Swanzforeva
Senior List
- May 28, 2013
- 248
- 45
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Banned
- #101
But they are the best 4-8 team ever
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Heath Shaw
- Thread starter Swanhotels
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- May 28, 2013
- 25,883
- 28,020
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Seattle Seahawks
Great - swap him for Hogan?
The Finger
Premiership Player
- Banned
- #103
No chance.
Swanhotels
Club Legend
- Nov 30, 2011
- 2,006
- 677
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #104
that makes no sense.
Swanhotels
Club Legend
- Nov 30, 2011
- 2,006
- 677
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #105
that makes no sense.
Swanhotels
Club Legend
- Nov 30, 2011
- 2,006
- 677
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #106
haha whoops, you know what I meant.
Swanhotels
Club Legend
- Nov 30, 2011
- 2,006
- 677
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #107
and no i wont get off the pipe.
- May 28, 2013
- 25,883
- 28,020
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Seattle Seahawks
I would imagine this happens to you a fair bit.
Swanhotels
Club Legend
- Nov 30, 2011
- 2,006
- 677
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #109
Black is the next Wayne Carey. Get around him!
Okay first of all I didn't hear what Cam Mooney said, but from what I understand, this rumour about Shaw was started by Cam based on the rumours going round about the Rat Pack not liking Bucks's changes, and has no basis from any insider knowledge.
Secondly, even if Shaw wanted out, as he is under contract and is a required player, Collingwood are under no obligation to trade him, just ask Mitch Brown from West Coast. Shaw wouldn't have the option of going into the draft, nor is he a free agent until his contract is up. Therefore if another club wanted Shaw, they would need to make a very good offer, probably what people on here would consider overs, in order to get him, particularly a team like Sydney who already have a strong list which will go close to getting another premiership this year.
Because quite simply if Collingwood didn't like the offer they can simply say no and Shaw's only options would be play for Collingwood or sit out of the game for 2 years.
Secondly, even if Shaw wanted out, as he is under contract and is a required player, Collingwood are under no obligation to trade him, just ask Mitch Brown from West Coast. Shaw wouldn't have the option of going into the draft, nor is he a free agent until his contract is up. Therefore if another club wanted Shaw, they would need to make a very good offer, probably what people on here would consider overs, in order to get him, particularly a team like Sydney who already have a strong list which will go close to getting another premiership this year.
Because quite simply if Collingwood didn't like the offer they can simply say no and Shaw's only options would be play for Collingwood or sit out of the game for 2 years.
Please stop. Please.
Agreed. Embarrassing strawman.
On topic, I'd take Heath Shaw at the Swans in a heartbeat, but as many have said, it's extremely unlikely to happen. The only way it would happen is if he genuinely wants to go, and Buckley genuinely wants him gone. In that scenario, our first rounder would do it.
On the other topic, Black has been better than Reid this year. Reid is definitely still worth more though. Younger, playing on better defenders, with greater focus from the opposition, and with greater latent physical attributes. Reid's form has been disappointing this year, but he's not the first young KPP to plateau in development for a bit before finally breaking out, and he certainly won't be the last.
swansfan51
Brownlow Medallist
- Jun 3, 2007
- 12,602
- 21,357
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- The Exers
If we're targeting more brothers Bret Goodes would have been the better option. Having a similar year to Shaw and would have been available very cheaply.
Don't want Shaw at the price we'd need to pay. If he was three years younger it'd be a different story.
2nd rounder.
2nd rounder.
How old is he?
He'd be 28 before the start of next year. I'd want him if it was on the cheap.
KissKiss
Norm Smith Medallist
- Nov 26, 2012
- 8,583
- 10,871
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
They were talking last night about Shaw+Brown (or Ben Ried) being offered to GWS. That way Shaw got out of Collingwood to Sydney with his brother and also gave GWS the mature backman they need.
Swanhotels
Club Legend
- Nov 30, 2011
- 2,006
- 677
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #119
Or we could just bend over and get pumped in the bot bot. ridic trade. Mumford and Swans first rounder for Shaw is more on the mark Throwing in a 21 year old Key forward with a gun ruckman is lunacy.
Think you get Shaw and Collingwoods 1st rd pick for Mumford and Reid, Swans has an abundance of tall forwards and Reid can't get a game at the moment!
Swanhotels
Club Legend
- Nov 30, 2011
- 2,006
- 677
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #121
Reid has been injured and is a massive part of the Swans future, apart from Reid we have Tippett and thats it for tall forwards. What you are suggesting is simply daylight robbery..
Your prepared to give Mumford and your 1st rd for Shaw instead of reid and getting a first rd from Collingwood. ?
That would make Reid worth 2x 1st rd picks!! Really!! you rate him higher than most would.
Swanhotels
Club Legend
- Nov 30, 2011
- 2,006
- 677
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #123
mmm maybe id give our second round pick but I do rate Reid very highly.
Spin it how you like, but Collingwood aren't getting Mumford and Reid for a defender past his best and some hit and miss first rounder.
Give me a break.
