2025 Hypothetical Trade Discussion

[eldorado]

Want to discuss your plan to get Harley Reid for Carlton's 2nd and Jasper Scaife's little brother! Here's the place!

You can envisage how we turn Ned Reeves into West Coast's future 1st, with a sweetener coming back our way as well? Knock yourself out!

You spent the last week concocting a 5-club, 6-player, 8 draft pick mega-trade, with every club a winner? You're home!





In all seriousness, please use THIS thread to document your OWN thoughts on who you might trade, who you like from other clubs, who you'd trade from our club, and how you think deals could get done.. HERE! IS THE PLACE!!

Please keep the trade discussion thread for actual news and updates that have some external validity...which could be a media article, a genuine bit of ITK conversation you had, etc etc

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

You’ve changed man

 

[RCAB]

 

[MazHawk]

Finally! A thread I can read when I need a laugh.

 

[eldorado]

You’ve changed man

Every day, just a little bit more curmudgeon-like...

 

[Dixie Flatline]

Two first round picks to Port Adelaide in exchange for Shaun Burgoyne. Who says 'no'?

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Just keep losing please Carlolton.

 

[Sirlemsip]

Just keep losing please Carlolton.

I want them to win this week against the Eagles though... if they lose this week then Voss is 100% gone - and they will win more games with the coach chair being empty than with Voss in charge.

 

[grumbleguts]

So where does Luke Breust end up this year?

 

[SSSSSS]

So where does Luke Breust end up this year?

On the Premiership dais.

 

[RCAB]

I want them to win this week against the Eagles though... if they lose this week then Voss is 100% gone - and they will win more games with the coach chair being empty than with Voss in charge.

You really think they will sack Voss this week if they lose?

 

[Sirlemsip]

You really think they will sack Voss this week if they lose?

Yes

 

[PenAndPaper]

You really think they will sack Voss this week if they lose?

Absolutely, if they lose this week they have already lost to the two teams most would say are the worst in the comp in Tigers/Eagles.

 

[TONYC3163]

Voss may fall on his own sword if Carlton lose - position will become untenable.
Carlton don’t cope well with losing.

 

[hardway]

Voss may fall on his own sword if Carlton lose - position will become untenable.
Carlton don’t cope well with losing.

I like them enjoying individual glory with Brownlows , the Judd effect I call it. Takes their eyes off what glory in team sport truly means.

 

[The Jet From Poowong]

Voss may fall on his own sword if Carlton lose - position will become untenable.
Carlton don’t cope well with losing.

You would think after two decades they would be accustomed to it

 

[unitedhawk2]

So, this thread was created this morning because hypothetical trades were being posted in some other thread and now, within a few hours, this thread has posts that probably belong in the Carltank thread.

I do not envy the mods their jobs - and I say that in all seriousness.

 

[bigbuddyboy]

Saw some stories on clubs circling Ramsden. He’s contracted and I hope we don’t get rid of him!

He’d be a great pickup for another club.

 

[Red4]

Saw some stories on clubs circling Ramsden. He’s contracted and I hope we don’t get rid of him!

He’d be a great pickup for another club.

Definitely trade reeves and give ramsden the backup spot

 

[Mr Meeseeks]

Saw some stories on clubs circling Ramsden. He’s contracted and I hope we don’t get rid of him!

He’d be a great pickup for another club.

Im just not sold on him. If the Hawks can get something worthwhile for him I will be happy.

Hawks fan as a kid so he might not be so keen though.

 

[bigbuddyboy]

Im just not sold on him. If the Hawks can get something worthwhile for him I will be happy.

Hawks fan as a kid so he might not be so keen though.

I don’t think we could ask for anything of real value for him to be honest, so I’d rather keep him.

He’s young for a ruck. Even our own Lord Meek took a while to get going.

 

[The Jet From Poowong]

I don’t think we could ask for anything of real value for him to be honest, so I’d rather keep him.

He’s young for a ruck. Even our own Lord Meek took a while to get going.

The difference is that Ramsden isnt a first ruck, and secondly Meek was dominating at the VFL/WAFL before being given his chance. Something Max has not shown to date. He should absolutely consider the best offer, as it might be his last at this level

 

[grumbleguts]

Judging by tonight's game Geelong would have to be the front runners for Harley. They could trade Nick Foot, Curtis Deboy, Brendan Hosking, and Robert Findlay.

 

[Dewnior]

The difference is that Ramsden isnt a first ruck, and secondly Meek was dominating at the VFL/WAFL before being given his chance. Something Max has not shown to date. He should absolutely consider the best offer, as it might be his last at this level

TDK didn't show much in his first 5 years. Max is 4 years his junior.

 

[The Jet From Poowong]

TDK didn't show much in his first 5 years. Max is 4 years his junior.

He isn’t a ruckman. Why people get so defensive when the proof is there at VFL level, is beyond explanation. I haven’t even stated anything about his efforts at AFL level as there is nothing to comment about

He is tall. And he runs. Great.