Remove this Banner Ad

Discussion 2025 General AFL Discussion

  • Thread starter Thread starter sammm
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Not his fault he's playing with washed up old has-beens like Schultz, Daicos, and Hill...
Schultz getting dumped on his ass by Toby Greene was so funny. Should have been a 50 paid to Toby, of course, but I think the umpire knew enough emotional damage had been done.

Thoroughly emasculated in one moment.
 
Sidebottom, Membrey and even Pendlebury are way too slow. Pies are in for a very long year.


I think we will finally see McCrae get exposed for being a terrible coach. Inherited a good list, and got lucky. Now he’s riding them into the ground
Loaded up on older recruits and kept past it players like Pendlenury and Sidebottom.

An absolute travesty of a draft coming up. Collingwood in the wilderness until 2030.

On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Yep, line through the pies this year. Oldest list in the AFL, a full year older than rank 2. Most experienced list with an average over 100 games.

Will start a lot of games strong but they looked extra flat in the second half, will be run over the top plenty.
 
I take a more 'us vs them' view. Anything that means another team is leesslikely to beat us I'll take. Not very charitable or kind I know.
I think that is truth.

Just think how many oppo teams we have given a leg up to due to our own misfortune.

Now Pretracca has busted ribs, Collingwood and Port hit hard again…

And today, I was lamenting the loss of Membrey, thinking he could have been re-purposed as an emergency defender. So I took a peep, and noticed he kicked a goal and almost two, but I don’t think he set the world on fire in Sydney today.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Sidebottom, Membrey and even Pendlebury are way too slow. Pies are in for a very long year.


I think we will finally see McCrae get exposed for being a terrible coach. Inherited a good list, and got lucky. Now he’s riding them into the ground
Potentially a long decade if you look at the under 24s on their list and their lack of draft picks.
 
Enjoyable to watch the Pies get flogged by GWS who made them look old and slow and Membrey didn't help in that department.

They were all talking him up as a steal after he kicked 3 goals in a practice game against Richmond but he was a liability today.

He was still better than Schultz though who they gave up draft picks for, Membrey didn't cost them anything other than a salary.
 
Missed when they hit him up perfectly and he dropped ab absolute pudding?

I’d be more worried about Pendles. He looks too slow all of a sudden
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Pies annihilated. But we've been hearing all pre-season from the "experts" how good they'll be.
Shows how much they know. Or actually don’t know. I wonder what people like Kane and Gerard will say?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom