Competitions Make Your Own Team - Carlton Board AFL Player Draft Game

Remove this Banner Ad

It seems GOD can be bought ;)…

This team is undeniably impressive and boasts a solid balance of youth, skill, and experience across all positions. There are several reasons why this group can be considered one of the best.

Key Reasons:​

  1. Defensive Solidity:
    • Andrew McGrath and James Sicily bring excellent leadership and ball use in the backline, with Sicily providing strong intercept marking and McGrath’s versatility.
    • The half-back line is also formidable with Connor McKenna and Adam Saad offering speed and flair, while Connor Idun is an elite one-on-one defender who can nullify the opposition’s best forwards.
  2. Midfield Power:
    • Matt Rowell brings relentless tackling and contested ball-winning ability. Darcy Parish complements this with elite ball distribution, while Connor Rozee is dynamic and capable of breaking through contests.
    • Josh Weddle is a promising young talent who adds a spark with his creativity and ability to push forward.
  3. Forward Line:
    • The forward half is potent, with players like Jesse Hogan, Brad Close, and Isaac Rankine contributing with both ground-level pressure and goal-scoring potential. Hogan provides a key target, while Linc McCarthyand Eric Hipwood add versatility and height to create mismatches.
  4. Bench & Depth:
    • The bench depth is superb. Dane Rampe offers experience and versatility, while Jack Martin provides speed and skill, Leo Lombardi brings energy and creativity, and Dylan Shiel offers speed and experience in the middle.
    • Maurice Rioli Jnr is a game-breaker who can change the match with his speed and flair off the bench.

Weaknesses:​

  • The biggest concern could be the relative inexperience in some areas, particularly in the key forward line (if injuries hit players like Hogan or Hipwood). However, the sheer talent and depth available in the midfield and defensive setups compensate for this.

Rating: 9.5/10​

This team has all the right ingredients—quality defenders, a hard-hitting midfield, and potent forwards. The depth is remarkable, and the tactical flexibility this lineup offers is second to none. If they can avoid injuries, they would be a serious contender for the best-ever title.
 
CCurnow3votes said:
It seems GOD can be bought ;)…

This team is undeniably impressive and boasts a solid balance of youth, skill, and experience across all positions. There are several reasons why this group can be considered one of the best.

Key Reasons:​

  1. Defensive Solidity:
    • Andrew McGrath and James Sicily bring excellent leadership and ball use in the backline, with Sicily providing strong intercept marking and McGrath’s versatility.
    • The half-back line is also formidable with Connor McKenna and Adam Saad offering speed and flair, while Connor Idun is an elite one-on-one defender who can nullify the opposition’s best forwards.
  2. Midfield Power:
    • Matt Rowell brings relentless tackling and contested ball-winning ability. Darcy Parish complements this with elite ball distribution, while Connor Rozee is dynamic and capable of breaking through contests.
    • Josh Weddle is a promising young talent who adds a spark with his creativity and ability to push forward.
  3. Forward Line:
    • The forward half is potent, with players like Jesse Hogan, Brad Close, and Isaac Rankine contributing with both ground-level pressure and goal-scoring potential. Hogan provides a key target, while Linc McCarthyand Eric Hipwood add versatility and height to create mismatches.
  4. Bench & Depth:
    • The bench depth is superb. Dane Rampe offers experience and versatility, while Jack Martin provides speed and skill, Leo Lombardi brings energy and creativity, and Dylan Shiel offers speed and experience in the middle.
    • Maurice Rioli Jnr is a game-breaker who can change the match with his speed and flair off the bench.

Weaknesses:​

  • The biggest concern could be the relative inexperience in some areas, particularly in the key forward line (if injuries hit players like Hogan or Hipwood). However, the sheer talent and depth available in the midfield and defensive setups compensate for this.

Rating: 9.5/10​

This team has all the right ingredients—quality defenders, a hard-hitting midfield, and potent forwards. The depth is remarkable, and the tactical flexibility this lineup offers is second to none. If they can avoid injuries, they would be a serious contender for the best-ever title.
Click to expand...

He certainly can!!! :p

Backline (B, HB)​

  • B: Joel Jeffrey, Alex Pearce (VC), Josh Sinn
    • Alex Pearce (VC) leads a formidable defensive unit with elite intercepting and leadership skills. He's capable of shutting down the competition's best forwards.
    • Joel Jeffrey adds flair and versatility as a hybrid defender who can take intercept marks and rebound effectively.
    • Josh Sinn brings exceptional speed and kicking efficiency, making him a perfect outlet under pressure.
    • Verdict: This backline is perfectly balanced with leadership, defensive strength, and rebound run.
  • HB: Keidean Coleman, Sam De Koning, Brayden Maynard
    • Keidean Coleman is one of the most dangerous attacking half-back flankers in the competition, offering elite ball use and line-breaking speed.
    • Sam De Koning is a premier young key defender, capable of nullifying tall forwards while also providing intercept marking.
    • Brayden Maynard’s toughness and ability to shut down opponents make him a perfect complement to the more creative defenders.
    • Verdict: This half-back line can dominate games with toughness, creativity, and elite ball movement.

