Brad Scott how long?

Remove this Banner Ad

Any coach going to Essendon is on a complete hiding to nothing, as long as Sheedy, Barham and šŸ¦¤are at the club.

Once Scott's gone, they'll struggle to find any serious candidates for the role, as it's pretty much a death sentence for any assistant with senior aspirations.

Might as well just bring back Hird and complete the collection of blokes at the club who Essendon fans need to get a restraining order on for their club to improve.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

evo said:
He has another couple years of grace.

Its all a predictable, glorious cycle:

Once those pesky finals are out of the way, attention can focus back on Essendon

- Firstly they will definitely win trade week. A big fish eg. Mckay will be landed at a bargain price, "North were absolutely fleeced by Adrian, hehehe"

- Secondly, Essendon will land a couple of flakely outside back flanker types, when they really need some big bodied grunt midfielders but nevertheless be declared as having a highly successful draft.

- Come January, their overrated one good game a month types will be declared burning up the track, think Stringrer, McGrath , Shiel

- come Februrary , their young hopefulls will get full page news articles about what fantastic futures they have, how we can expect a Hobbs break out season and Martin for All Australian

- April, May they ll have a postive win loss ratio and be in the the Eight, their fans will start puffing their chest out, bumping old threads where we were laughing at them and proudly declaring this seaon is different "suck shit Carlton, Hawks or North supporters"

-come July , Esendon will start getting flogged again and slip out of the eight back to their rightfull position around 10 -14. Essendon supporters will go quiet, and opposition supporters will bump the Dodoro thread and chortle.

- rinse and repeat
Click to expand...

He has seen the future.
 
windyhill said:
No denying that, who would ? Wooden spoon a bit nasty. Whatā€™s pick one look like ? Not another Dusty ?!?
Click to expand...

Draper looks great.. so does Jagga Smith and Finn Oā€™Sullivan ā€¦ looks like a very strong draft and we will be knee deep in it.
Enjoy mid table and all its spoils ..
 
nut said:
Draper looks great.. so does Jagga Smith and Finn Oā€™Sullivan ā€¦ looks like a very strong draft and we will be knee deep in it.
Enjoy mid table and all its spoils ..
Click to expand...
Iā€™m enjoying putting two in a row on you, ( The Durham one especially sweet) about time we put a bit more distance on the h2h.
 
When he was at North Brad was more concerned for his favourite players (usually older journeymen) to be able to buy property and be financially set up for life - it took priority over winning. This was well known in North circles for the last couple of years of his tenure. Remember 2016? We started 9-0 and he came out and said only 12 wins was the goal. What message does that send to your players, when you say they only have to win 3 of their last 13 games? And sure enough, we won only 3 of the last 14 games.

I'm seeing the exact same pattern at Essendon. No club has had less debutants this year and he keeps playing a bunch of 26-30 year olds that may or may not jag a random finals appearance but no further, and are just going to leave them treading water and clog up the list in the long term, like he did with us.

He is who he is and he won't change now.
 
Last edited:
nut said:
Draper looks great.. so does Jagga Smith and Finn Oā€™Sullivan ā€¦ looks like a very strong draft and we will be knee deep in it.
Enjoy mid table and all its spoils ..
Click to expand...

Not a great year to have pick 1 outright as there isn't a genuine consensus number 1 player.

However, get a decent return for Liam Baker and/or trade into the first round of this season and it will give the rebuild a nice little starting point. Very deep first round this year, so any team that can score multiple picks will be doing well.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

evo said:
He has another couple years of grace.

Its all a predictable, glorious cycle:

Once those pesky finals are out of the way, attention can focus back on Essendon

- Firstly they will definitely win trade week. A big fish eg. Mckay will be landed at a bargain price, "North were absolutely fleeced by Adrian, hehehe"

- Secondly, Essendon will land a couple of flakely outside back flanker types, when they really need some big bodied grunt midfielders but nevertheless be declared as having a highly successful draft.

- Come January, their overrated one good game a month types will be declared burning up the track, think Stringrer, McGrath , Shiel

- come Februrary , their young hopefulls will get full page news articles about what fantastic futures they have, how we can expect a Hobbs break out season and Martin for All Australian

- April, May they ll have a postive win loss ratio and be in the the Eight, their fans will start puffing their chest out, bumping old threads where we were laughing at them and proudly declaring this seaon is different "suck shit Carlton, Hawks or North supporters"

-come July , Esendon will start getting flogged again and slip out of the eight back to their rightfull position around 10 -14. Essendon supporters will go quiet, and opposition supporters will bump the Dodoro thread and chortle.

- rinse and repeat
Click to expand...
The Guardian has published a less prophetic but still worthwhile expansion on this theme here: https://www.theguardian.com/sport/b...-brad-scott-and-grinds-bombers-season-to-dust
 
Freomaniac said:
I havent given up on him.

