List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread - No.3

[seasonedsainter]

According to the Herald pick 8 is next to no chance to be used by us on Draft night. Every chance it’s traded for GWS 2 x mid teen picks.

That would be ideal I think. Best available mid with 7. Let Dalrymple stake his claim thereafter.

 

[LeonardHayes87]

That would be ideal I think. Best available mid with 7. Let Dalrymple stake his claim thereafter.

Seems the belief is there is 6-7 standout players and then a group of 10 approx in the level below. If you split 8 into a couple of teens picks you get two bites of the cherry which makes sense. If we had 3 top 20 picks and got 2 mids plus a tall (one of Whitlock twins or Shanahan) that’s a bloody good haul to add to Wilson NAS Garcia Phillipou Owens Windhager etc.

 

[The_Steadier]

As long as we’re keeping our f1

Why?

Next year onward everyone can trade multiple future years picks right?

If we get a good deal for our 2025 first we should take it

 

[SteeleSaints]

Why?

Next year onward everyone can trade multiple future years picks right?

If we get a good deal for our 2025 first we should take it

The other consideration next year is of the 94 players involved in futures games this year as 17yo's - 46 are tied to clubs. Almost half the kids next year will have restricted availability. Given the rule changes a few will slip out of clubs grasps but that number is ridiculous. Then two years later Tasmania enter and that will make the draft a total white wash for a few seasons after.

The AFL have basically re created the old Zones recruiting again and currently they dont have a path to circumvent it.

 

[hayes]

According to the Herald pick 8 is next to no chance to be used by us on Draft night. Every chance it’s traded for GWS 2 x mid teen picks.

Obviously we won’t know the results of this for years but I’m not a big fan of it. Top 10 picks are like gold and we get two cracks at getting a gun midfielder instead of one. This is very Pelchen-ey.

 

[akaifu]

Obviously we won’t know the results of this for years but I’m not a big fan of it. Top 10 picks are like gold and we get two cracks at getting a gun midfielder instead of one. This is very Pelchen-ey.

Unlikely there’ll be a gun mid at pick 8

 

[Dard Ball Get]

Unlikely there’ll be a gun mid at pick 8

Absolute unadulterated rubbish to state this as fact.

 

[akaifu]

Absolute unadulterated rubbish to state this as fact.

Who stated anything as fact?

 

[BigMonty]

Take Reid if rest are gone and then see who bites for 8 or take Tauru.

With Hall and Carroll, we do not have a lot of list spots left if we take Cole Hoffman Peckett and Sandy player.

7,8,32 fills the list, unless we delist or out Crouch on long term injury.


On SM-S916B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[The_Steadier]

Take Reid if rest are gone and then see who bites for 8 or take Tauru.

With Hall and Carroll, we do not have a lot of list spots left if we take Cole Hoffman Peckett and Sandy player.

7,8,32 fills the list, unless we delist or out Crouch on long term injury.


On SM-S916B using BigFooty.com mobile app

Availability of list spots is a small potatoes concern.

If (based on who is on the board at 8 and who we think will be there with teens pics)... we think splitting 8 gets us closer to a flag- then we do it.

Number of available list spots plays zero part in that decision.

List spots is a consideration for small potatoes stuff like whether to take a peckett or not.

 

[hayes]

Unlikely there’ll be a gun mid at pick 8

Everyone’s saying this is one of the great drafts. We already played ourselves out of the real high end by winning meaningless games I don’t think we should be dropping any further with either pick.

 

[ScrappyDo]

Everyone’s saying this is one of the great drafts. We already played ourselves out of the real high end by winning meaningless games I don’t think we should be dropping any further with either pick.

None of that statement holds water.

 

[saintmike65]

Do you think Hugo Garcia will be a good player from what you've seen in the minimal quarter's he has played in his 9 games

Hugo has the combination of speed and endurance plus a great work ethic & hunger to get better..

 

[Tommy Wigs]

The other consideration next year is of the 94 players involved in futures games this year as 17yo's - 46 are tied to clubs. Almost half the kids next year will have restricted availability. Given the rule changes a few will slip out of clubs grasps but that number is ridiculous. Then two years later Tasmania enter and that will make the draft a total white wash for a few seasons after.

The AFL have basically re created the old Zones recruiting again and currently they dont have a path to circumvent it.

And even though the points are being modified somewhat, the points are the same whether it is a good draft or potentially a weaker one. They’ll be constantly topping up through next year and the Tassie drafts, while other clubs will have very slim pickings.

Free agents will become critical for everyone.

 

[snails13]

I just watched WA SEN yesterday 's morning edition and Mick Ablett mentioned WAFL Ruckman Lachy Blakiston has had a medical with Saints recently
Sorry if already mentioned

 

[tommo7]

Hawks have their sites set on LDU according to Jon Ralph

 

[jumperfan]

Hawks have their sites set on LDU according to Jon Ralph

Surely they won't be able to afford him? Their young guns are going to want pay rises and they've got some pretty big contracts on their books already.

 

[GYoung]

Surely they won't be able to afford him? Their young guns are going to want pay rises and they've got some pretty big contracts on their books already.

we need to have a season that would attract LDU to us

 

[Train12]

we need to have a season that would attract LDU to us

We sure do!!!

 

[dudeintheswamp]

Be nice to see the Hawks slide down next season.

 

[Saints4ever]

Be nice to see the Hawks slide down next season.

View attachment 2163722

Couldn’t agree more with this.
Bunch of arrogant flogs.

 

[Mowman]

Unlikely there’ll be a gun mid at pick 8

Oh Please lol

 

[Saints4ever]

Oh Please lol

Exactly.
Only have to go back 5 years.
Pick 8 Caleb Serong

 

[Saints4ever]

Pick 8 Jimmy Bartel.
Geez that would be nice.

 

[akaifu]

Oh Please lol

Lalor FOS Jagga Draper Smillie Langford. 6 players. 7 picks before 8

Oh please