Unofficial Preview Changes V Carlton: White omitted, Marsh injured, Moore and Goldsack in

[CFC2010]

Not a fan of Moore?

I was talking about White Quicky.

 

[Big Bryza]

The player that is most likely to have a significant impact THIS week which I think is White.

Really disappointing to promote a kid who has had a pretty tepid season to date purely as he's the "future" over a guy who has had a significant impact over numbers of weeks without even having to resume in the VFL. If Moore was playing as well as some seem to suggest then that's a different story, but that isn't the reality. The game against the Doggies was his best for the year (well for 3/4s anyway) so hopefully he can resume at that level.

You can't understand why we are getting games into Moore over White?

 

[ClaytonM]

Talent like him you don't hold back

Why? At least one game back through the 2s to build form would be preferable.

 

[Quicky]

I was talking about White Quicky.

Sorry it gets hard to follow the conversation when people say "he" instead of "[insert name here]". I thought the conversation was about Moore. My mistake.

 

[left at home]

He is not the future,the sooner you realise this the easier it will be.

no he is not and l have never said he was. but l like to see a player dropped because some one forced them out by
form and not because of the future. form wins games, hope is a may be.

 

[Starcevich90]

The season is over for us. We all know what White is. To put Moore in the twos would be a foolish decision. Time to look to the future, not hope a never-will-be will come good.

 

[doodles98]

White a bit stiff...

at least it wasn't Cox

 

[CFC2010]

no he is not and l have never said he was. but l like to see a player dropped because some one forced them out by
form and not because of the future. form wins games, hope is a may be.

Let's be honest here our form has been pathetic......White has been fine but getting games into Moore takes precedence because Moore is our future for the next ten years.

 

[doings]

White and Cloke have no future potential for our side
Gault and Moore and cox are the only people I ever want to see playing in the forward line key position wise

 

[BoxMatrix]

White and Cloke have no future potential for our side
Gault and Moore and cox are the only people I ever want to see playing in the forward line key position wise

Lol Gault.

Dude is the biggest spud in the side. Never want to see him in the side again.

 

[Maggie5]

long time reader, first time lurker. I could smell a bit of sour banter from the Collingwood camp from a mile away and wasn't disappointed!

Nah, that smell was coming from you. Go away you are stinking it up big time.

 

[TradeDraft]

White and Cloke have no future potential for our side
Gault and Moore and cox are the only people I ever want to see playing in the forward line key position wise

Gault has no Future. He is even not good enough at VFL Level

 

[TradeDraft]

Lol Gault.

Dude is the biggest spud in the side. Never want to see him in the side again.

I say Golds is Worse

 

[left at home]

Let's be honest here our form has been pathetic......White has been fine but getting games into Moore takes precedence because Moore is our future for the next ten years.

not if he rebreaks his collarbone. they have taken a courses approach to injuries this year which l like, so why now risk it.
he is part of our future, not all of it. agree about getting games into him, but also like to see form. 5 weeks out from surgery, one more week off
does not matter

 

[spartan-magpie]

Waiting for Carlscum, in black and white...

I like that. Pretty good likeness for Maynard too

 

[doodles98]

Ok let's run with this, tell me a game in his career with the Pies that White has had a significant impact, maybe White is a bit stiff to be omitted but that's the reality of footy, like I said whether it's this week or the next or the next I will take Moore every day of the week over a White

The game against Brisbane this year. Easily our best forward and one of the best players on the ground.

 

[doings]

I say Golds is Worse

Why did we pick him up
Never understood that

 

[jscan]

Every time they've dropped Cloke was an example of this. White should never be picked ahead of Cloke. The former was lucky to stay in after the Port game, he should've been dropped then over Cloke for the infamous 3-rucks Queens Birthday game.

Cloke is overpaid and has under delivered, all bit it not completely his fault given the 'game plans'.

White has delivered relative to what his paid as an average player, at best.

 

[PieBeast]

Can understand why someone had to be stiff to go out for Moore and why it ended up being White, can even understand why Goldsack comes in ahead of Oxley, at least he can play tight if need be.

But why Blair isn't being phased out of this side is beyond my comprehension. And please spare me the effort and tackles fluff, his actual impact on our fortunes has been sfa for years.

 

[Apex36]

White and Cloke have no future potential for our side
Gault and Moore and cox are the only people I ever want to see playing in the forward line key position wise

Lol Gault. Why would you want to see a terrible player who won't be on an AFL list next year getting games ahead of Cloke, who despite his age, has at least 3 years left...

 

[doings]

Lol Gault. Why would you want to see a terrible player who won't be on an AFL list next year getting games ahead of Cloke, who despite his age, has at least 3 years left...

LOL I KNOW HES SHIT
BUT HE HAS POTENTIAL
CLOKE DOESNT
I HOPE THAT WE
MAKE A TRADE
IN THE OFFSEASON
FOR A NEW FORWARD
JOSH JENKINS OR
NICK RIEWOLDT
TAYLOR WALKER
JOSH SCHACHE
DREW PETRIE
LUKE MCDONALD
JOSH KENNEDY
MATTHEW PAVLICH
JAKE NEADE
TOM LYNCH
JEREMY CAMERON
THATS MY SHORTLIST

 

[Maggie5]

Can understand why someone had to be stiff to go out for Moore and why it ended up being White, can even understand why Goldsack comes in ahead of Oxley, at least he can play tight if need be.

But why Blair isn't being phased out of this side is beyond my comprehension. And please spare me the effort and tackles fluff, his actual impact on our fortunes has been sfa for years.

Got a voucher for SpecSaver think you need a new pair.
Blair has been one of our best in the last few weeks.

 

[doodles98]

Did we work out if it is Jason Donovan or Donovan the 60's folk singer we want sacked from the club now? Whichever one it is, I'm all for it!

 

[PieBeast]

Got a voucher for SpecSaver think you need a new pair.
Blair has been one of our best in the last few weeks.

No offense but I don't pay any attention to your ratings of players.

Send the voucher anyway, might use it when and if I'll get to your age.

 

[Maggie5]

No offense but I don't pay any attention to your ratings of players.

Send the voucher anyway, might use it when and if I'll get to your age.

Neither do I on yours, that is why I reply to your posts.
Got selection right though, so someone must agree with me.
What you are under 21?