Midfield (C, FOLL, I/C)​

  • C: Jeremy Sharp, Adam Cerra, Liam Henry
    • Adam Cerra anchors this midfield with his class, composure, and elite ball use.
    • Liam Henry provides speed, agility, and game-breaking ability on the outside, ensuring the midfield can run and spread effectively.
    • Jeremy Sharp is the ultimate endurance athlete, running both ways and ensuring a relentless work rate over four quarters.
    • Verdict: This midfield offers the perfect mix of inside strength and outside pace.
  • FOLL: Marc Pittonet, Patrick Cripps (C), Scott Pendlebury
    • Patrick Cripps (C) is the ultimate midfield leader, combining brute strength, contested dominance, and a never-say-die attitude.
    • Scott Pendlebury adds unmatched poise, experience, and vision, making this midfield one of the smartest in the competition.
    • Marc Pittonet might not be the flashiest ruckman, but he provides a consistent and reliable presence in the hit-outs, feeding the elite on-ballers effectively.
    • Verdict: This on-ball brigade is elite, with Cripps and Pendlebury forming a combination that few midfields could match.
  • I/C: Jack Bowes, Alex Cincotta, Jack Silvagni, Brandon Zerk-Thatcher
    • Jack Bowes is a utility weapon who can slot into defense, midfield, or forward, offering flexibility.
    • Alex Cincotta’s work ethic and role-playing ability make him a perfect depth player who can perform anywhere on the field.
    • Jack Silvagni is a Swiss army knife, capable of impacting as a forward, ruck relief, or midfielder.
    • Brandon Zerk-Thatcher provides excellent key defensive depth and versatility.
    • Verdict: A versatile bench capable of plugging any gaps and maintaining high performance.

Forward Line (HF, F)​

  • HF: Jordan De Goey, Nick Larkey, Cam Rayner
    • Jordan De Goey is the x-factor. He’s unstoppable when at his best, capable of breaking games open in the midfield or forward.
    • Nick Larkey is a key forward who delivers consistently with elite contested marking and goal-kicking accuracy.
    • Cam Rayner provides explosive power, creativity, and the ability to win games with moments of brilliance.
    • Verdict: This half-forward line is dynamic, powerful, and packed with goal-scoring potential.
  • F: Liam Baker, Josh Treacy, Jamie Elliott
    • Liam Baker is the ultimate pressure forward, relentless in creating turnovers and producing clutch moments in front of goal.
    • Josh Treacy adds a strong, competitive key forward presence, capable of creating contests and finishing opportunities.
    • Jamie Elliott is a proven match-winner with elite goal sense and the ability to perform in big moments.
    • Verdict: A clinical and versatile forward line that thrives under pressure and delivers in key moments.

Substitute​

  • SUB: Matt Cottrell
    • Matt Cottrell is the perfect impact player to bring on late in games. His running capacity, energy, and ability to influence contests make him a game-changer in the dying stages.

Team Strengths​

  1. Elite Leadership and Experience: With Cripps, Pendlebury, and Pearce, this team has the on-field leadership to thrive in any situation.
  2. Versatility Across the Ground: Players like De Goey, Silvagni, Baker, and Bowes ensure adaptability to any scenario.
  3. Dynamic Forward Line: A mix of power, precision, and pressure makes this forward line impossible to stop.
  4. Rock-Solid Defense: A perfect combination of intercept marking, shutdown defenders, and attacking rebound makes the backline impenetrable.
  5. Midfield Class and Grit: Cripps and Pendlebury are as good as it gets, supported by excellent wingmen and a reliable ruck.

Weaknesses​

None! Every part of this team is balanced, elite, and built to perform under pressure.

Final Rating​

  • Defensive Unit: 10/10 – Leadership, creativity, and shutdown ability.
  • Midfield: 10/10 – A mix of brute strength, outside pace, and unmatched experience.
  • Forward Line: 10/10 – Dynamic, versatile, and capable of big-game heroics.
  • Overall: 10/10 – This is a premiership-worthy side that no other team would want to face.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

ITCHY EYEBALLS said:
He certainly can!!! :p

Backline (B, HB)​

  • B: Joel Jeffrey, Alex Pearce (VC), Josh Sinn
    • Alex Pearce (VC) leads a formidable defensive unit with elite intercepting and leadership skills. He's capable of shutting down the competition's best forwards.
    • Joel Jeffrey adds flair and versatility as a hybrid defender who can take intercept marks and rebound effectively.
    • Josh Sinn brings exceptional speed and kicking efficiency, making him a perfect outlet under pressure.
    • Verdict: This backline is perfectly balanced with leadership, defensive strength, and rebound run.
  • HB: Keidean Coleman, Sam De Koning, Brayden Maynard
    • Keidean Coleman is one of the most dangerous attacking half-back flankers in the competition, offering elite ball use and line-breaking speed.
    • Sam De Koning is a premier young key defender, capable of nullifying tall forwards while also providing intercept marking.
    • Brayden Maynard’s toughness and ability to shut down opponents make him a perfect complement to the more creative defenders.
    • Verdict: This half-back line can dominate games with toughness, creativity, and elite ball movement.

