simpson!

I need to trade Heater and Walters (I have Simpson).
Menagola and Hurn or Brayshaw and Gray?

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

 

[Hai_Newman]

Simpson!

I need to trade Heater and Walters (I have Simpson).
Menagola and Hurn or Brayshaw and Gray?

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

 

[Andrew Birch]

Simpson's lowest score this year was against the Doggies when Caleb Daniel sat on him for the whole game. The little runt is in good form at the moment too.

 

[NMxrkxdxs]

Menegola v DSmith

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Menegola v DSmith

Menegola.......GEEL last two games at home .....against FREO & GC .....last two scores 119 & 144

No Brainer !

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Rd22 forced trade for Heater (RIP). Go with experience or play the kids?

Simpson v Witherden

Witherden ......110 last week ....GC this week ....he finished strongly last season too

CARL play Bulldogs & Crows .....Simpson just 1 ton in 5 weeks .....they're done

 

[BigLittleHawk]

Hi guys. I'm desperate for some advice. Please help, and thanks in advance.
I would like to make 2 changes this round...

Doedee for any DEF:
Crisp, McGovern, Hurn, JJ, B.Smith, Tmac.???

Ahern for any FWD:
Tomahawk, Wingard, De Goey, Buddy, Tmac, Billings, R.Gray.???

 

[DaveyBoy123]

Menegola.......GEEL last two games at home .....against FREO & GC .....last two scores 119 & 144

No Brainer !

How about if the choice was Menegola vs Jelwood? I seriously can't split them.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

How about if the choice was Menegola vs Jelwood? I seriously can't split them.

Coin toss .....but i can see Jelwood coasting in the "easier" last 2 games ......

 

[DaveyBoy123]

Coin toss .....but i can see Jelwood coasting in the "easier" last 2 games ......

Yeah, ditto... Or more realistically, 1 of the games anyway.

I have to decide whether I go on field Menegola & Holman this week & then Menegola & Jelly next week (IE: Trade Gaff to Menegola)
OR Macrae & Holman this week & then Macrae & Holman next week as well. (IE: Trade Jelly to Macrae)

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Yeah, ditto... Or more realistically, 1 of the games anyway.

I have to decide whether I go on field Menegola & Holman this week & then Menegola & Jelly next week (IE: Trade Gaff to Menegola)
OR Macrae & Holman this week & then Macrae & Holman next week as well. (IE: Trade Jelly to Macrae)

This is if your able to get away with (league situation)

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

I want to trade Gaff to a new mid, who is the best option under 532k?

Joel Selwood
Mitch DUNCAN
Scott Pendlebury
Edward CURNOW
Shaun Higgins
Callan Ward
Marcus Bontempelli
Sebastian Ross
Luke PARKER
Matt Crouch
Steele Sidebottom
Lachlan Hunter
Sam MENEGOLA


Gut says Ross
Head says Selwood but head also says Banfield is back in
Balls say Hunter

 

[Suns of Anarchy]

I want to trade Gaff to a new mid, who is the best option under 532k?

Joel Selwood
Mitch DUNCAN
Scott Pendlebury
Edward CURNOW
Shaun Higgins
Callan Ward
Marcus Bontempelli
Sebastian Ross
Luke PARKER
Matt Crouch
Steele Sidebottom
Lachlan Hunter
Sam MENEGOLA


Gut says Ross
Head says Selwood but head also says Banfield is back in
Balls say Hunter

Fill your pockets with the Bont.