- Aug 9, 2019
- 35,331
- 61,543
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Panthers, GWV Rebels, Central Augusta
Nah best 18Perryman would be a top 10 player in our team. He goes in past almost everyone
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: Sydney v Port Adelaide - 7:40 / 7:10 Fri
Squiggle tips Swans at 57% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
LIVE: Geelong v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Cats at 54% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Prelim Finals
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Nah best 18Perryman would be a top 10 player in our team. He goes in past almost everyone
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Can I ask how so many posters know we didnt ask about, or even pursue, Hollands? Look perhaps (probably?) we didnt - I really have no idea but just interested how others are aware (perhaps I have missed official comms from the club confirming we had no interest in him etc).Well, yeah. I would have absolutely agreed with pursuing Hollands, so I'm not disagreeing there.
But I think Perryman rolls into the combo mid role - he's not the purely inside of Laird/Crouch, and he's not Rankine who's distributes from the outside. But he has a midfield role, I think, especially with Dawson taking oin other roles at times.
Not sure where we’d actually play Perryman so including both inside and outside players (including half backs).Perryman would be a top 10 player in our team. He goes in past almost everyone
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Which SANFL club is Neddy playing for?At least Neddy will have a fishing mate if we recruit Perryman who is also a dedicated fisho...
firstly remember alot of this speculation ends up being wrong. Remember the rumoured Rankine at 5 years on 850k etc. And Yeo at 900k for 3 years. I would be very surprised if 850k is true thinking about it further esp if its 150-200k above GWS and Horks offer. But yes we are in a high inflation environment and players are getting crazy $ so maybe it is. We just dont know for sure.Yeah surely we could have taken a huge chunk of this Perryman money and allocated it for Moyle
Glad we're going hard for Perryman and Cumming. We have tons of cap space, they'd improve our 23, and they'd raise the competitive standard/pressure across the entire list. No-brainers. The only small risk is that the money we'd be paying them upsets some other players.
Of course we can improve it, if we target areas that need improving. Like our core midfield with elite talent, our small forward stocks, our ruck.
Does Perryman actually improve our team significantly, to the tune of $5 million, instead of playing someone we already have?
He's a good player, but he's closer to the role player end of the scale than star end of the scale. So the question has to be asked whether it's worth that sort of cash to replace one of our role players off half back, the wing, 2nd midfield rotation
Oh well, seeya.
Both Crouch and Laird need to go. Spreadless, damageless stat padders make us worse. Anything that allows those 2 to be moved on or played away from our midfield instantly makes us better. As long as it’s not a like for like swap.
At least Neddy will have a fishing mate if we recruit Perryman who is also a dedicated fisho...
Would love to see a breakdown of players who are on front loaded contracts who in turn demand a trade while still under contract.
I think you are overrating Perryman. He's a role player in positions we're not desperate for and have decent youth coming through.
I mean as a club we're passing on players like Elijah Hollands (or just not making any offer at all) which would have cost us a junk pick and a much lower salary, then handing over $850k for Perryman? Madness
Personally think his continuing non selection is illuminating. GONESKI in my view.I reckon Ned is genuine 50/50 to stay on the list. I suspect he may be Jimmy Rowed (signed or delist based on who ends up coming in via draft and trade)
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Do you honestly believe the club would recruit Perryman to replace Crouch or Laird?
He'd be replacing the Nankervis, Dowling, Taylor, Cook types in our side
Keeler's not a ruck he's played a mix of Key Forward and Key Back for the Sandringham Zebras, Key Forward last year and Key Back this year, Barnett is struggling at WAFL level, Goad has been awful at VFL even considering he's very raw, appears miles off it.Any news on any of the SA developmental rucks that are currently in the 2's of other teams?
I.e. Keeler, Barnett, Goad etc?
Can't recall seeing any of them playing at AFL level, but that doesn't mean they wouldn't be a walk on improvement to our ruck situation
What did he go for? Packet of chips on a 1 year deal?Can I ask how so many posters know we didnt ask about, or even pursue, Hollands? Look perhaps (probably?) we didnt - I really have no idea but just interested how others are aware (perhaps I have missed official comms from the club confirming we had no interest in him etc).
But I know for a 100% FACT we have chased quality players in recent years and the information was never even speculated about in the media.
Keane also a possible departure. He’s contracted, I like him and I’d be holding him to contract unless the deal was firmly in our favourPersonally think his continuing non selection is illuminating. GONESKI in my view.
Besides Sloane and Parnell (small chance Tex goes) are there any more obvious cuts to make? (Dragon likely Giants bound and Berry to Saints rumour seems to have traction with Berry putting off contract talks - I expect he is gone and we need to get Saints second rounder). Some assumed outs like Sholl and Bond have firmed up their positions recently.
Ned’s Manager almost seemed resigned to the fact he was getting flicked the other week in his public messaging
Nord, he’d fit inWhich SANFL club is Neddy playing for?
I reckon Ned is genuine 50/50 to stay on the list. I suspect he may be Jimmy Rowed (signed or delist based on who ends up coming in via draft and trade)
For example if we were to get a Benny Barrett then he would likely be gone - if no similar player comes in then he would get another year. Will be interesting how that rolls
Of course Benny is likely out of our reach now even if we wanted him based on the AFL mooted rule changes from yesterday
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Nah, we don’t take scrubbersNord, he’d fit in
OK good to know. Do you think Barnett would be worth a list spot if he became available?Keeler's not a ruck he's played a mix of Key Forward and Key Back for the Sandringham Zebras, Key Forward last year and Key Back this year, Barnett is struggling at WAFL level, Goad has been awful at VFL even considering he's very raw, appears miles off it.
You'd have to be joking re an improvement on O'Brien and Strachan, none of them would geta look in against our 2 blokes currently.
I thought it was initially a longer contract offered that then got cut down at the last moment with both parties consent after the drug charge?What did he go for? Packet of chips on a 1 year deal?
Don’t think we were too excited by him.
Also note that Keane & Parnell are both on the rookie list, so their departures do not automatically create a vacancy on the senior list.Keane also a possible departure. He’s contracted, I like him and I’d be holding him to contract unless the deal was firmly in our favour
Either way the evidence would suggest we weren’t overly interestedI thought it was initially a longer contract offered that then got cut down at the last moment with both parties consent after the drug charge?
We probably enquired, but were told "no thanks" - given all the reasons he had for joining Carlton.Either way the evidence would suggest we weren’t overly interested
Keeler's not a ruck he's played a mix of Key Forward and Key Back for the Sandringham Zebras, Key Forward last year and Key Back this year, Barnett is struggling at WAFL level, Goad has been awful at VFL even considering he's very raw, appears miles off it.
You'd have to be joking re an improvement on O'Brien and Strachan, none of them would geta look in against our 2 blokes currently.