Midfield (C, FOLL, I/C)​

  • C: Jeremy Sharp, Adam Cerra, Liam Henry
    • Adam Cerra anchors this midfield with his class, composure, and elite ball use.
    • Liam Henry provides speed, agility, and game-breaking ability on the outside, ensuring the midfield can run and spread effectively.
    • Jeremy Sharp is the ultimate endurance athlete, running both ways and ensuring a relentless work rate over four quarters.
    • Verdict: This midfield offers the perfect mix of inside strength and outside pace.
  • FOLL: Marc Pittonet, Patrick Cripps (C), Scott Pendlebury
    • Patrick Cripps (C) is the ultimate midfield leader, combining brute strength, contested dominance, and a never-say-die attitude.
    • Scott Pendlebury adds unmatched poise, experience, and vision, making this midfield one of the smartest in the competition.
    • Marc Pittonet might not be the flashiest ruckman, but he provides a consistent and reliable presence in the hit-outs, feeding the elite on-ballers effectively.
    • Verdict: This on-ball brigade is elite, with Cripps and Pendlebury forming a combination that few midfields could match.
  • I/C: Jack Bowes, Alex Cincotta, Jack Silvagni, Brandon Zerk-Thatcher
    • Jack Bowes is a utility weapon who can slot into defense, midfield, or forward, offering flexibility.
    • Alex Cincotta’s work ethic and role-playing ability make him a perfect depth player who can perform anywhere on the field.
    • Jack Silvagni is a Swiss army knife, capable of impacting as a forward, ruck relief, or midfielder.
    • Brandon Zerk-Thatcher provides excellent key defensive depth and versatility.
    • Verdict: A versatile bench capable of plugging any gaps and maintaining high performance.

Forward Line (HF, F)​

  • HF: Jordan De Goey, Nick Larkey, Cam Rayner
    • Jordan De Goey is the x-factor. He’s unstoppable when at his best, capable of breaking games open in the midfield or forward.
    • Nick Larkey is a key forward who delivers consistently with elite contested marking and goal-kicking accuracy.
    • Cam Rayner provides explosive power, creativity, and the ability to win games with moments of brilliance.
    • Verdict: This half-forward line is dynamic, powerful, and packed with goal-scoring potential.
  • F: Liam Baker, Josh Treacy, Jamie Elliott
    • Liam Baker is the ultimate pressure forward, relentless in creating turnovers and producing clutch moments in front of goal.
    • Josh Treacy adds a strong, competitive key forward presence, capable of creating contests and finishing opportunities.
    • Jamie Elliott is a proven match-winner with elite goal sense and the ability to perform in big moments.
    • Verdict: A clinical and versatile forward line that thrives under pressure and delivers in key moments.

Substitute​

  • SUB: Matt Cottrell
    • Matt Cottrell is the perfect impact player to bring on late in games. His running capacity, energy, and ability to influence contests make him a game-changer in the dying stages.

Team Strengths​

  1. Elite Leadership and Experience: With Cripps, Pendlebury, and Pearce, this team has the on-field leadership to thrive in any situation.
  2. Versatility Across the Ground: Players like De Goey, Silvagni, Baker, and Bowes ensure adaptability to any scenario.
  3. Dynamic Forward Line: A mix of power, precision, and pressure makes this forward line impossible to stop.
  4. Rock-Solid Defense: A perfect combination of intercept marking, shutdown defenders, and attacking rebound makes the backline impenetrable.
  5. Midfield Class and Grit: Cripps and Pendlebury are as good as it gets, supported by excellent wingmen and a reliable ruck.

Weaknesses​

None! Every part of this team is balanced, elite, and built to perform under pressure.

Final Rating​

  • Defensive Unit: 10/10 – Leadership, creativity, and shutdown ability.
  • Midfield: 10/10 – A mix of brute strength, outside pace, and unmatched experience.
  • Forward Line: 10/10 – Dynamic, versatile, and capable of big-game heroics.
  • Overall: 10/10 – This is a premiership-worthy side that no other team would want to face.
Click to expand...
Somehow I ended up with Isaac Rankine in my fwd line - I like this god!

Praise be!
lisa lisa yes GIF
 
Most of you are assessing your own team so prob a good idea I do the same...


1737172941337.png


BACKS
Bailey Williams (27 yo, 151 games)
Liam Jones ( 33 yo, 200 games)
Tom Stewart (31 yo, 171 games)

A very experienced back line led by the ever impressive Tom Stewart...

Tom has earned 5 All Australian jumpers and was a valuable member of the 2022 premiership team. He provides toughness, drive, poise... can move into the midfield if required.

