Review Good/Bad/Ugly vs Richmond, R5 2022

[IntelligentFish]

Here comes another ban. I’ve accidentally posted something on the Port Board

For a team that brags about toughness, their supporters are remarkably fragile.

 

[Bearded Clam]

Hard marker, sure he had a couple of fumbles but his good far far outweighed his bad.

22 Disposals, 18 kicks, 4 handballs, 9 Marks, 535m gained, 6 intercepts, 2 score involvements, 76.9% Disposal efficiency, 100% time on ground.

its understandable that a few cant stand frampton.. his start to last year was deplorable.

but its hard to argue that he hasnt taken the bull by the horns to take on this new role in defense.
apart from a fumble or two and a bad handpass at the end he was pretty solid today. he’s probably our most reliable by foot back there. did some great defensive punches and gained some massive mileage for the team with over 500m.

people need to remember this is only his 5th game in defence at AFL level after only transitioning from forward to defence in the SANFL halfway through last year.

what does everyone expect ffs?.. that he’s somehow gotta be peak Talia already?

 

[CrowBloke]

That's the most immensely satisfying win we've had for ages.

That's the most immensely satisfying win we've had, since the Showdown, R3.

But still a veryvery good win.

 

[cleanhands]

For a team that brags about toughness, their supporters are remarkably fragile.

That’s the old Port not the plastic one trying to ride on their coattails

 

[DJ75]

Yeah Frampton had 22 disposals but he also had 10 turnovers, so he was almost better off not getting the ball

How do you have 76% disposal efficiency if nearly half your disposals are turnovers?

 

[cleanhands]

How do you have 76% disposal efficiency if nearly half your disposals are turnovers?

Not being good at maths

 

[Jinglebells32]

its understandable that a few cant stand frampton.. his start to last year was deplorable.

but its hard to argue that he hasnt taken the bull by the horns to take on this new role in defense.
apart from a fumble or two and a bad handpass at the end he was pretty solid today. he’s probably our most reliable by foot back there. did some great defensive punches and gained some massive mileage for the team with over 500m.

people need to remember this is only his 5th game in defence at AFL level after only transitioning from forward to defence in the SANFL halfway through last year.

what does everyone expect ffs?.. that he’s somehow gotta be peak Talia already?

I'm sure they are the same supporters that wrote Nathan Bock off after a few poor games as a forward

 

[jamesclean]

I think we can all agree that we have no idea how stats are measured and that they could quite well be cooked, it's just a bunch of nerds behind a computer. Like us.

 

[hey shorty]

How do you have 76% disposal efficiency if nearly half your disposals are turnovers?

An effective disposal according to CD is 40+ metres to a break even contest

 

[Noidnadroj]

Tigers get on top in the third quarter … umpires say ‘Hold my beer’. Full strength Adel except for Seedsman. 32-13 in free kicks and you kicked 12-1 from set shots. It’s nice to win but I’d probably cool the celebrations - wouldn’t want to celebrate too early like in GF week of 2017 when Tex saved a seat on the plane for the cup


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Scorpus]

How do you have 76% disposal efficiency if nearly half your disposals are turnovers?

It's a stupid system

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Yep

Crouch is out of step with the whole team. Takes forever then floats up a lob wedge

He was v lucky to play at all today , definitely was at his worst against Essendon. Still prefer to give Hately his role for now

 

[hey shorty]

Tigers get on top in the third quarter … umpires say ‘Hold my beer’. Full strength Adel except for Seedsman. 32-13 in free kicks and you kicked 12-1 from set shots. It’s nice to win but I’d probably cool the celebrations - wouldn’t want to celebrate too early like in GF week of 2017


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Probably should've been 40 frees if they umpired well.

Salty boy

 

[40porpoise]

I particularly liked how we stuck with Sloane not having a centre bounce attendance, even when the game got tight.

Berry was OK not good, but nice to know we backed him in

 

[dplggr47]

How do you have 76% disposal efficiency if nearly half your disposals are turnovers?

Probably didn't take full possession on some of those turnovers.

 

[Geoffa32]

This game (Aussie Rules) is hard to quantify.



On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[dogs105]

You'll have to ask Champion Data about that

View attachment 1375133

Turned it over without a disposal perhaps?

 

[the universal]

Tigers get on top in the third quarter … umpires say ‘Hold my beer’. Full strength Adel except for Seedsman. 32-13 in free kicks and you kicked 12-1 from set shots. It’s nice to win but I’d probably cool the celebrations - wouldn’t want to celebrate too early like in GF week of 2017 when Tex saved a seat on the plane for the cup


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

You should really be accounting for a team of kids if you're a finals contender - umpires or no umpires.

 

[CrowsB4hoes]

Imagine being so salty about another loss you come on to the victors board to ask them not to celebrate too hard.

 

[Mutineer]

its understandable that a few cant stand frampton.. his start to last year was deplorable.

but its hard to argue that he hasnt taken the bull by the horns to take on this new role in defense.
apart from a fumble or two and a bad handpass at the end he was pretty solid today. he’s probably our most reliable by foot back there. did some great defensive punches and gained some massive mileage for the team with over 500m.

people need to remember this is only his 5th game in defence at AFL level after only transitioning from forward to defence in the SANFL halfway through last year.

what does everyone expect ffs?.. that he’s somehow gotta be peak Talia already?

Remember when most thought Nathan Bock was useless when he was first switched into defence after being drafted as a tall forward from Woodville West Torrens?
So far Billy is looking a chance to make some sort of a career as a KPD, early days yet.

 

[LeftyLuke]

What troubled me most --- his repeated fumbling. Gets 2 hands to the ball, fumbles it often, even on handball receives.

He should be told NEVER to short-pass the ball. Never. He just can't do it with any precision/confidence. ROB as well.

Frampton just looks like he doesn't know what to do creatively with the ball. If I had to guess, it's self-doubt.

Time to trade in a topline KPD. Would be worth around 3 wins. Frampton is not a long term solution.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Tigers get on top in the third quarter … umpires say ‘Hold my beer’. Full strength Adel except for Seedsman. 32-13 in free kicks and you kicked 12-1 from set shots. It’s nice to win but I’d probably cool the celebrations - wouldn’t want to celebrate too early like in GF week of 2017 when Tex saved a seat on the plane for the cup


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

We don’t really give a flying Fk

Just happy to show something this season while you make your decline

 

[lamby]

Himmelberg’s turn around has been borderline unbelievable, maybe it’s finally clicked.

Jesus people. The reason is that
Tex is back! Himmelberg (well anybody really) plays better when the best defender and loose player are on someone else!

 

[cleanhands]

Tigers get on top in the third quarter … umpires say ‘Hold my beer’. Full strength Adel except for Seedsman. 32-13 in free kicks and you kicked 12-1 from set shots. It’s nice to win but I’d probably cool the celebrations - wouldn’t want to celebrate too early like in GF week of 2017 when Tex saved a seat on the plane for the cup


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Why bother?

 

[dogs105]

Tigers get on top in the third quarter … umpires say ‘Hold my beer’. Full strength Adel except for Seedsman. 32-13 in free kicks and you kicked 12-1 from set shots. It’s nice to win but I’d probably cool the celebrations - wouldn’t want to celebrate too early like in GF week of 2017 when Tex saved a seat on the plane for the cup


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Sad...