Post Your Team Here

[UpTheGuts]

Any feedback appreciated... 1st timer!
BACKS: C Newman, L Gilbee, H Shaw, J Smith, R Houlihan, A Raines, J Grimes (Sudan & Rance)
MIDS: G Ablett, D Cross, S Pendlebury, N Foley, H Skipworth, D Rich (Beams & Davenport)
RUCKS: D Cox, H McIntosh (Trengrove & Currie)
FWDS: M Pavlich, P Chapman, M Richardson, A Didak, C Rioli, J Neagle, S Higgins (Gumbleton & Hogan)

I think jesse smith did another hammy on the weekend - check it out. Malceski?

whatever jay neagle is valued at, it's that much too much. Spud

otherwise, a fine side.

 

[Bordo89]

full image available here

What are your thoughts ??

I have $22,200 left

I was thinking if upgrading jonathan brown

 

[blues4flag]

BACKS Goddard, S.Fisher, Cornes, Drummond, Houlihan, Raines, Grimes (Hill, Petrenko)
MIDS Bartlett, S.Tuck, J.Selwood, Gibbs, Hasleby, Beams (Robinson, Anthony)
RUCKS Cox, Ottens (White, Currie)
FORWARDS O'Keefe, Deledio, Didak, B.Johnson, Higgins, Skipworth, Sidebottom (Gumbleton, Ballantyne/Walker)

Posted in the other thread, but no critiques.

Someone...anyone...please?

 

[Baxter23]

BACKS Goddard, S.Fisher, Cornes, Drummond, Houlihan, Raines, Grimes (Hill, Petrenko)
MIDS Bartlett, S.Tuck, J.Selwood, Gibbs, Hasleby, Beams (Robinson, Anthony)
RUCKS Cox, Ottens (White, Currie)
FORWARDS O'Keefe, Deledio, Didak, B.Johnson, Higgins, Skipworth, Sidebottom (Gumbleton, Ballantyne/Walker)

Posted in the other thread, but no critiques.

Someone...anyone...please?

Need another gun in the midfield IMO.

 

[UpTheGuts]

full image available here

What are your thoughts ??

I have $22,200 left

I was thinking if upgrading jonathan brown

I think 5 blues is a fair few...

 

[blues4flag]

Need another gun in the midfield IMO.

In place of who (one of Tuck, Gibbs, Selwood or upgrade Hase?) By downgrading Hill down to a 94k rookie, I can upgrade Selwood and Tuck to anyone bar Ablett, Gibbs to anyone bar Ablett, Hodge and Harvey and Hasleby to anyone under 496k.

Though I think Selwood, Tuck and Gibbs all represent good value and will increase their averages while Hase at 358k is definitely underpriced. A risk he could potentially average 15-20 PPG higher than he's priced.

Given I'm playing both Drummond and Grimes in defence, I like the security that Hill gives me as a reserve.

Though I could downgrade White to a 94k player then upgrade Selwood to anyone under 600k...

Which I think I will do, now that I think about it.

 

[Baxter23]

In place of who (one of Tuck, Gibbs, Selwood or upgrade Hase?) By downgrading Hill down to a 94k rookie, I can upgrade Selwood and Tuck to anyone bar Ablett, Gibbs to anyone bar Ablett, Hodge and Harvey and Hasleby to anyone under 496k.

Though I think Selwood, Tuck and Gibbs all represent good value and will increase their averages while Hase at 358k is definitely underpriced. A risk he could potentially average 15-20 PPG higher than he's priced.

Given I'm playing both Drummond and Grimes in defence, I like the security that Hill gives me as a reserve.

Though I could downgrade White to a 94k player then upgrade Selwood to anyone under 600k...

Which I think I will do, now that I think about it.

If you need another $20k-$30k, you could do Fisher or Goddard to Gilbee.
I would upgrade Tuck.

 

[rusty10]

Mate what are you smoking?