Liam's courage, marking and spoiling are key components of this underrated defender's game. While 33 years old, he hasn't yet shown any signs of slowing down. The important thing here is he has only played 200 games which isn't much for someone approaching his 15th season. Sometimes it's important to determine a player's expiry date by considering how many games they have played (toll on body) rather than how old they are.

Bailey's versatility is an underrated part of his game. Last season he spent more time in the midfield but he has proven over multiple seasons he is a reliable rebounder. Coming off his best season (IMO), he finished 9th in the best and fairest although surprisingly he did finish 5th in 2021 when his team made the grand final.

HALF BACKS
Rory Laird (31 yo, 247 games)
Jake Lever (28 yo, 178 games)
Caleb Daniel (28 yo, 192 games)

Another experienced half back line comprising of a couple of versatile players...

Rory is the most accomplished of the trio with three best and fairests and two All Australian jumpers. While he plays predominately in the midfield for his team, he did earn his two All Australian honours occupying positions in the back line in 2017 & 2018.

Jake will form a reliable key defensive partnership with Liam Jones and both have similar styles which isn't necessarily a bad thing. He won All Australian honours in a premiership year and was a b2b2b representative in the 22 under 22 teams between 2015 & 2017.

Caleb has been the one of the most effective kicks of the footy since making his debut in 2015. His CV includes a premiership, best and fairest and All Australian jumper. He finished second in the 2016 Rising Star and he has had the pleasure of riding on a gorilla's back. A new team for Caleb in 2025 might reignite his career... although I don't necessarily agree he should have needed to reignite his career... Why did he fall out of favour at the Dogs???

Riding Gorillas with Jarrad Roughead
1737174440061.png

CENTRES
Jaspa Fletcher (20 yo, 41 games)
Clayton Oliver (27 yo, 183 games)
Nathan O'Driscoll (22 yo, 24 games)

Our least experienced line but the exciting part here is I genuinely expect all three players to improve of their 2024 season...

Jaspa is entering his third season in the competition after arriving in the system as a highly rated father/son prospect. He has a bit of pace which in important for our team and the premiership player certainly has clean hands. Surprisingly he is yet to record 20 possessions in a match... that's gonna change in 2025.

Clayton is possibly the biggest high risk / high reward selections in the draft. His CV includes one premiership 2x AFLCA player of the year, 3x All Australian jumpers, 4a best and fairests, 2x Lou Richards medals and many more. 2024 aside, he was one of the best players in the comp and is certainly capable of returning to that elite status.

Nathan is an exciting prospect. He hasn't proven much yet but IMO is capable of turning into a very handy player. Despite only playing 24 games, his highlights reel is pretty impressive. There's no denying he has a tremendous work rate and is rated elite in running. He has strong hands as well which allows him to play in defence as required which he did at the beginning of his career.

HALF FORWARDS
Stephen Coniglio (31 yo, 217 games)
Peter Wright (28 yo, 133 games)
Matt Kennedy (27 yo, 118 games)

Another experienced line who all offer something different...

Stephen is captain of his team and has been a star for many seasons. He does his best work in the midfield but has certainly shown he is more than capable hitting the scoreboard with 120 goals. His 2024 season failed to reach the heights of his 2023 season but that's because he was battling injury.

Peter is an important member of the team as he provides a back up option to Grundy in the ruck. A best and fairest winner in 2022, he hasn't reached those same heights in recent years but he has shown on his day he is more than capable of kicking a bag of goals. It would be difficult to motivate yourself playing for a rabble like Essendon & I am confident his motivation to play for us will result in him being a consistent strong marking, high impact goal kicker.

Matt offers plenty to this team. Not only is he a tough nut capable of impacting in the middle of the ground and on the scoreboard, his good looks will keep keep the women away from Clayton Oliver which will allow Clayton to return to his elite form in 2025. Now at his third club in 2025, you can expect him to continue averaging around 20 disposals & 4 tackles per game while contributing to the scoreboard with a few snags.

FORWARDS
Jack Higgins (25 yo, 122 games)
Tom Lynch (32 yo, 220 games)
Bailey Fritsch (28 yo, 149 games)

Experience is a common theme with this team and our fwd line is no exception...

Jack is his team's leading goal kicker in the past two seasons. His CV includes goal of the year in 2018 & a Morrish Medal in 2017. His consistency is pretty important having averaged 1.5 goals per in the past four years. His best footy IMO is still ahead of him.

Tom has only played four matches in each of the past two seasons. It's for this reason he was able to slide to a mid round selection. There's no denying he has an impressive CV... 2x premierships, All Australian, 3x best and fairests, 6x club leading goal kicker. He has twice averaged three goals per match and IMO injury (and not age) is the only thing holding him back.

Bailey is the star of our fwd line. A pest, sure... But he's an out and out star. The premiership player has been his club's leading goal kicker for the past five seasons and he has the record of kicking the most goals in a grand final since the 1990s.

