Trades 2025 Round 4 Trades

[Jiska]

Could you post a sticky at the top stating Bice is on the bubble this week.

Everyone knows Bice is on the bubble this week

 

[Deliverance]

Do we trust Maric off 1 decent score?

I'll watch against GWS this week. Plenty of other options around

 

[CotchyPls]

 

[gutsroy]

I'll watch against GWS this week. Plenty of other options around

Think where people see the upside /decent perspective is that he was already getting a strong share of kick-ins with McGovern in the side and now Gov is out for a stretch.
And there will be kick-ins galore.

 

[Veer Right]

View attachment 2268826

Trading out Neale when he has Richmond this week?

 

[iDon]

Baz vs Humph?

To be honest probably prefer Humph with his run, can still get baz next week, will be less increase then humph too.

 

[PoopingHindi]

Think where people see the upside /decent perspective is that he was already getting a string share of kick-ins with McGovern in the side and now Gov is out for a stretch.
And there will be kick-ins galore.

McGovern out means less pressure in defence so probably more goals and less behinds.
also, I’m not sure why everyone is so confident the coach won’t move players around to try to make the defence less shit.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Baz vs Humph?

To be honest probably prefer Humph with his run, can still get baz next week, will be less increase then humph too.

I’m still not sold on Baz’ fitness

 

[soreplums]

Any word on How long Lyndsay is out for?

 

[Choppers]

Any word on How long Lyndsay is out for?

1-2 wks

Injury Report | Windsor set for return

Check out Melbourne’s latest injury news ahead of Round 4

www.melbournefc.com.au

 

[gutsroy]

McGovern out means less pressure in defence so probably more goals and less behinds.
also, I’m not sure why everyone is so confident the coach won’t move players around to try to make the defence less shit.

Full disclosure: can realistically only.take one of Maric and Humphrey, leaning Humphrey.
Agree they could shuffle things around and how many mayflies like Z Fischer have there been over the years etc.?
Maric does use the ball better than many of those and if he's not dead weight as an actual defender, can see it working.
In terms of the defence, it's relative to the flood of ball heading down that way, they can do a decent job and still get 20 kicked on them, WC midfield goes to water without E Hewett

 

[CotchyPls]

Trading out Neale when he has Richmond this week?

View attachment 2268833

with absolute joy.. though i do feel bad for him as he has to come up against the greatest tagger of all time

 

[blueiris]

He's likely not going to be top-eight, but there are bigger priorities surely. 467k with a BE of 67 and won't lose cash any time soon – would definitely hold off on that just for now, even though he's a BOG average player these days.

As someone who needs forwards i can move Daniel to cover the oliver pick he'll make more money bring in Smith Murphy and Humphrey/Maric and as Someone who started Wash I'd back him over Oliver

My team after doing these trades -

Out -

Short
JHF
FOS


In

Sinclair
Maric
Humphrey


Only 5 rookies left on the field.

Am tempted to go Sheezel > Zorko instead of getting Humphrey

View attachment 2268777

Zorko is clearly the best defender ATM Coleman is still 5 to 6 weeks away from training if Coleman is the reason not to pick the Magician

 

[cacik]

Is maric a trap? Yes
Will I trade him in?

 

[blueiris]

View attachment 2268826

Rowell tag games coming up he scored a 60 against the Lions last season when tagged

 

[blueiris]

with absolute joy.. though i do feel bad for him as he has to come up against the greatest tagger of all time

View attachment 2268871

Yeah Neale will only score 150 against slow McIntosh

 

[A Bit Dusty]

This is how pissed off I am with my team. Nothing to lose might as well get rid of the dead wood before they are worth nothing. Leaves me with $1,013,000 ITB for next week

 

[Double the Fist]

Agree with the first sentence. It’s infuriating.

But surely even Goody can see that we ain’t winning a flag with the old crew, the window is definitely closed and it’s time to pump games in to the kids before Tasmania arrives.

So do I trade Petracca and piggy?

 

[Northernsoul74]

Gonna have to do the sensible thing and pass on Rowell and grab Baz instead

 

[A Bit Dusty]

So do I trade Petracca and piggy?

Clarry is a Hold.
Just traded Trac myself.

 

[Double the Fist]

there's a golf board, wtf, is it full of handicapped people or something

Yup. There is a golf board. It is in the hobbies section of this sport Forum.

 

[Double the Fist]

Clarry is a Hold.
Just traded Trac myself.

You don't think he'll make a good F5 or 6?

 

[Double the Fist]

He's likely not going to be top-eight, but there are bigger priorities surely. 467k with a BE of 67 and won't lose cash any time soon – would definitely hold off on that just for now, even though he's a BOG average player these days.

What is going on at Melbourne please? I havn't really heard or seen anything other than news a recent post match ruffled some feathers?

 

[Scythe]

What is going on at Melbourne please? I havn't really heard or seen anything other than news a recent post match ruffled some feathers?

Over the hill, flawed and unhappy playing list mixed with a moronic coach that would rather throw out corporate buzzwords and fluff about how much they love each other than come up with a tangible change to a gameplan/structure that hasn't been up to scratch for nearly four years now.

There's other things but that's the general gist lol

 

[A Bit Dusty]

You don't think he'll make a good F5 or 6?

Maybe later on in the season when the Demons have a new coach but not now.
I'm happy to trade him while he still has some value.

 

[SavDog23]

I’m still not sold on Baz’ fitness

I can see it now, Geelong are 80 points up on Melbourne in the 3rd quarter and Chris Scott decides to sub Baz out when he's on 70 SC points.