Culley, Chesser and Ginbey today were worse than sheed and gaff who were serviceable.
Take out sheed and gaff and who replaces them? We don’t have the depth right now.
Need at least one more high draft pick and Elijah hewett back to cover them
Best players Yeo, McGovern, Barrass, Waterman
Kelly- Too inconsistent, no hurt factor, turnover prone.
Ginbey- Getting better, Developing
Chesser- Developing
Reid- Gun star player and still developing
Yeo- Too injury prone
Hunt- Not a long term solution
Sheed- No role for a slow player
Gaff- No role for a winger in the game any more...
The Tim kelly experiment has been a failure. 30 Tim kelly possessions does not impact a game and makes the team worse. He is soft, lazy and inconsistent. He is a big reason why we are near the bottom of the ladder.
Positives
Ginbey
Barrass
Mcgovern
Hunt
Waterman
Chesser
Cripps
Negatives
Our ruckman were destroyed, Williams is not a afl player, Barnett is still raw
Our ineffective forward line- Darling and long did nothing all game
Senior midfielders Yeo and Kelly disappeared when GWS got on top. They...
He has lost his speed and his tackling pressure is no longer there. He has stopped leading for the ball. This has caused him to wait underneath the ball and get manhandled by the defenders.
He is done.
Positives
Williams and Jamieson played well
Harley Reid was one of our best
Ginbey, Hough and Chesser tried
McGovern was solid
Petruccelle with the bag of goals
Negatives
Ball movement is too slow, not enough run, play ons and kicks through the middle
Our Forward structure leaves our forward...
Jack Petruccelle (12/4/99) - Signed a 3 year extension (2021,2022,2023) in October 2020- EXTEND
Jake Waterman (6/5/98) - Signed a 3 year extension (2021,2022,2023) in October 2020-EXTEND
Sam Petrevski-Seton (19/2/98) - Signed a 2 year contract (2022,2023) in October 2021-DELIST
Luke Foley...
Looks like the Jack Darling replacement, playing as a undersized key forward. Hoping he can add some much needed tackling pressure in our forward line.
Positives
Culley kicking 4 goals
Williams
Duggan was solid
Bazzo needs to play in the team
Allen and Darling worked hard all day
Negatives
Culley playing as a forward
Another injury to Shuey
Barrass getting towered up by another KPF
Kelly -half his possessions are turnovers
Gaff is just so...
Kelly is a turnover merchant but gets a lot of it
Gaff tries but his kicking doesn't hurt you
Barrass is a bad one on one defender
Jones and Hurn are bad small defenders. Hurn is too slow
Darling does some ok things, but needs to stop leading towards the pockets all the time
Waterman needs to...
Positives
Waterman showing that his true value is at full forward
SPS having a breakout game at half forward flank
Jones providing some run
Ginbey showed flashes
Kelly returning to form
Shuey is still our best midfielder
Sheed was solid
Hunt was a important contributor
Negatives
Allen needs...
Sounded like he was one of the most impressive trainers at the club. Didn't look like he took his chance in the preseason games. Which is why he is on the outer.
Folks, Hough is not a wingman and J Jones does not belong in the backline
B Cole Barrass Hurn
HB Hough McGovern Duggan
C Gaff Kelly Sheed
HF Ryan Darling Petruccelle
F Cripps Allen Waterman
FOLL- Naitanui, Yeo, Shuey
I/C- B.Williams, Culley, Ginbey, Jones
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.