RUCKS
Brodie Grundy (30 yo, 216 games)
Isaac Heeney (28 yo, 201 games)
Jack Viney (30 yo, 219 games)

This midfield group are of a similar vintage in terms of age and games played. All are rated elite for their work rate by position. The dominant ruck craft of Grundy combined with the skill of Heeney and toughness of Viney makes this ruck unit one of the very best in the competition...

Brodie is quite clearly the second best active ruckman if every player was ranked on what they have produced in their career. 2x All Australian jumpers, 2x best and fairests, 2018 player of the year. Now at his third club, we're expecting Brodie to outperform his 2024 season due to having Dean Cox as his coach. He still has a bit left in the tank and we're expecting him to have his best season since 2021.

Isaac's 2024 season was simply outstanding earning his first best and fairest and second All Australian jumper. His AFL journey began with a plethora of awards including AFLPA best first year player (2015), AFLCA best young player (2016) and a couple of representations in the 22under22 team. He is extremely versatile with his ability to dominant in the air and at ground level. He is equally dominant as a forward as he is in the midfield. I'm surprised he lasted until pick 14 as we rated him a top five player.

Jack will thrive in this midfield set up having played alongside Clayton for years and also having some experience playing under the shoulders of Grundy. His courage, hard nut edge will complement this midfield beautifully. The premiership player & former club captain is a 2x best and fairest winner has strung together three injury free seasons after being hampered by niggling injuries previously. His tackling, pressure, clearance work and ball winning ability will propel this team to great heights.

BENCH
Sam Frost (35 yo, Australian actress)
Xavier Duursma (24 yo, 88 games)
Cam Mackenzie (20 yo, 34 games)
Nick Haynes (32 yo, 211 games)
Jack Gunston (33 yo, 260 games)

The respective surnames of our five bench players sums up our team overall...
****ing Deadly Marking, Handballing & Goalkicking...

Sam is one of our country's sexiest actresses. Hailing from Ferntree Gully, the former winner of The Bachelor will have all tongues wagging in the clubrooms after the match. She is expected to be very popular among the playing group at Mad Monday.

Xavier is an interesting player in that he isn't elite in any one category but he doesn't appear to have any weaknesses. A player like this is needed in every team. A couple of his biggest strengths are his athleticism and versatility. He is a run and carry player capable of running goal. Primarily we will be playing him on the wing.

Cam is another athletic player who will rotate through the midfield, on the wing and the occasional stint in the fwd line. He is rated elite for disposal efficiency and IMO he has a very bright season. He only missed the 2024 finals campaign due to a hamstring injury he suffered in the final H & A match. Entering his third season, the former #7 draft pick is my tip to be our team's most improved player in 2025.

Nick offers experience and will provide great coverage for our three bid bodied rebounding defenders. With Stewart, Laird and Williams all capable of playing through the midfield, Hayes can easily slot into a defensive position where his intercept marking and rebounding will be a very welcome addition to our team.

Jack is a 3x premiership player, All Australian representative and club best and fairest. He has been a very reliable goal kicker for over a decade. It's incredible to think a player who averaged 1.6 goals per game last season lasted all the way until the very last round. He has shown an ability to player as an undersized KPF so he will be a handy back up to Lynch and Wright.
 
slider95 said:
Most of you are assessing your own team so prob a good idea I do the same...


View attachment 2206333


BACKS
Bailey Williams (27 yo, 151 games)
Liam Jones ( 33 yo, 200 games)
Tom Stewart (31 yo, 171 games)

A very experienced back line led by the ever impressive Tom Stewart...

Tom has earned 5 All Australian jumpers and was a valuable member of the 2022 premiership team. He provides toughness, drive, poise... can move into the midfield if required.

Liam's courage, marking and spoiling are key components of this underrated defender's game. While 33 years old, he hasn't yet shown any signs of slowing down. The important thing here is he has only played 200 games which isn't much for someone approaching his 15th season. Sometimes it's important to determine a player's expiry date by considering how many games they have played (toll on body) rather than how old they are.

Bailey's versatility is an underrated part of his game. Last season he spent more time in the midfield but he has proven over multiple seasons he is a reliable rebounder. Coming off his best season (IMO), he finished 9th in the best and fairest although surprisingly he did finish 5th in 2021 when his team made the grand final.

HALF BACKS
Rory Laird (31 yo, 247 games)
Jake Lever (28 yo, 178 games)
Caleb Daniel (28 yo, 192 games)

Another experienced half back line comprising of a couple of versatile players...

Rory is the most accomplished of the trio with three best and fairests and two All Australian jumpers. While he plays predominately in the midfield for his team, he did earn his two All Australian honours occupying positions in the back line in 2017 & 2018.

Jake will form a reliable key defensive partnership with Liam Jones and both have similar styles which isn't necessarily a bad thing. He won All Australian honours in a premiership year and was a b2b2b representative in the 22 under 22 teams between 2015 & 2017.

