List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread - No.3

[snails13]

Alright sports fans here’s my final hopes for the draft.

7: Smillie/Langford/Smith/Draper

Live trade picks 8, 32 and F3 for 15, 16, 21.

15: Reid

16: Shanahan

21: Trainor


Now the planets just need to align perfectly and we’re sorted.

Have read a few other teams threads tonight and most of them have mentioned GWS trading 16 & 21 to Port for 13 & 29

 

[The_Steadier]

Have read a few other teams threads tonight and most of them have mentioned GWS trading 16 & 21 to Port for 13 & 29

Hopefully somebody has a huge boner for a player still on the board at pick 8 and is willing to give us an awesome deal for it.

If not- we take best available and carry on.

 

[bakes10]

Hopefully somebody has a huge boner for a player still on the board at pick 8 and is willing to give us an awesome deal for it.

If not- we take best available and carry on.

There's every chance this happens.

Now I know that this a great draft by all means, but let's not forget that there are players out of contract next year like Finn Callaghan and Leek Aleer which we'll target and which we'll need to fast track our premiership push. We'll need picks.

So let's say on draft night that Tauru is still available at Pick 8 and North come to us saying they want our pick because they want him. We say no worries, give us your F1 and F2 knowing that North will probably finish on the bottom of the ladder next year and we'll pocket Pick 1. Thoughts?

 

[HeavenlySources]

There's every chance this happens.

Now I know that this a great draft by all means, but let's not forget that there are players out of contract next year like Finn Callaghan and Leek Aleer which we'll target and which we'll need to fast track our premiership push. We'll need picks.

So let's say on draft night that Tauru is still available at Pick 8 and North come to us saying they want our pick because they want him. We say no worries, give us your F1 and F2 knowing that North will probably finish on the bottom of the ladder next year and we'll pocket Pick 1. Thoughts?

Id value Norths Future 1 at Pick 12-16 in this year’s draft, similar to ours. We’d need atleast F1+F2 if not more..

 

[snails13]

There's every chance this happens.

Now I know that this a great draft by all means, but let's not forget that there are players out of contract next year like Finn Callaghan and Leek Aleer which we'll target and which we'll need to fast track our premiership push. We'll need picks.

So let's say on draft night that Tauru is still available at Pick 8 and North come to us saying they want our pick because they want him. We say no worries, give us your F1 and F2 knowing that North will probably finish on the bottom of the ladder next year and we'll pocket Pick 1. Thoughts?

Apparently this Draft is far superior to next so why would we give up a great pick to drop down to 1x1st round pick.
And we are not likely to get Free Agents if we are not winning games

 

[Rogue Warrior]

There's every chance this happens.

Now I know that this a great draft by all means, but let's not forget that there are players out of contract next year like Finn Callaghan and Leek Aleer which we'll target and which we'll need to fast track our premiership push. We'll need picks.

So let's say on draft night that Tauru is still available at Pick 8 and North come to us saying they want our pick because they want him. We say no worries, give us your F1 and F2 knowing that North will probably finish on the bottom of the ladder next year and we'll pocket Pick 1. Thoughts?

Given you can trade futures 2 years into the future. I don’t see having no 1st round pick next year a limitation to getting someone in. + if they are out of contract and we have a commitment from the player we can be absolutely c**nts in the negotiation and force the team to take unders (ala Geelongs approach).

 

[bakes10]

Given you can trade futures 2 years into the future. I don’t see having no 1st round pick next year a limitation to getting someone in. + if they are out of contract and we have a commitment from the player we can be absolutely c**nts in the negotiation and force the team to take unders (ala Geelongs approach).

Yes, this makes sense, You can only give what you've got.

Anyway I still thinking getting next years F1 from North (which may end up being Pick 1 or Pick 2) is worth considering.

Let's see how it all plays out !

 

[goodie23]

Hopefully somebody has a huge boner for a player still on the board at pick 8 and is willing to give us an awesome deal for it.

If not- we take best available and carry on.

And/or someone desperate to leapfrog Melbourne

 

[joydivision22]

Our future fires is probably worth around 25 this year and probably still worth it. Not the end of the world to keep it though. Cristian Moraes was considered top 5 this time last year.

 

[austinnn]

There's every chance this happens.

Now I know that this a great draft by all means, but let's not forget that there are players out of contract next year like Finn Callaghan and Leek Aleer which we'll target and which we'll need to fast track our premiership push. We'll need picks.

So let's say on draft night that Tauru is still available at Pick 8 and North come to us saying they want our pick because they want him. We say no worries, give us your F1 and F2 knowing that North will probably finish on the bottom of the ladder next year and we'll pocket Pick 1. Thoughts?

Not trading out of this draft. End of discussion.

 

[gringo2011]

Apparently this Draft is far superior to next so why would we give up a great pick to drop down to 1x1st round pick.
And we are not likely to get Free Agents if we are not winning games

It's deep this year. Not sure about better. Next year a few players will push up. Giving up our first pick shouldn't be done lightly.

 

[Rogue Warrior]

Not trading out of this draft. End of discussion.

It’s a footy forum. If we can’t discuss every single logical and absurd possible outcome to death, what are we doing here

 

[austinnn]

It’s a footy forum. If we can’t discuss every single logical and absurd possible outcome to death, what are we doing here [emoji23]

Yeah sorry, I didn't phrase that well. Let me try again:

If St Kilda allows themselves to get traded out of this draft with the only compensation being trading into a heavily compromised draft a year later, it would be Pelchen-level idiotic and throw my confidence on the incumbent St Kilda decisionmakers and this generation of the club's success into severe doubt.

That's the extent of my opinion on the matter and I will not be convinced otherwise, and I reserve the right to disregard the opinion of any poster who considers this idea as a legitimate positive move for the club on any future matter.

 

[dudeintheswamp]

Well, four days till the draft and the trade period seems a long time ago now. To help pass the time, here's a song I wrote back then about Trade Radio, two minutes and six seconds of your life you'll never get back...

View attachment Tryhard Radio.mp3

 

[saintbill]

Well, four days till the draft and the trade period seems a long time ago now. To help pass the time, here's a song I wrote back then about Trade Radio, two minutes and six seconds of your life you'll never get back...

View attachment 2166601

Ha ha, very catchy. Well done.

 

[Saint Ray]

Well, four days till the draft and the trade period seems a long time ago now. To help pass the time, here's a song I wrote back then about Trade Radio, two minutes and six seconds of your life you'll never get back...

View attachment 2166601

Pass