List Mgmt. Pick 27 & F2 Traded for North 2025 Round 1

Did We Get The Pick Right


  • Total voters
    151
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

After the shit he has put up with at North i doubt he would want to come to us.
He will go to the Hawks, Pies or Cats IMO...
Pies are in worse shape than us
 

Log in to remove this ad.

can't believe norf were desperate for talls, sat and watched us take 3 of the best in the draft off the board, then gave us their F1 for the shitlock

Will Ferrell Lol GIF
Apparently they rang every club from pick 11 onwards.lol
 

Attachments

  • 9bi89g.jpg
    9bi89g.jpg
    75.4 KB · Views: 9
North Melbourne did not locate to the Gold Coast because North Melbourne supporters deserved to have the opportunity to attend all their home games.

Two seconds later they sell home games to Tasmania and then Western Australia.

How does having interstate home games provide their supporters the opportunity to attend these home games?
 
North Melbourne did not locate to the Gold Coast because North Melbourne supporters deserved to have the opportunity to attend all their home games.

Two seconds later they sell home games to Tasmania and then Western Australia.

How does having interstate home games provide their supporters the opportunity to attend these home games?
Very good pick up!
Zackly ✅
How quickly(AFL) we all forget!
 
North Melbourne did not locate to the Gold Coast because North Melbourne supporters deserved to have the opportunity to attend all their home games.

Two seconds later they sell home games to Tasmania and then Western Australia.

How does having interstate home games provide their supporters the opportunity to attend these home games?
They reckon they have so few supporters in Victoria that there’ll be a roughly equal number of their supporters anywhere else
 
There was nothing stopping them from trading those 2 picks (19 & 20) for other picks and maintaining a presence in this years draft. If we identified that this draft was strong and deep then they would have too.

This so called strategy smacks of Clarkson having too much say in list management.

I wasn’t aware of that. I thought it was use them in a trade for players or potentially lose them. Whatever… it’s a glorious cluster f*ck regardless


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

North Melbourne did not locate to the Gold Coast because North Melbourne supporters deserved to have the opportunity to attend all their home games.

Two seconds later they sell home games to Tasmania and then Western Australia.

How does having interstate home games provide their supporters the opportunity to attend these home games?

Like us they have reciprocal home game rights when playing as away team in Melbourne.

Just like the Hawks did in Dusty's 300th for our home game.

And we did when we sold games to Cairns.
 
I wasn’t aware of that. I thought it was use them in a trade for players or potentially lose them. Whatever… it’s a glorious cluster f*ck regardless


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
The only caveat attached to those picks was that they would lose them if they significantly improved their ladder position.

You can't lose them if you trade them for other draft capital.

A monumental **** up in so many levels that led to us with another top 5 pick.
 
The only caveat attached to those picks was that they would lose them if they significantly improved their ladder position.

You can't lose them if you trade them for other draft capital.

A monumental **** up in so many levels that led to us with another top 5 pick.

Even if you forgave them those trades .. the Daniel for 25 is unforgivable IMO. They had Darling and Parker tucked away. And they have running HBF options coming out of their wazoo … Fisher, McKercher, Scheezel … even Duursma, Phillips.

They must have known PRIOR TO THE DRAFT as we all did that at least one of : Whitlock, Whitlock, Shanahan, Faull, Sims, Armstrong were getting to mid-late 20’s…. as it turned out 3 of them made it.

They could have also easily traded 2 to GWS for 15, 16 and a F2. Armstrong and Whitlock plus capital for other trades.

Or pick 2 to us for 11, 23 and 24 : Hotton, Whitlock and Shanahan…. plus keep 25 and pick up the other Whitlock to play CHB.

So it’s FOS and Daniel

V

Whitlock x 2, Hotton and Shanahan.

FOS is gonna have to be a player from another world to forgive the way the Roos botched this entire trade/draft period.



Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
All jokes aside, this may be one of the biggest reamings in sporting history. This is one of those where the AFL should have stormed into that north recruitment room and started throwing hands. I still cannot believe this trade occurred. North recruiters should apologize to their fan base.
 
Even if you forgave them those trades .. the Daniel for 25 is unforgivable IMO. They had Darling and Parker tucked away. And they have running HBF options coming out of their wazoo … Fisher, McKercher, Scheezel … even Duursma, Phillips.

They must have known PRIOR TO THE DRAFT as we all did that at least one of : Whitlock, Whitlock, Shanahan, Faull, Sims, Armstrong were getting to mid-late 20’s…. as it turned out 3 of them made it.

They could have also easily traded 2 to GWS for 15, 16 and a F2. Armstrong and Whitlock plus capital for other trades.

Or pick 2 to us for 11, 23 and 24 : Hotton, Whitlock and Shanahan…. plus keep 25 and pick up the other Whitlock to play CHB.

So it’s FOS and Daniel

V

Whitlock x 2, Hotton and Shanahan.


FOS is gonna have to be a player from another world to forgive the way the Roos botched this entire trade/draft period.



Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Actually,

FOS, Whitlock, Daniel and our F2 (could be 30)

v

Whitlock x 2, Hotton, Shanahan and Sharp/Ludowyke/Greaves
 
They could have also easily traded 2 to GWS for 15, 16 and a F2. Armstrong and Whitlock plus capital for other trades.

Or pick 2 to us for 11, 23 and 24 : Hotton, Whitlock and Shanahan…. plus keep 25 and pick up the other Whitlock to play CHB.
Not sure if either us nor GWS would have made those trades.
 
I think we by and large don’t realize how many deals are pitched over the trade period into draft night.

If we can think it, odds are teams have discussed it.
Discuss? Sure, but you said they could have easily have made those trades
I'm not so sure we would have traded away 3 picks in the Top 25 of this draft just to get Pick 2, we were taking calls as early as 11 and no one could offer us enough to pull the trigger, so I just don't think it was going to be that easy
 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. Pick 27 & F2 Traded for North 2025 Round 1

Back
Top