Caleb has been the one of the most effective kicks of the footy since making his debut in 2015. His CV includes a premiership, best and fairest and All Australian jumper. He finished second in the 2016 Rising Star and he has had the pleasure of riding on a gorilla's back. A new team for Caleb in 2025 might reignite his career... although I don't necessarily agree he should have needed to reignite his career... Why did he fall out of favour at the Dogs???

Riding Gorillas with Jarrad Roughead
View attachment 2206361

CENTRES
Jaspa Fletcher (20 yo, 41 games)
Clayton Oliver (27 yo, 183 games)
Nathan O'Driscoll (22 yo, 24 games)

Our least experienced line but the exciting part here is I genuinely expect all three players to improve of their 2024 season...

Jaspa is entering his third season in the competition after arriving in the system as a highly rated father/son prospect. He has a bit of pace which in important for our team and the premiership player certainly has clean hands. Surprisingly he is yet to record 20 possessions in a match... that's gonna change in 2025.

Clayton is possibly the biggest high risk / high reward selections in the draft. His CV includes one premiership 2x AFLCA player of the year, 3x All Australian jumpers, 4a best and fairests, 2x Lou Richards medals and many more. 2024 aside, he was one of the best players in the comp and is certainly capable of returning to that elite status.

Nathan is an exciting prospect. He hasn't proven much yet but IMO is capable of turning into a very handy player. Despite only playing 24 games, his highlights reel is pretty impressive. There's no denying he has a tremendous work rate and is rated elite in running. He has strong hands as well which allows him to play in defence as required which he did at the beginning of his career.

HALF FORWARDS
Stephen Coniglio (31 yo, 217 games)
Peter Wright (28 yo, 133 games)
Matt Kennedy (27 yo, 118 games)

Another experienced line who all offer something different...

Stephen is captain of his team and has been a star for many seasons. He does his best work in the midfield but has certainly shown he is more than capable hitting the scoreboard with 120 goals. His 2024 season failed to reach the heights of his 2023 season but that's because he was battling injury.

Peter is an important member of the team as he provides a back up option to Grundy in the ruck. A best and fairest winner in 2022, he hasn't reached those same heights in recent years but he has shown on his day he is more than capable of kicking a bag of goals. It would be difficult to motivate yourself playing for a rabble like Essendon & I am confident his motivation to play for us will result in him being a consistent strong marking, high impact goal kicker.

Matt offers plenty to this team. Not only is he a tough nut capable of impacting in the middle of the ground and on the scoreboard, his good looks will keep keep the women away from Clayton Oliver which will allow Clayton to return to his elite form in 2025. Now at his third club in 2025, you can expect him to continue averaging around 20 disposals & 4 tackles per game while contributing to the scoreboard with a few snags.

FORWARDS
Jack Higgins (25 yo, 122 games)
Tom Lynch (32 yo, 220 games)
Bailey Fritsch (28 yo, 149 games)

Experience is a common theme with this team and our fwd line is no exception...

Jack is his team's leading goal kicker in the past two seasons. His CV includes goal of the year in 2018 & a Morrish Medal in 2017. His consistency is pretty important having averaged 1.5 goals per in the past four years. His best footy IMO is still ahead of him.

Tom has only played four matches in each of the past two seasons. It's for this reason he was able to slide to a mid round selection. There's no denying he has an impressive CV... 2x premierships, All Australian, 3x best and fairests, 6x club leading goal kicker. He has twice averaged three goals per match and IMO injury (and not age) is the only thing holding him back.

Bailey is the star of our fwd line. A pest, sure... But he's an out and out star. The premiership player has been his club's leading goal kicker for the past five seasons and he has the record of kicking the most goals in a grand final since the 1990s.

RUCKS
Brodie Grundy (30 yo, 216 games)
Isaac Heeney (28 yo, 201 games)
Jack Viney (30 yo, 219 games)

This midfield group are of a similar vintage in terms of age and games played. All are rated elite for their work rate by position. The dominant ruck craft of Grundy combined with the skill of Heeney and toughness of Viney makes this ruck unit one of the very best in the competition...

Brodie is quite clearly the second best active ruckman if every player was ranked on what they have produced in their career. 2x All Australian jumpers, 2x best and fairests, 2018 player of the year. Now at his third club, we're expecting Brodie to outperform his 2024 season due to having Dean Cox as his coach. He still has a bit left in the tank and we're expecting him to have his best season since 2021.

Isaac's 2024 season was simply outstanding earning his first best and fairest and second All Australian jumper. His AFL journey began with a plethora of awards including AFLPA best first year player (2015), AFLCA best young player (2016) and a couple of representations in the 22under22 team. He is extremely versatile with his ability to dominant in the air and at ground level. He is equally dominant as a forward as he is in the midfield. I'm surprised he lasted until pick 14 as we rated him a top five player.

Jack will thrive in this midfield set up having played alongside Clayton for years and also having some experience playing under the shoulders of Grundy. His courage, hard nut edge will complement this midfield beautifully. The premiership player & former club captain is a 2x best and fairest winner has strung together three injury free seasons after being hampered by niggling injuries previously. His tackling, pressure, clearance work and ball winning ability will propel this team to great heights.

