List Mgmt. 2024 National Draft - November 20-21

[Jen2310]

 

[sr36]

Is the shin bone connected to the knee bone and the knee bone connected to the thigh bone

Watching North play, I think the shin bone is connected to the arse bone or some other shitting bone.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

I think that’s the sesamoid? Same as Scharenberg and Thomas.

Clancy Dennis’ injury was described by Shifter as an ankle injury, so it’s not navicular or sesamoid if he’s to be believed.

 

[Apex36]

Clancy Dennis’ injury was described by Shifter as an ankle injury, so it’s not navicular or sesamoid if he’s to be believed.

True, but I’m not sure Shifter is the poster boy of using correct medical terminology either.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

True, but I’m not sure Shifter is the poster boy of using correct medical terminology either.

No doubt.

 

[sr36]

True, but I’m not sure Shifter is the poster boy of using correct medical terminology either.

He got his name from shifting injuries from one part of the body to another.

 

[Apex36]

I doubt we would of Bid IF we thought they where going to Match

Make Leppa look like a Lyer after the Interview after the Draft Saying they thought Swans would Pass and that why we put a Bid on him

Of course we’d have bid. You don’t know if you don’t try.

 

[Jen2310]

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Of course we’d have bid. You don’t know if you don’t try.

Yeah, people massively overthink the thought process of the bidding process.

If he's on top of your board, you bid.

If they match, you move to the next player on your board.

If they don't, you just drafted the player on top of your board, and as a bonus, it's someone you probably presumed you wouldn't get access to, so your draft pool just got bigger.

Presuming that neither Luca Greggo or Cooper Bell (the two players drafted in between our picks) were on our board in between where we had Cochran and where we had West, it's pretty safe to assume that had Sydney matched our bid for Cochran, we would then have drafted Charlie West in that spot.

 

[TradeDraft]

Yeah, people massively overthink the thought process of the bidding process.

If he's on top of your board, you bid.

If they match, you move to the next player on your board.

If they don't, you just drafted the player on top of your board, and as a bonus, it's someone you probably presumed you wouldn't get access to, so your draft pool just got bigger.

Presuming that neither Luca Greggo or Cooper Bell (the two players drafted in between our picks) were on our board in between where we had Cochran and where we had West, it's pretty safe to assume that had Sydney matched our bid for Cochran, we would then have drafted Charlie West in that spot.

Then who we taken at 50 in the Scenario?

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Then who we taken at 50 in the Scenario?

Impossible to know what the strategy would've been Dave - Maybe Will Hayes was genuinely the next player on the board, and they would have taken him there, or maybe the strategy was two talls with the first two picks and then the best small with the 3rd.

In either case, we have no idea who would've been next on the board - If we wanted another tall defender, Cal Twomey also linked us to Riak Andrew or Adrian Cole (who didn't get bid on or picked up by St Kilda in any capacity), and also mentioned Lachlan Voss and Clancy Dennis, who also didn't get drafted at all.

Given that Twomey also had us linked to West and Cochran, but not to Hayes, I think it's fair to say Hayes was the Hine-special smokey, and that maybe someone from that list of talls would've been the next pick at #50 if Sydney had matched on Cochran.

 

[Jen2310]

Draft night: The inside story of Pies’ 2024 haul

With the likes of academy selections, bids, trading up, and a host of complexities meaning nothing is assured in the 2024 reality of securing the nation’s best talent, go inside Collingwood's draft bunker as the Pies pick up three new players.

www.collingwoodfc.com.au

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

 

[Pistol Night]

At Collingwood id assume media training to handle the flogs?

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Draft night: The inside story of Pies’ 2024 haul

With the likes of academy selections, bids, trading up, and a host of complexities meaning nothing is assured in the 2024 reality of securing the nation’s best talent, go inside Collingwood's draft bunker as the Pies pick up three new players.

www.collingwoodfc.com.au

Disappointing compared to last year, as we get no new information about other names we were considering at any of the picks.

 

[Jen2310]

Disappointing compared to last year, as we get no new information about other names we were considering at any of the picks.

But explains the reactions in the box

 

[TradeDraft]

Disappointing compared to last year, as we get no new information about other names we were considering at any of the picks.

Don't think they are Legally allowed to say them and don't want any Negative things towards the People who where on the Board who where not Picked at all

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Don't think they are Legally allowed to say them and don't want any Negative things towards the People who where on the Board who where not Picked at all

They're obviously not legally barred from saying anything, TD. Last year they mentioned that they wanted to trade up for Logan Morris and Archer Reid but weren't able to, and that they were interested in Riley Hardeman, Ollie Murphy and Arie Schoenmaker at the picks they took.

You might be onto something about not mentioning if they were considering drafting players who didn't end up getting drafted, as it only would've added to the heartache for those guys.

 

[Apex36]

Draft night: The inside story of Pies’ 2024 haul

With the likes of academy selections, bids, trading up, and a host of complexities meaning nothing is assured in the 2024 reality of securing the nation’s best talent, go inside Collingwood's draft bunker as the Pies pick up three new players.

www.collingwoodfc.com.au

Well I’m glad I wasn’t going crazy when I said that our recruiters looked shocked when we got Cochran.

 

[TradeDraft]

You might be onto something about not mentioning if they were considering drafting players who didn't end up getting drafted, as it only would've added to the heartache for those guys.

Yeah you would not been happy to hear that they where High on Draft Board but was not Picked

Don't think go down well

 

[JuniorB]

Impossible to know what the strategy would've been Dave - Maybe Will Hayes was genuinely the next player on the board, and they would have taken him there, or maybe the strategy was two talls with the first two picks and then the best small with the 3rd.

In either case, we have no idea who would've been next on the board - If we wanted another tall defender, Cal Twomey also linked us to Riak Andrew or Adrian Cole (who didn't get bid on or picked up by St Kilda in any capacity), and also mentioned Lachlan Voss and Clancy Dennis, who also didn't get drafted at all.

Given that Twomey also had us linked to West and Cochran, but not to Hayes, I think it's fair to say Hayes was the Hine-special smokey, and that maybe someone from that list of talls would've been the next pick at #50 if Sydney had matched on Cochran.

Adrian Cole is a player worth looking at if we need to find another tall back at some point.
He's more of a lockdown type, but a good one.
A bit of a headscratcher that the aints didn't pick him, although they did pick Tauru, who we might look to steal a few years down the track