I actually think Brad Scott can get finals and win a final next season
Click to expand...
Based on the approach this off-season they are gearing towards a rebuild rather than chasing the sugar hit of a finals win by topping up with experience.

I would be relatively surprised if we arenā€™t in the bottom 7-8 teams next year as I think the main focus will be to give opportunities to the younger talent on our list to prove whether or not they are up to the standard of AFL footy (Tsatas, Hobbs, Perkins, Cox for example).
 
Cyber_punk said:
When he was at North Brad was more concerned for his favourite players (usually older journeymen) to be able to buy property and be financially set up for life - it took priority over winning. This was well known in North circles for the last couple of years of his tenure. Remember 2016? We started 9-0 and he came out and said only 12 wins was the goal. What message does that send to your players, when you say they only have to win 3 of their last 13 games? And sure enough, we won only 3 of the last 14 games.

I'm seeing the exact same pattern at Essendon. No club has had less debutants this year and he keeps playing a bunch of 26-30 year olds that may or may not jag a random finals appearance but no further, and are just going to leave them treading water and clog up the list in the long term, like he did with us.

He is who he is and he won't change now.
Click to expand...
I mean you could justify Brad Scott clogging the list with journey men and hacks from other clubs if the club makes and win finals.

Again.... I look back at North Melbourne when they made finals in 2014, 2015 and 2016.

North Melbourne wasn't a top 4 club, they were not bottom 4 either.

They finished 5th to 8th for 3 years in a row.

North definitely overachieved in 2014. They won 2 finals vs Essendon in the MCG and cats in the MCG that season.

They overachieved in 2015 as well. Beating Richmond in the MCG and Swans in NSW.

I don't care what anyone says, North Melbourne finals run of 2014 and 2015 and 2016 was very good.

Even if 2014 and 2015 both ended up as Elim final wins in week one and a semi final exit the next week, at least they won finals.
 
Freomaniac said:
I mean you could justify Brad Scott clogging the list with journey men and hacks from other clubs if the club makes and win finals.

Again.... I look back at North Melbourne when they made finals in 2014, 2015 and 2016.

North Melbourne wasn't a top 4 club, they were not bottom 4 either.

They finished 5th to 8th for 3 years in a row.

North definitely overachieved in 2014. They won 2 finals vs Essendon in the MCG and cats in the MCG that season.

They overachieved in 2015 as well. Beating Richmond in the MCG and Swans in NSW.

I don't care what anyone says, North Melbourne finals run of 2014 and 2015 and 2016 was very good.

Even if 2014 and 2015 both ended up as Elim final wins in week one and a semi final exit the next week, at least they won finals.
Click to expand...

We never felt like a threat in my eyes, even when we started 9-0 in 2016. The nature of the close finals wins reflected that. We were just too old with too many journeyman to stomp anyone.
 
Jock McHale couldn't do anything with this absolutely garbage list.

Crichton Medal
1. Zach Merrett - 212 votes
2. Nic Martin - 197
3. Sam Durham - 184
4. Andrew McGrath - 157
5. Jye Caldwell - 154
6. Ben McKay - 151
7. Kyle Langford - 131
8. Mason Redman - 108
9. Jake Stringer - 104
10. Harrison Jones- 80

Top 3 + Ridley are good footballers.

Rest are absolute garbage.
 
Last edited:
WillHayward said:
Jock McHale couldn't do anything with this absolutely garbage list.

Crichton Medal
1. Zach Merrett - 212 votes
2. Nic Martin - 197
3. Sam Durham - 184
4. Andrew McGrath - 157
5. Jye Caldwell - 154
6. Ben McKay - 151
7. Kyle Langford - 131
8. Mason Redman - 108
9. Jake Stringer - 104
10. Harrison Jones- 80

Top 3 + Ridley are good footballers.

Rest are absolute garbage.
Click to expand...
A little unfair to call McGrath, Langford, McKay and Stringer garbage.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Brad Scott how long?

Similar threads

BigVic
Andrew McQualter - how long?
2
Replies
37
Views
1K
bungalow_bill
bungalow_bill
Chinacats
Opinion Longmire or Scott?
Replies
14
Views
657
Jimmy Yamazaki
J
go_the_dockers
How long should a rebuild take?
2 3 4 5
Replies
123
Views
5K
Freomaniac
Freomaniac
Chaisa
Is the game too long?
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
155
Views
5K
Bjo187
Bjo187
Cleric
How good will Riley Thilthorpe be?
Replies
19
Views
590
Del165198
D
LordLucifer
Opinion Number Of Players In A Team ......... How Would You Structure It ??
Replies
11
Views
479
kreuze_missile
kreuze_missile
Cleric
How did the draft work in the 1980s?
Replies
6
Views
426
Billy ray
Billy ray

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top