BENCH
Sam Frost (35 yo, Australian actress)
Xavier Duursma (24 yo, 88 games)
Cam Mackenzie (20 yo, 34 games)
Nick Haynes (32 yo, 211 games)
Jack Gunston (33 yo, 260 games)

The respective surnames of our five bench players sums up our team overall...
****ing Deadly Marking, Handballing & Goalkicking...

Sam is one of our country's sexiest actresses. Hailing from Ferntree Gully, the former winner of The Bachelor will have all tongues wagging in the clubrooms after the match. She is expected to be very popular among the playing group at Mad Monday.

Xavier is an interesting player in that he isn't elite in any one category but he doesn't appear to have any weaknesses. A player like this is needed in every team. A couple of his biggest strengths are his athleticism and versatility. He is a run and carry player capable of running goal. Primarily we will be playing him on the wing.

Cam is another athletic player who will rotate through the midfield, on the wing and the occasional stint in the fwd line. He is rated elite for disposal efficiency and IMO he has a very bright season. He only missed the 2024 finals campaign due to a hamstring injury he suffered in the final H & A match. Entering his third season, the former #7 draft pick is my tip to be our team's most improved player in 2025.

Nick offers experience and will provide great coverage for our three bid bodied rebounding defenders. With Stewart, Laird and Williams all capable of playing through the midfield, Hayes can easily slot into a defensive position where his intercept marking and rebounding will be a very welcome addition to our team.

Jack is a 3x premiership player, All Australian representative and club best and fairest. He has been a very reliable goal kicker for over a decade. It's incredible to think a player who averaged 1.6 goals per game last season lasted all the way until the very last round. He has shown an ability to player as an undersized KPF so he will be a handy back up to Lynch and Wright.
Click to expand...

You can add this to your team on the presentation thread if you want. Just edit it in.
 
Here's my Chat GPT analysis, with an example of how it can be manipulated.

Share
User

You said:​

Please analyse my AFL team for a competition I am participating in.

ChatGPT said:​


I'd be happy to analyze your AFL team! Please provide the following details:
  1. Team List: List all players in your team, including positions and any relevant designations (captain, vice-captain, etc.).
  2. Competition Rules: Are there any unique scoring rules, salary cap limits, or team composition requirements for this competition?
  3. Your Strategy: Are you aiming for consistent performers, high-risk/high-reward players, or a mix of both?
  4. Competitor Insights (if available): What are some trends or common picks in your competition?
Once I have these details, I can offer a detailed analysis and recommendations!

4o

You said:​

I am looking at an overall rating of the team for immediate success, long term success and quality of player, plus balance of the side.

ChatGPT said:​


Got it! To provide a comprehensive analysis of your AFL team’s immediate success, long-term potential, quality of players, and balance, please share the following details:

1. Team Composition​

  • Player names, positions (e.g., forwards, midfielders, defenders, ruck), and clubs.
  • Captain and vice-captain (if applicable).
  • Are these players part of a specific fantasy format (e.g., AFL Fantasy, SuperCoach), or are we looking at real-world AFL performance?

2. Immediate Success​

  • Are you prioritizing a strong start to the season, or do you want consistency throughout the year?
  • Include known injury statuses or availability of players.

3. Long-Term Success​

  • Do you have young, developing players or seasoned veterans?
  • Any future picks or players who might come into their prime later?

4. Quality of Players​

  • Are they high performers in the AFL (e.g., Brownlow contenders, All-Australians)?
  • How do they rank statistically (disposals, marks, goals, tackles, etc.)?

5. Balance of the Side​

  • Does your team have a good mix of roles (inside/outside mids, key forwards, intercept defenders, etc.)?
  • Are there any glaring weaknesses in depth or position?
Once you provide this, I’ll analyze and rate your team comprehensively!

4o

You said:​

B: Nathan Broad, Harris Andrews, Lachie JonesHB: Miles Bergman, Rory Lobb, Reuben GinbeyC: Ed Langdon, Ollie Wines, Sam DochertyHF: Zac Bailey, Aaron Naughton, Darcy Byrne-JonesFor: Tom Papley, Aaron Cadman, Sam Powell-PepperFoll: Toby Nankervis, Hayden Young, Adam TreloarInt: Mark Blicavs, James Aish, Tom Sparrow, Finn MaginnessSub: Oisin Mullin

ChatGPT said:​


AFL Team Analysis: Strengths and Weaknesses​

1. Immediate Success​

Rating: 6.5/10
  • Strengths:
    • Reliable midfield core with proven performers like Ollie Wines, Sam Docherty, and Adam Treloar, who should deliver consistent results.
    • Forward line has dangerous players like Tom Papley (goal-scoring threat) and Aaron Naughton (aerial dominance).
    • Versatile contributors in Mark Blicavs (utility) and Sam Powell-Pepper, who can impact games physically.
    • Harris Andrews as a defensive anchor offers strong leadership and intercept marking.
  • Weaknesses:
    • The backline lacks standout, consistent rebounders. Nathan Broad and Reuben Ginbey may provide defensive solidity but won't dominate.
    • Forward depth beyond Papley and Naughton is limited, with Aaron Cadman being unproven.
    • The ruck (Toby Nankervis) is serviceable but not elite compared to higher-tier rucks in the AFL.

