Game Day 2025 Round 5 Discussion ...Carnage

[SC fish]

Hoping trainor can get 170+

FTFY

 

[toxic]

Going to be a hard watch today. My only docker is Reid. Expect everyone with Brayshaw/ Serong to get a really good bump.

Was going to trade Freijah to one of them until I stuffed up my loop. Almost tempted to trade Callaghan to one of them, but it seems too sideways, and I'm hoping Callaghan might be motivated against the mob that he knocked back $17m from. Thoughts community?

Hold

He won't be tagged today

Kelly
Whitfield
Green

All before Finn

 

[VainGlorious]

Ha ha that actually gave me a laugh mate thanks.

Team is not great tbh mate and my trades haven’t been very good either.

Have a few potentially dead rookies like most I would think. Under performing premos has been the biggest problem so far.

View attachment 2281492

I’m in the same boat at the moment.

Well, the boat is more of a rusty tinny with more holes than Swiss cheese.

Tried going value/MPM and I’ve made a few howlers.

This one was horrendous. Started Knevitt, traded him out when he was ‘injured’, brought him back in when he was named for SDK who I also started, to load up the bank for a Daicos/Heeney type.

It’s going to be a looooong year,

 

[Eagling]

Well then you'd be a nuffy Eagles fan that picked Allan despite not being named and scoring -12 in the PS. Just like YeoGabbaGabba

I am a nuffy eagles fan.

I did pick Bo Allan in Round 1 (I had Maric and he was sub and so Allan was the only viable option).

But whilst I still have Allan, I also have Paton at D8 as well

 

[Scythe]

All before Finn

Might be underestimating Rossco's pettiness. I'm a Finn owner prepared for the worst lol

 

[Scythe]

Brayshaw, Trainor and new recruit Clark in this one. Couple of big scores would be handy

 

[Caztheconquerer]

I’m in the same boat at the moment.

Well, the boat is more of a rusty tinny with more holes than Swiss cheese.

Tried going value/MPM and I’ve made a few howlers.

This one was horrendous. Started Knevitt, traded him when he was injured, brought him back in when he was named for SDK who I also started, to load up the bank for a Daicos/Heeney type.

It’s going to be a looooong year,

Yeah agreed mate it’s going to be hard to make up ground from here. Went for value at the start to a point as well, trac Oliver Callaghan roberts etc.

Didn’t start smith so he was a trade in for Jhf who went 150 that week lol .
Went Callaghan out to brayshaw this week and not sure how that’s going to go

 

[VainGlorious]

Didn’t start smith so he was a trade in for Jhf who went 150 that week lol .

Ouch. I started them both. It’s been a roller coaster.

Went Callaghan out to brayshaw this week and not sure how that’s going to go

Good trade on paper. Let’s see what horrors await us on SBS.

 

[Petrify]

Only SP M. Reid in this one. And Trainor on the bench. If I can get my projected of over 2300 i'll be thrilled

 

[Nelso]

Tempted to roll the dice and make Clark captain.

 

[Biggie]

The red Haired grass eater bounced back this week, over to you now Finn.

 

[Scythe]

T-minus two hours until potential 'delete team'

 

[MacStradbroke]

Tempted to roll the dice and make Clark captain.

 

[TasSixer]

1509 -48 if Lindsay's score is lowest
Serong C
Short
Trainor
M Hall
Macrae
Rozee
JHF

Save me captain Serong

 

[PoopingHindi]

Going to be a hard watch today. My only docker is Reid. Expect everyone with Brayshaw/ Serong to get a really good bump.

Was going to trade Freijah to one of them until I stuffed up my loop. Almost tempted to trade Callaghan to one of them, but it seems too sideways, and I'm hoping Callaghan might be motivated against the mob that he knocked back $17m from. Thoughts community?

If Callaghan isn’t a long term hold (a late upgrade) for you then you might as well move him now. a game against Richmond is a pretty good entry point for any mid.
personally I think Finn will turn it around and end up a good value pick.

plus it depends on future plans, trades, finances, structure, byes and all that other boring shit.

 

[buttox]

Just
Clarke
Trainor e in the first one

 

[MacStradbroke]

T-minus two hours until potential 'delete team'

View attachment 2281540

Scythe waiting for final teams

 

[PoopingHindi]

just Trainor on bench without an E. can relax and enjoy the show.
hopefully the Tigers put up a fight.

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Be great if Tom Lynch can kick a few snags and score above 50 today!

 

[Scythe]

View attachment 2281547
Scythe waiting for final teams

Literally me for the past 24 hours lol

 

[Scythe]

Never taking this sort of risk again lmao

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Serong was going to be my (C) B4 I took TDK's (VC) score .....was it the right move? ....TWT

 

[SavDog23]

1759 with Clark, Trainor, Whitfield, Macrae, Travaglia to play.

 

[Petrify]

Oh shit I just remembered I traded Dudley into my bench. Oh well

 

[True Blue Saint]

Kelli is hilarious.

Cox receives a handball then comes under pressure: "OOOOH HE PLAYED ON!"