- Oct 4, 2015
- 13,273
- 24,960
- AFL Club
- Carlton
And rate of decline from their older brigade...
Hot Topic Carlton 2024 Trade Discussion
- Thread starter The Old Dark Navy's
- Start date
- Tagged users None
And rate of decline from their older brigade...
bluesDeluxe
Senior List
- Oct 15, 2022
- 199
- 342
- AFL Club
- Carlton
It sounds like the call was made a few days ago to pull out of the Houston race, and concentrate on taking 2 first rounders + Campos.
GWS looks like the best option to trade with.
GWS looks like the best option to trade with.
Westy's_Warriors
Debutant
The consistent narrative on here from the people who have some knowledge on what’s happening behind the scenes has been we will do things “on our terms”.
And this sounds quite like the way we go about things on field as well.
The problem is that football on and off the field is rarely on your terms as there are 17 other clubs competing with you.
The trade period issue for mine is that from the information we have the club don’t seem to have a definite plan to either go all in and makes us better for the immediate term and challenge, or takes some picks and start regenerating.
Either of the above is fine, but operating in the middle of the two isn’t good practice, and the indecision or “on our terms” has left the door open for other clubs to make some bold plays, while we may just sit back waiting for things to pan out on our terms
And this sounds quite like the way we go about things on field as well.
The problem is that football on and off the field is rarely on your terms as there are 17 other clubs competing with you.
The trade period issue for mine is that from the information we have the club don’t seem to have a definite plan to either go all in and makes us better for the immediate term and challenge, or takes some picks and start regenerating.
Either of the above is fine, but operating in the middle of the two isn’t good practice, and the indecision or “on our terms” has left the door open for other clubs to make some bold plays, while we may just sit back waiting for things to pan out on our terms
Jimmae
Brownlow Medallist
They're all role players this year, and have plenty of players in their prime or coming into their prime, though they definitely need to seek out contested mids over time.
15 & 16 for 12 & 34
That was a no!
I wouldn't do that deal if we had 15 & 16
The club moving up pays the premium
Why would GWS do that deal
16 & 21 might be closer
Wickzki
Definitely Sam MacLure.
- Oct 1, 2010
- 26,441
- 63,541
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Ophidians Old Boys, Blazers, MCFC
Too significant a premium. If it were pick 20ish it would be closer.
You'd only consider it on draft night if you were truly locked in on someone and knew they wouldn't last.
- Moderator
- #387
What they said: Austin opens trade period
Head of List Management Nick Austin spoke to media on the opening day of the Continental Tyres Trade Period.
Turns the ball over a fair bit too…
He’s worth a pick in the 30’s at best…
BlueZombie
Club Legend
- Aug 7, 2020
- 1,062
- 2,366
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Australian Cricket team
NEVER DONE ONE OF THESE BEFORE - BUT SINCE I DON'T START WORK TILL LATER AND HAVE SOME TIME I THOUGHT I’D GIVE IT A GO. I'M SURE THIS IS FULL OF HOLES / NEEDS TINKERING - BUT IT'S JUST FOR FUN.
CARLTON GIVE: 12, 34 & CHANGE?
GWS GIVE: 16, 21, 37
GIVES US: F1, 16, 21, 37
CARLTON GIVE: F1 + 21
PORT GIVE: DAN HOUSTON
GIVES US: DAN HOUSTON, 16, 37, + WHATEVER TRADE CAPITAL WE AQUIRE FOR THE PLAYERS WE HAVE UP FOR TRADE.
OWIES = LATE 2ND ROUND PICK?
KENNEDY = LATE 2ND ROUND PICK?
YOUNG = LATE 3RD?
CARROLL = EARLY 3RD?
GIVES US: DAN HOUSTON, 16, 37, + MAYBE 2 X LATE 2NDS, (OWIES & KENNEDY PICKS FOR ARGUMENTS SAKE)
SURELY WE COULD THEN TURN THE 3 x LATE 2NDS INTO ANOTHER LATE 1ST ROUNDER?
GIVING US:
DAN HOUSTON,
2 X LATE 1ST ROUNDERS,
+ WHATEVER MEAGRE OFFERINGS FALL OUR WAY SHOULD YOUNG AND CARROLL BE TRADED.
...NOW I CAN FINALLY SAY I'VE DONE ONE OF THESE ON BIGFOOTY!
CARLTON GIVE: 12, 34 & CHANGE?
GWS GIVE: 16, 21, 37
GIVES US: F1, 16, 21, 37
CARLTON GIVE: F1 + 21
PORT GIVE: DAN HOUSTON
GIVES US: DAN HOUSTON, 16, 37, + WHATEVER TRADE CAPITAL WE AQUIRE FOR THE PLAYERS WE HAVE UP FOR TRADE.
OWIES = LATE 2ND ROUND PICK?
KENNEDY = LATE 2ND ROUND PICK?
YOUNG = LATE 3RD?
CARROLL = EARLY 3RD?
GIVES US: DAN HOUSTON, 16, 37, + MAYBE 2 X LATE 2NDS, (OWIES & KENNEDY PICKS FOR ARGUMENTS SAKE)
SURELY WE COULD THEN TURN THE 3 x LATE 2NDS INTO ANOTHER LATE 1ST ROUNDER?
GIVING US:
DAN HOUSTON,
2 X LATE 1ST ROUNDERS,
+ WHATEVER MEAGRE OFFERINGS FALL OUR WAY SHOULD YOUNG AND CARROLL BE TRADED.
...NOW I CAN FINALLY SAY I'VE DONE ONE OF THESE ON BIGFOOTY!
Dramoth
Premium Platinum
I would leave Kemp forward to be honest. Leave McLovin back. Move Jack into the midfield as a ruck/rover type... I remember someone from his family doing a fantastic job in that position.
Wow nice … but we’re ending up with Haynes Membrey and a couple of kids lol
By listening to Haynes on SEN this morning it seems like he will be getting some game time next season. Nick mentioned he can play on talls aswell as smalls.
I wonder how this is gonna play out,how would the team line up including Nick?
I wonder how this is gonna play out,how would the team line up including Nick?
We will NOT trade Pick 12 backwards. That is finite.
We will use next years pick/s and/or 34 to move up this year to ADD to 12.
We will use next years pick/s and/or 34 to move up this year to ADD to 12.
Harry Sharp?
Jimmae
Brownlow Medallist
I would be hesitant to trade a future 3rd for him.
- Oct 4, 2018
- 10,143
- 25,787
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Arsenal & NY Knicks
Nick Austin on Trade Feed
4flagsin5yrs
Premiership Player
OK So my FOMO is in overdive right now but this sums up what I also think:
www.foxsports.com.au
‘I’d be taking the risk’: Blues’ confusing, conservative trade call could gift-wrap star to rivals
‘I’d be taking the risk’: Blues’ confusing, conservative trade call could gift-wrap star to rivals
www.foxsports.com.au
Totally delusional, as the Woods F1 could be around pick 13/14 itself meaning that Col think Noble is worth 23 & 29......fair bit of arrogance in that demand, and like you said GC need to be strong and tell em to get stuffed over that scenario!!!
- Oct 3, 2015
- 1,958
- 8,945
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Forty3’s analysis of what we are doing with list management is a good deal more insightful than what Fox are putting out.OK So my FOMO is in overdive right now but this sums up what I also think:
‘I’d be taking the risk’: Blues’ confusing, conservative trade call could gift-wrap star to rivals
‘I’d be taking the risk’: Blues’ confusing, conservative trade call could gift-wrap star to rivals
