nathanchelsea
Senior List
what kind of value do you think they have? 4th rounder, upgrade pick?
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Are McMahon, Schultz, Couglhan, Pettifer worth anything in trade week?
- Thread starter nathanchelsea
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Barnzy
Premium Platinum
For all of them combined you could maybe get a decent meal at a 2 star restaurant.
obviously petts and mcmahon wont get you anything.
if we played schulz for the rest of the season he could pick up a little currency but i doubt it.
coughlan i dont think we will get anything for, but if we delist him he might get picked up by another team.
if we played schulz for the rest of the season he could pick up a little currency but i doubt it.
coughlan i dont think we will get anything for, but if we delist him he might get picked up by another team.
i dont think a club would give away 4 spots on there list. but i would like to keep Coughlan and Schulz atleast for next season.
- Banned
- #6
maybe a bag full of sherrins, some gatorade powder and half a dozen rolls of ankle tape
JR#8
Norm Smith Medallist
WTF is everybody on the board talking about trading Coughlan for?
He came back this year and everybody on the forum was wrapt to have him back in the team. He played a handful of games and to my memory his last game before he got dropped was average. Now we are talking about delisting/trading him?
Seriously, get a clue some of you. He has played well pretty much all season and hasn't even been given a real chance to prove himself this year. He is also only 27-28 years old.
He came back this year and everybody on the forum was wrapt to have him back in the team. He played a handful of games and to my memory his last game before he got dropped was average. Now we are talking about delisting/trading him?
Seriously, get a clue some of you. He has played well pretty much all season and hasn't even been given a real chance to prove himself this year. He is also only 27-28 years old.
since he is not tearing it up people want him gone.
JR#8
Norm Smith Medallist
Understood, but give the bloke a chance. He has been injured for 3 years. He isn't going to play a handfull of games and get back to his best so soon.
Upgrayedd
A Vote for Clive is a Vote for Justice
Mcmahon-May as well Keep, cant see him going for more then a late third rounder
Schultz-Third rounder at Port
Coughlan-You might as well keep
Pettifer-May as well keep or delist
Schultz-Third rounder at Port
Coughlan-You might as well keep
Pettifer-May as well keep or delist
the thing is most people will want instant results. thats why so many want to get rid of JON and not let him develop. if they dont, well everyone wants them delisted. im willing to give cogs all of next year, he was playing some good footy, but got dropped when we wanted to play all kids so if it wasnt for that would properly still be in the team now.
I dont undertsand why mcmahon isnt getting a game
he was in the top 10 BF wasnt he last year?
he was in the top 10 BF wasnt he last year?
tugga
Hall of Famer
- May 9, 2006
- 35,930
- 72,078
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Tottenham,NY Rangers,Red Sox, SA Spurs
maybe even an indecent meal.
Short answer: no
totally agree, cogs could be a gun next year with a preseason, im sick of people wanting him gone too
we need atleast alittle bit of depth so people like king and jon dont make it into the team
Tigertom
Team Captain
Was adequate in our poor side for a few years. A good inside player that always ran like he had lead in his boots. I for one was reluctant to see him play this year with all the untired youth on the list but Rawlings has taken care of that
. Browny is enough evidence of how an injury and a couple of seasons out affect the pace. the game is getting faster each year and the players who struggle for pace now won't be around for too long.Has been a serviceable asset to RFC but if we are to take the next step unfortunately I don't feel he will be part of it.
I would think the only one to attract interest would be Schulz .... but only as a pre-season pick after we delisted him.
Clubs are smart, they'd know none of the above will play a role in our future.
Clubs are smart, they'd know none of the above will play a role in our future.
No!
Mcmahon - is worth nothing, wish we picked ward f.... terry wallace.
schulz - was a spud 4 years ago but still is on our list
coughlan - his damn injuries could've been a long term superstar
pettifer - nearly conned us all with one decent year but we should've delisted him when he went back to his old tricks
Mcmahon - is worth nothing, wish we picked ward f.... terry wallace.
schulz - was a spud 4 years ago but still is on our list
coughlan - his damn injuries could've been a long term superstar
pettifer - nearly conned us all with one decent year but we should've delisted him when he went back to his old tricks
at richmond, yes, in afl maybe not, but probably yes
astro_toby
Cancelled
- Sep 30, 2004
- 5,455
- 1,339
- AFL Club
- Richmond
neither were you - what's that tell you about the bloke?
He hasn't been able to get more than a game in two sides in two years that finished bottom 4 that year?
you can have him back for the 3rd rounder this year
Well, look at this way. McMahon is no good across the Half Back line. If we played him as a wing/HF i don't see were he can go wrong. I think we should keep him because he has skills believe it or not. All you people calling for him to get delisted. Whats that going to prove?, This draft is weak. Rather keep him give him another year to settle into a WING/HF position and see how he goes there.
