Opinion 2025 Player X v Y v Z

[Cactus_]

Everyone jumping on Serong must not remember his position move in the last half of games because the brayshaw, serong, young midfield was just not working. With addition to Bolton will he be back to the main midfield rotation or will he be still be playing stints in the forward line? His Scoring dropped off after the bye with only 1 120+ score and a fair few 80-90 scores. Similar happened to Dangerfield. Spent more time forward which capped his scoring potential from a 130+ to 100+

Brayshaw after the move for Serong now scores higher.

This is what I come here for

 

[Cactus_]

Everyone jumping on Serong must not remember his position move in the last half of games because the brayshaw, serong, young midfield was just not working. With addition to Bolton will he be back to the main midfield rotation or will he be still be playing stints in the forward line? His Scoring dropped off after the bye with only 1 120+ score and a fair few 80-90 scores. Similar happened to Dangerfield. Spent more time forward which capped his scoring potential from a 130+ to 100+

Brayshaw after the move for Serong now scores higher.

And you’re not wrong Ash

Just had a look on TooSerious

Serong’s big scores clumped towards the start of the year, Brayshaw’s towards the end

Most informative post I’ve read this year

 

[Cactus_]

I’ll happily take any other insights that you’re happy to share Ash1337

 

[Choppers]

And you’re not wrong Ash

Just had a look on TooSerious

Serong’s big scores clumped towards the start of the year, Brayshaw’s towards the end

Most informative post I’ve read this year

Chips and straws.......

Serong av 106 since the bye with 7x 100s and total points of 2661
Brayshaw av 109 since the bye with 8 x100s and total points 2526
Serong is 32K dearer

With Bolton coming in, who knows who it will impact.......I don't....

So I reckon it boils down to personal opinion..so I think I'll stick with Serong at this stage, as long as he doesn't get injured beforehand...

 

[VainGlorious]

Short (D3) Flynn (R3) Rankine (F1)

V

Sinc (D2) Loop (R3) JHF (F1)

 

[Choppers]

Short (D3) Flynn (R3) Rankine (F1)

V

Sinc (D2) Loop (R3) JHF (F1)

I have Short (D3) JHF (F1) and Sinc (Flex)

 

[King_Steele]

JHF & Coleman
V
Parker & Short

 

[Lord De Goey]

Chips and straws.......

Serong av 106 since the bye with 7x 100s and total points of 2661
Brayshaw av 109 since the bye with 8 x100s and total points 2526
Serong is 32K dearer

With Bolton coming in, who knows who it will impact.......I don't....

So I reckon it boils down to personal opinion..so I think I'll stick with Serong at this stage, as long as he doesn't get injured beforehand...

It wasn’t just like Serong was the only one getting moved around anyway, all of them were. Young another great example of one that spent time forward, even back at times too.

Serong was the number 1 guy when they played their best footy last year. Young is their most damaging mid and if he starts to cop a few tags Serong becomes a must start imo

 

[A Bit Dusty]

JHF & Coleman
V
Parker & Short

Tough call only JHF is the only keeper from that lot.
If Coleman plays early then he is a lock. Really not sure about the other 2 although I am starting Short.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

It wasn’t just like Serong was the only one getting moved around anyway, all of them were. Young another great example of one that spent time forward, even back at times too.

Serong was the number 1 guy when they played their best footy last year. Young is their most damaging mid and if he starts to cop a few tags Serong becomes a must start imo

I like all of Serong/Sprayshaw/Young as picks. Buggered if I know which one goes the best this year though. Young the cheapest, like Serong the most, got Spraw in my team currently.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I like all of Serong/Sprayshaw/Young as picks. Buggered if I know which one goes the best this year though. Young the cheapest, like Serong the most, got Spraw in my team currently.

Young just signed a new 33 year Contract .....there'll be the usual letdown whilst Young organises his investment portfolio

 

[St Steady]

JHF & Coleman
V
Parker & Short

same thoughts as dusty, ive only got jhf in mind so far of those, even tho they have all been in my play around sides at some point. kiddy maybe after the bye if hes actually up and about. (ive currently plonked sinn 230k at d5 atm, so he may go into that spot)

 

[St Steady]

one thing i do think, is we dont give WC/freo/port/adel as much consideration when building our sides as we do the east coast teams,

 

[A Bit Dusty]

one thing i do think, is we dont give WC/freo/port/adel as much consideration when building our sides as we do the east coast teams,

I'm not so sure about that!!!
WC/Freo/Port/Adel make up 22.2% of the competition.
That means from 31 players next season you only need 7 players from these clubs combined to = 22.58% of your team.

 

[Northernsoul74]

I'm not so sure about that!!!
WC/Freo/Port/Adel make up 22.2% of the competition.
That means from 31 players next season you only need 7 players from these clubs combined to = 22.58% of your team.

 

[Seymour Skinner]

JHF & Coleman
V
Parker & Short

The one that doesn't have Luke Parker