List Mgmt. Trade & Free Agency - Fred 11

[_RT_]

Updated Picks As Of October 15th

 

[archibald]

As long as we don’t cave for 11 & 18 for Bolton, then we win trade week. I imagine this includes a ceremonial passing of the torch from dodo and his bummers.

 

[tora tora tora]

After all these picks have come in

I genuinely do not see the need to trade Shai unless we get huge overs

We have 1, 6, 14, 20, 23 and 24

If we do not get 10,11, keep him

there's no need to trade him. But he has wanted out all year, allegedly. 10 & 18 do me, or pay his full salary if that helps.

$hai's on a $million. Bolton will put em over surely.

 

[Mr Magic]

This is really insulting to our current list.

Ross, Taranto, Hopper, Ralphsmith, Gibcus, Balta, Brown, Mansell, Banks, Lefau, Campbell, Rioli Jr are all talented and fun to watch.
Jury is still out on these blokes, but they could easily be talented and exciting - Bauer, Smith, Blight, Sonsie, Fawcett, Clarke.


Then add in 8 or so early picks this year.

This isn't like the days where we lost a star for a player that didn't work out, or one or two picks that ended up duds. We're cashing in for a huge haul at the perfect time. If we waited 2-3 more years to do this the draft will be compromised by Tassie and it'll be an uphill battle.

no guns, where is the gun??

it is not insulting, it is respectful, we finished last for a reason

 

[tigerdan]

Saints will be sniffing with 7&8, they're keen for Lalor too. We'd have to overpay a bit by adding a third pick to either of those offers.

I don't think st kilda will give up 2 picks in the first round just to move to 2. They'd have to be rapt with two picks in a solid draft. You'd only do that in a draft where there are two standouts and it then drops away (and 8n that case another would surely not be selling).

Hell, they might even go the other way and flip it to a club desperate to trade in.

 

[daird]

no guns, where is the gun??

If you don't think Balta, Taranto, Hopper are guns then you are blind.

 

[CatRiot]

Pick 14 for Baker is very good trading...

 

[avengers]

Magic's woken up

 

[Mr Magic]

If it was for just pick 2, yes. I'm saying pick 2 and 25. You really need to learn to read.

We get the players we rank top 2, unopposed, and only drop down ~11 spots, into the area of the draft (13-30) that is a lot more even.

as if pick 25 is worth anything much, lol

We need pick 25 to get Luke Hodge, yeah, nah

 

[Kyusss]

I think its clear this draft is so even its better to have more picks than a very high pick.

This is the only explanation as to why we didn’t trade for 3


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Mr Magic]

If you don't think Balta, Taranto, Hopper are guns then you are blind.

they are not guns, good players but not guns, Hopper may not even be regarded as a good player yet, still needs more consistency and get over his setbacks

 

[Barunga Bullet]

i am not relaxing I am checking out, this is the **** up, I am not sticking around for another thirty years


this is how the thirty year drought happened and we where so bad for so long we got Lids, Dusty , Cotch, Rance , JR and still did not believe until it happened because we refuse to help ourselves unlike CFC

 

[daird]

they are not guns, good players but not guns

So you're saying our team has one gun (Bolton) then? What's the point of holding one gun around with no support?

 

[SleepingGiant]

This is really insulting to our current list.

Ross, Taranto, Hopper, Ralphsmith, Gibcus, Balta, Brown, Mansell, Banks, Lefau, Campbell, Rioli Jr are all talented and fun to watch.
Jury is still out on these blokes, but they could easily be talented and exciting - Bauer, Smith, Blight, Sonsie, Fawcett, Clarke.


Then add in 8 or so early picks this year.

This isn't like the days where we lost a star for a player that didn't work out, or one or two picks that ended up duds. We're cashing in for a huge haul at the perfect time. If we waited 2-3 more years to do this the draft will be compromised by Tassie and it'll be an uphill battle.

We had our core last time pre-GC and GWS. We will again this time as well.

 

[Mr Magic]

So you're saying our team has one gun (Bolton) then? What's the point of holding one gun around with no support?

I am saying Hollands, Cripps, Weitering are the types of Bolton's ilk

RFC does not have the cattle, Yze cannot survive this, he needs a longer tenure than Dimma ever got

 

[DickieKnee]

If you don't think Balta, Taranto, Hopper are guns then you are blind.

They are good but not guns like Rance, Martin, Cotchin, Reiwoldt.

 

[Danog]

you do not think CFC, Adelaide or Melbourne pick him before 6?? lol

Then they can keep 2? I'm honestly easy either way

 

[Boxo004]

they are not guns, good players but not guns, Hopper may not even be regarded as a good player yet, still needs more consistency and get over his setbacks

Bolton Good player but not a gun

 

[Frank Grimes]

Am I missing something or did the Rioli Trade go through or not? I notice the GC picks already added to the excel table pinned to this thread.

 

[Mr Magic]

Bolton Good player but not a gun

Bolton is a gun

 

[daird]

I am saying Hollands, Cripps, Weitering are the types of Bolton's ilk

RFC does not have the cattle, Yze cannot survive this, he needs a longer tenure than Dimma ever got

Hollands.. Cripps.. Weitering.. All first round picks, interesting.

 

[Mr Magic]

Then they can keep 2? I'm honestly easy either way

that is the problem, acceptance of mediocrity at RFC

 

[Boxo004]

Bolton is a gun

Could be. But he’s not

 

[Willo_23]

Am I missing something or did the Rioli Trade go through or not? I notice the GC picks already added to the excel table pinned to this thread.

Nah it hasn't gone through.

 

[daird]

They are good but not guns like Rance, Martin, Cotchin, Reiwoldt.

Yeah but they're not currently on our list either. So we need to cash in and draft in as much elite young talent as we can, while we can.

 

[Mr Magic]

Hollands.. Cripps.. Weitering.. All first round picks, interesting.

but not just first rounders , they have ability to and put it on show

FOS is a better player than Walsh probably and Walsh would know and Wright with Hawthorn connection proabbly knows something about Tauru as well.

There might be a miss here and there but CFC has far more X factor and pedigree than RFC on their list