Teams 2025 Rate My Pre-Season Team

[A Bit Dusty]

Just a heads up kents if you didn't know you can copy & paste you team in one go clicking on this.

 

[Jiska]

Rock bottom rookie price is 99k. Prices have shifted downward to account for an extra player in the flex role.

Ahhh. Must have had a filter on. Cheapest DEF I could see was 119k.

They shouldn’t have adjusted for the flex role IMO and just left it as was.

Less generic full premo teams at years end,

 

[JDWCE]

1.0

All players below 150k placeholders.

Come at me.

View attachment 2193935

No petracca or Oliver at their prices. Can you give me the Melbourne fan insight on them and why you’re skipping them?

 

[Jiska]

No petracca or Oliver at their prices. Can you give me the Melbourne fan insight on them and why you’re skipping them?

That was 1.0
First time I’ve looked at AFL SC since August
I also hadn’t selected a Flex LOL
1.01

 

[Jiska]

Need Scythe94 to sell Rivers to me again.

Two seasons in the mid 80’s.

Where’s the improvement coming from? More mid time? Will he be a top 10 defender?

Not convinced. Spent a fair bit of time through the midfield last year as it was. Gun, absolutely, but a bonefide MID, doubtful. Kossie one year older and has the tank now, spent the summer training with midfield group. Windsor will go in there as well this year. Kolt was blooded early and earmarked in and under MID. Plus two top 10 draft picks spent on midfielders.

Clarry, Trac and Viney ain’t playing anywhere else. That’s a lot cycling through.

No offence to Scythe94 who's a gun at SC, but sometimes it's best to ignore posters on the teams they support as they can be too optimistic about their own players.

Agree. Exception is rookies or bonefide premos.

Nice structure though.

Mills at D4 makes me feel a bit more comfortable.

**** the structure. Most points wins, regardless of where the points come from.

I’m hesitant on Mills. But for that price, down back, can’t see him losing money.

 

[Jiska]

Lot of love for Phillipou in these parts. Why? Plenty of speculatives at that price. What’d I miss?

 

[VainGlorious]

Kiddy injury? But you have Mills, Oliver, Petracca, B Smith and T Lynch. Take the leap.

Kiddy is doubtful for round 1.

 

[VainGlorious]

Lot of love for Phillipou in these parts. Why? Plenty of speculatives at that price. What’d I miss?

Slated for more mid time next year and is training with the midfield group.

Played the last 4 games as a mid and averaged 94.

That’s the thinking behind the selection.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Slated for more mid time next year and is training with the midfield group.

Played the last 4 games as a mid and averaged 94.

That’s the thinking behind the selection.

Early prediction - Philipou will be the player "everyone" says to pick and "everyone" gets the blame for Jiska picking/not picking him.

Lot of love for Phillipou in these parts. Why? Plenty of speculatives at that price. What’d I miss?

St Kilda games late in the season? Anyone will eyes can see the upside there.

Merry Christmas all btw

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Current stab.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Merry Christmas all btw

Not everyone had a great Christmas ......gee those SC Port supporters are cruel ! ....what say you Nelso

 

[Lindsay_Gilbee]

Anyone starting to go a bit cold on Sheezel? So much money. Think the tag might become an issue.

 

[Nelso]

Not no one.

Christian Moraes is the other one @ Alberton turning heads apparently
or is this not correct Nelso

Sorry for the late reply.

Berry is locked and loaded when I eventually get around to doing my team. He has no competition for the small forward role apart from Rioli and both of them can play in the same team.

Moraes has impressed a lot of people with his work ethic and willingness to get involved. Port have had to hold him back for his own good from certain parts of training in the lead up to the XMAS break. Not sure he will make the round one team as SPP will hopefully be back by then.

Sinn will be given first opportunity to replace Houston on the back flank.

The one to look out for is for Lorenz. Not sure what his price is for 2025? Hinkley made a fatal mistake last year by not giving him more games ahead of spuds like Evans, Narkle and McEntee.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Sorry for the late reply.

Berry is locked and loaded when I eventually get around to doing my team. He has no competition for the small forward role apart from Rioli and both of them can play in the same team.

Moraes has impressed a lot of people with his work ethic and willingness to get involved. Port have had to hold him back for his own good from certain parts of training in the lead up to the XMAS break. Not sure he will make the round one team as SPP will hopefully be back by then.

Sinn will be given first opportunity to replace Houston on the back flank.

The one to look out for is for Lorenz. Not sure what his price is for 2025? Hinkley made a fatal mistake last year by not giving him more games ahead of spuds like Evans, Narkle and McEntee.

Lorenz is $120k

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Anyone starting to go a bit cold on Sheezel? So much money. Think the tag might become an issue.

Yep, I haven't taken Sheezel .....will he be top 2 in Defenders, yes .....but I don't think he'll take the game away from me, particularly if I use the savings elsewhere

I agree, surely teams will put more effort into Sheezel, with NORTH on the rise

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Yep, I haven't taken Sheezel .....will he be top 2 in Defenders, yes .....but I don't think he'll take the game away from me, particularly if I use the savings elsewhere

I agree, surely teams will put more effort into Sheezel, with NORTH on the rise

There aren't that many good defender options if you take out those that have the early bye.
Sheezel will get DPP in Round 6 as well.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

There aren't that many good defender options if you take out those that have the early bye.
Sheezel will get DPP in Round 6 as well.

I'm also wary of all the R12 Bye players ....Bont, JHF, Butters, Xerri, T. De Koning, Caleb Daniel ect