2. Long-Term Success​

Rating: 7.5/10
  • Strengths:
    • Aaron Cadman, Reuben Ginbey, and Finn Maginness offer significant potential for growth. If developed well, they could become long-term stars.
    • Miles Bergman and Zac Bailey are young players showing promise in their respective roles.
    • Oisin Mullin, as a sub, adds upside if his skill set transitions well to AFL-level competition.
  • Weaknesses:
    • Several core players like Adam Treloar, Toby Nankervis, and Mark Blicavs are closer to the latter stages of their careers.
    • A lot rides on Aaron Cadman’s development to anchor the forward line in the future.
    • Midfield depth for the long term isn’t as promising without more young, emerging players.

3. Quality of Players​

Rating: 7/10
  • High-Quality Performers:
    • Ollie Wines (Brownlow winner) and Sam Docherty (consistent and versatile midfielder/defender) are elite contributors.
    • Harris Andrews is an All-Australian-caliber defender.
    • Tom Papley is a proven match-winner in the forward line.
  • Areas of Concern:
    • Role players like Ed Langdon, Lachie Jones, and James Aish are valuable but don’t add star power.
    • A reliance on developing talent (Reuben Ginbey, Aaron Cadman) for future success rather than immediate impact.

4. Balance of the Side​

Rating: 6/10
  • Strengths:
    • Good versatility with players like Mark Blicavs, Miles Bergman, and Sam Powell-Pepper capable of filling multiple roles.
    • A midfield with outside run (Ed Langdon) and inside grunt (Ollie Wines, Adam Treloar).
  • Weaknesses:
    • The forward line lacks depth beyond key figures (Papley, Naughton). If they’re out of form or injured, goal-kicking options are scarce.
    • The backline leans defensive without a clear attacking rebounder to generate offensive chains.
    • Toby Nankervis is the sole ruck option without backup or flexibility in case of injury.

Summary of Ratings:​

  • Immediate Success: 6.5/10
  • Long-Term Success: 7.5/10
  • Quality of Players: 7/10
  • Balance of the Side: 6/10
  • Overall Rating: 6.75/10

Suggestions for Improvement:​

  1. Strengthen the Forward Line: Add a proven, consistent second forward option to complement Papley and Naughton.
  2. Develop Young Talent: Invest in developing Ginbey, Bailey, and Cadman, as they are the future cornerstones of the team.
  3. Enhance Backline Balance: Look for a rebounding defender to add dynamism to the defensive unit.
  4. Add Ruck Depth: Consider a backup ruck option to support or rotate with Nankervis.
This team has a solid foundation and potential for long-term growth but may struggle against stronger sides in the short term due to positional imbalances and a lack of proven depth in key areas.

4o

You said:​

Rory Lobb and Mark Blicavs are known back up ruckmen

ChatGPT said:​


Good point! Both Rory Lobb and Mark Blicavs are versatile players who can step into the ruck role when needed. Here’s how that affects the analysis:

Updated Analysis: Ruck Depth and Flexibility​

Immediate Success​

  • Toby Nankervis remains the primary ruckman, but having Rory Lobb and Mark Blicavsas backup rucks is a significant advantage.
    • Rory Lobb can act as a second ruck while still contributing as a forward, providing flexibility in match strategies.
    • Mark Blicavs’ versatility across midfield, defense, and ruck makes him a key utility who can fill gaps depending on injuries or team needs.

Balance of the Side​

  • The ruck situation is much stronger than initially thought. With three capable ruck options:
    • There’s coverage for injuries or form slumps.
    • It offers tactical flexibility to shift Lobb or Blicavs into the ruck, allowing Nankervis to rest while maintaining strong contest work around the ground.

Adjusted Ratings:​

  • Immediate Success: 7/10 (up from 6.5) – The improved depth and versatility make the team more competitive in the short term.
  • Balance of the Side: 6.5/10 (up from 6) – The presence of dual-position players like Blicavs and Lobb strengthens structural balance.
This adjustment makes your side better equipped for the rigors of a full season and adds an element of unpredictability to your tactics. The other areas (e.g., forward depth, rebounding defenders) remain key improvement points.

4o
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

YeoShuey said:
BlueTongue Look above. Had to update as this is too good to NOT use :p

The spelling doesn't even bother me on the football LOL
Click to expand...
Didn't take you long! I regen'd mine about 30 times and still had to combine 2 images and even then i had to clone stamp stuff out. But it DID get my jumper design Spot on.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Competitions Make Your Own Team - Carlton Board AFL Player Draft Game

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top