Game Day 2025 Round 4 Discussion

[sockets]

The sadistic, vindictive me wants Bice to miss this week to punish all those who traded him in early and now have one less headache this week.

Pin this post?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Pin this post?

*** any profanity contained here was simply a manifestation of the times, my youth and naivety

 

[Deliverance]

Hardwick for the coaches.

Cheated on his wife
Punchable face
Left Richmond as a basket case
Jumped on GC at prime time, to look like a hero, when he was "done with coaching "
Cheated on his wife

 

[Jiska]

Zorko
Jhf
Ginnivan
May
Oliver
Harley
Stringer
Just off the top of my head

Done

 

[JuddgementDay]

Toby is a player that you'd love to have in your side though

 

[Scythe]

Interrupting flog chat for a moment – how are we all feeling about our PODs so far (sub-20% for the sake of this exercise). My team basically hinges on this group (mixed results thus far)

• SPP and Prior are rookies, whatever
• Sinc I'm thrilled with
• Brayshaw I'm reasonably happy with
• Cripps I'm somewhat underwhelmed with, especially since I forked out an extra 140k or so to go from Cerra to him on the last day of PS (waste)
• Petracca I'm very underwhelmed with, but keeping faith for now and forward DPP might be nice
• Maric and Humpa are new, so can't judge yet

 

[Jiska]

Not many voting for “off the top of my head” buttox (except me)

 

[Jiska]

Interrupting flog chat for a moment – how are we all feeling about our PODs so far (sub-20% for the sake of this exercise). My team basically hinges on this group (mixed results thus far)

View attachment 2270404

• SPP and Prior are rookies, whatever
• Sinc I'm thrilled with
• Brayshaw I'm reasonably happy with
• Cripps I'm somewhat underwhelmed with, especially since I forked out an extra 140k or so to go from Cerra to him on the last day of PS (waste)
• Petracca I'm very underwhelmed with, but keeping faith for now and forward DPP might be nice
• Maric and Humpa are new, so can't judge yet

Maric and Humphrey will come in this week
Trac
Clark
Dawson
Dale
Cerra
Freijah
Gawn

 

[buttox]

Not many voting for “off the top of my head” buttox (except me)

Possible future polls for the next few weeks.
Coach flogs
X player flogs
Media flogs
Administration flogs for example President's.

 

[Deliverance]

Clark
Cerra
Trac

The rest are rookies and not much to report.

 

[Cactus_]

Hardwick for the coaches.

Cheated on his wife
Punchable face
Left Richmond as a basket case
Jumped on GC at prime time, to look like a hero, when he was "done with coaching "
Cheated on his wife

Couldn’t stand Hardwick when he was a player

One of those blokes who’d pretend to be spoiling the ball and punch his opponent in the back of the head

(Is there anyone who’s been a successful AFL coach who hasn’t been a complete Bastard?)

 

[Jiska]

Possible future polls for the next few weeks.
Coach flogs
X player flogs
Media flogs
Administration flogs for example President's.

Mod flogs?

 

[Deliverance]

Mod flogs?

Poster flogs? Let's blow this joint up

 

[Scythe]

Mod flogs?

 

[Jiska]

(Is there anyone who’s been a successful AFL coach who hasn’t been a complete Bastard?)

As a player? And what do you define as “success”? A flag? 50% win/loss? Long career?

Subjective, but if talking premiership coaches; Horse, Simmo, Goody, Beverage

 

[Jiska]

View attachment 2270430

 

[JuddgementDay]

Interrupting flog chat for a moment – how are we all feeling about our PODs so far (sub-20% for the sake of this exercise). My team basically hinges on this group (mixed results thus far)

View attachment 2270404

• SPP and Prior are rookies, whatever
• Sinc I'm thrilled with
• Brayshaw I'm reasonably happy with
• Cripps I'm somewhat underwhelmed with, especially since I forked out an extra 140k or so to go from Cerra to him on the last day of PS (waste)
• Petracca I'm very underwhelmed with, but keeping faith for now and forward DPP might be nice
• Maric and Humpa are new, so can't judge yet

I love PODs, but I often end up with POS

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Trav next weekend. Make money this one.

I mean watch this week, trade next week. Langford shouldn't be too far out of my range with his rise

 

[Nelso]

(Is there anyone who’s been a successful AFL coach who hasn’t been a complete Bastard?)

The last 2 premiership coaches in Fagan and McRae

 

[Andrewy]

The last 2 premiership coaches in Fagan and McRae

Mad Mickey Malthouse too

 

[Test Tickle]

 

[Jiska]

This is disappointing from Scott. Legit chance here for a late change.

Missing a week and a 20 in his rolling cycle almost makes him a trade ahead of FOS TBH.

 

[kyri]

was looking for any excuse to reverse lindsay back in..

 

[Sydney Kicker]

Possible future polls for the next few weeks.
Coach flogs
X player flogs
Media flogs
Administration flogs for example President's.

With coaches as far as SC is concerned, better off having a poll of which coach isn't a flog. Might have trouble finding three legit options though.

 

[Falchoon]

4th year in the system.
22 point average increase on his previous season.
Paid premium price.

JHF is definitely a 'premium' this system, and one of the most naturally talented and explosive young players in the game at his best.
He has a horrible attitude right now and is clearly low on some confidence, but it will turn at some point.
Back to back home games for the Power and he's been destroyed by the footy public all week.

Every chance he goes 120+ with his eyes closed over the next fortnight.

Generally does well against us.

Fanfooty says last year "head to head with Steele" & "matching up with Stocker"

This year expect "tagged by Windhager"