List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016 Part 3

[RupetFan]

Motlop... nah thanks

 

[TradeDraft]

Motlop... nah thanks

Agree. Don't Want Him. WHE be what we want

 

[Chrispiesssss]

MotFlop.

 

[Scodog10]

Some are more nobody here then others though. TradeWhisperer is some journo alts accounts that likes to stir. Witty and provocative. One can't take the Trade period too serious with everything that is thrown about.
Mayne is coming that's for sure and how much $$$ is justified , I will melt over that after 1 season of him in b&w.

I've made my peace with it. To be giving just shy of $200k less to him than a guy that went top 10 in the Brownlow disturbs me, but my only concern from here is more for the incoming coach if Bucks falls over.

If it goes that way they'll look over things and just be like "WTF is this" crazy is about all I can say now.

 

[Horaceg]

Lin Jong has re-signed with the dogs apparently

I'm OK with this

 

[BEEG]

Hoping to get some stuff from the Copeland tonight, im not going but will find out a few things tomorrow hopefully.

 

[PicaBoo]

I've made my peace with it. To be giving just shy of $200k less to him than a guy that went top 10 in the Brownlow disturbs me, but my only concern from here is more for the incoming coach if Bucks falls over.

If it goes that way they'll look over things and just be like "WTF is this" crazy is about all I can say now.

I was up in that same frame of mind until Gubby came into the frame. If he doesn't look at what is best for the club post Bucks, he deserves every ban the AFL and Caro can throw at him. As for Mayne I doubt he will be given his own B&W segment, newspaper column and what not media gig. Unlike our Brownlow candidate ( and according to evil rumours a a job for the GF)

 

[millsy29gopies]

If Motlop doesn't cost more than a second rounder, I'd be up for that.

 

[MyManLynch]

That poster was Bucksboys (Hinequarters) and whatever name he had before then.

Do you keep secret files on these guys?

 

[GoalSneak07]

Any chance of Wells winning the Kangas Best and Fairest tonight then jumping in a cab and joining his future teammates at Crown for the Copeland in a Collingwood Tie? Man that would push a few buttons amongst the AFL.

 

[TradeDraft]

Hoping to get some stuff from the Copeland tonight, im not going but will find out a few things tomorrow hopefully.

Bet lot of Whispers will come from Copeland.

Hopefully the Copeland Trophy Winners in here can get some Scoops

 

[TradeDraft]

Any chance of Wells winning the Kangas Best and Fairest tonight then jumping in a cab and joining his future teammates at Crown for the Copeland in a Collingwood Tie? Man that would push a few buttons amongst the AFL.

No Chance. That is why he will make announcement after there B&F and most likely on Monday

 

[Scodog10]

I was up in that same frame of mind until Gubby came into the frame. If he doesn't look at what is best for the club post Bucks, he deserves every ban the AFL and Caro can throw at him. As for Maybe I doubt he will be given his own B&W segment, newspaper column and what not media gig. Unlike our Brownlow candidate ( and according to evil rumours a a job for the GF)

Good luck to the club justifying it either way, IMO. I seriously doubt that too and that AT is on anything outrageous outside the cap. Dealing in what we can he'll be on massive overs which could prove problematic down the line.

 

[left at home]

mattys123 Said He toured the Westpac Center this week

thanks dave. leaving no stone un turned by the club

 

[Apex36]

Personally, I'd do a third for Hoskin-Elliott, I have a hunch though that it's going to end up more like a second and swap of picks.

What would you do for him, and what's your predicition on what the actual trade will be?

I don't think we'd be hot enough for him to give up a second under any circumstances.

 

[Lefthanded]

I've made my peace with it. To be giving just shy of $200k less to him than a guy that went top 10 in the Brownlow disturbs me, but my only concern from here is more for the incoming coach if Bucks falls over.

If it goes that way they'll look over things and just be like "WTF is this" crazy is about all I can say now.

Stop being so pessimistic. If we get a new coach I'm sure huh there will be a thorough selection process and the best candidate will single handedley fix all our issues, including player longevity! Only thing they won't be able to do is develop 20 players to finish top 10 (in the same year) of the Copeland. Ok so maybe Blair won't be developed into a contested marking king.

 

[Old Spice]

Bet lot of Whispers will come from Copeland.

Hopefully the Copeland Trophy Winners in here can get some Scoops

Boy, how the mighty have fallen.

 

[Scodog10]

Stop being so pessimistic. If we get a new coach I'm sure huh there will be a thorough selection process and the best candidate will single handedley fix all our issues, including player longevity! Only thing they won't be able to do is develop 20 players to finish top 10 (in the same year) of the Copeland. Ok so maybe Blair won't be developed into a contested marking king.

No issues with that side of things every club needs role players you just pay them a role players wage lol. Its like running up an expensive bar tab and getting the next guy that walks through the door to pay it for you. Not cool in other words!

 

[Magpie Girl]

I don't see any 'Welcome' threads
Has anything happened?

 

[Lethal06]

I don't think we'd be hot enough for him to give up a second under any circumstances.

WHE is a bloody good player. I've seen him play plenty of times in Canberra. Great leap and mark, good acceleration and disposal skills. Exactly the kind of outside player we need. Closest comparisons on our list are probably Howe and to a lesser extent Aish. I think WHE could be better than both of them if he can get his body right. Minor but disruptive injury interruptions plus GWS's excess of quality outside players has seen him play far less at AFL level than his talent would justify. IMO he will be best-22 for us once he finds his feet. Anyway, no need to take my word for it - Treloar and Adams will be providing CFC with great inside info on his pros, cons and market value.

 

[dansa]

Any chance of Wells winning the Kangas Best and Fairest tonight then jumping in a cab and joining his future teammates at Crown for the Copeland in a Collingwood Tie? Man that would push a few buttons amongst the AFL.

I know you're only having a laugh.

But I would really dislike if any free agent joining the Pies disrespected his former club like that. It would tell you all needed to know about their character.

I will always have the utmost respect Luke Ball for the respect he showed St Kilda when leaving and when celebrating the Premiership - all class.

 

[unplugged]

Anyone considered setting up a camping chair just outside of the Holden Centre entrance to keep tabs (and take photos) of all personnel entering and exiting?

Dave?

 

[Matt_352]

Personally, I'd do a third for Hoskin-Elliott, I have a hunch though that it's going to end up more like a second and swap of picks.

What would you do for him, and what's your predicition on what the actual trade will be?

3rd rounder straight swap 2017 3rd. Should be Pick 50ish

 

[JustInsideFifty]

Stop being so pessimistic. If we get a new coach I'm sure huh there will be a thorough selection process and the best candidate will single handedley fix all our issues, including player longevity! Only thing they won't be able to do is develop 20 players to finish top 10 (in the same year) of the Copeland. Ok so maybe Blair won't be developed into a contested marking king.

You never know, Leppa managed to develop 4 winners of Lions B+F last year!

 

[mike123]

I'd rather Motlop to Mayne and WHE