 

[sirviv]

Your thoughts would be grateful.

Backs - Goddard - Milburn - Cornes - Drummond -Raines - Houlihan - Hill
I/C - Rance - Petrenko

Mids - Thompson - Dal Santo - Ball - Dalziell - Skipworth - Davenport
I/C - Robinson - Steven

Rucks - Cox - Petrie
I/C - Graham - Jacobs

Forwards - Riewoldt -Pavlich - Franklin - O'Keffe - Higgins - Krakouer - Zieball
I/C - Brown - Nahas

 

[UpTheGuts]

Your thoughts would be grateful.

Backs - Goddard - Milburn - Cornes - Drummond -Raines - Houlihan - Hill
I/C - Rance - Petrenko

Mids - Thompson - Dal Santo - Ball - Dalziell - Skipworth - Davenport
I/C - Robinson - Steven

Rucks - Cox - Petrie
I/C - Graham - Jacobs

Forwards - Riewoldt -Pavlich - Franklin - O'Keffe - Higgins - Krakouer - Zieball
I/C - Brown - Nahas

downgrade buddy and riewoldt and upgrade midfield

 

[Kramer1]

full image available here

What are your thoughts ??

I have $22,200 left

I was thinking if upgrading jonathan brown

Im not gonna sugarcoat it Bordo..you'll get flogged with that team.

Firrito, Lockyer, Taylor and Adcock are all honest battlers, but none of them are top shelf. You need a big injection of quality down back.

Mids are solid enough. All quality, just comes down to preferences. Rucks also, although you may do better than Cloke. He actually scores reasonably well, but you are better to drop back to Ottens, or maybe save a few buck with Macintosh or Charman.

Wouldn't go with Betts, Anthony or Riewoldt up forward. Anthony played the game of his life last week and still couldn't crack 100 points. Riewoldt and Betts are too inconsistent. Sidebottom looked good, but I think he will struggle for games early on.

I'd press the 'Clear my team' option and have another crack. Good luck.

 

[Stanton_Legend]

Goddard, H.Shaw, C.Cornes, Drummond, Houlihan, Raines, Grimes

Bartel(c), Judd(vc), Kirk, Cross, T.Tuck, Rich

Hille, McIntosh

Pavlich, Deledio, Chapman, B.Johnson, Higgins, Skipworth, Ziebell

E: Hill, Suban, Beams, Robinson, J.White, Currie, Gumbleton, J.Grant

 

[BigSledge]

Backs: Fisher, Newman, Bock, Cornes,Malceski, Raines & Grimes
(Hill & Petrenko)

When is first started picking my side this was the area which worried me the most so whilst i have put a little more into my bench than planed i think its worth it for that peace of mind. I've got Petrenko in on nothing more than a hunch but if he isn't picked Round 1 he will probably be gone.

Mids: Ablett, Judd, Gibbs, T Tuck, Masten & Rich (Dangerfield & Beams/Swfit)

I think Ablett & Judd will be the two highest scoring players this year so I want them from the start will aim for Bartel or Selwood mid year when Masten or Rich top out price wise. The two other players i was considering was C Knights & C Morton but both got squeezed out a few drafts ago.

Rucks: Cox & Jolly (White & Currie)

Lock & leave hoping not to need to trade anything here all year (injury permitting)

Forwards: O'Keefe, Goodwin, Fevola, J Riewoldt, Higgins, Skipworth & Ziebell (Walker & Ballantyne)

This area is worring me now because O'keefe aside the rest aren't those massive premiums. I'm tempted to swap Goodwin for Delidio but then I'll have 4 Richmond players in my starting line up. Also tempted to swap Roughead in for Fevola or J Riewoldt (I have $176,400 left over). Also keen on Sidebottom but don't know if he'll play early on now.

Tried posting this in the V.2 thread but got nothing so i'ld really appreciate any feedback good or bad.

 

[Hot Tiges]

Goddard, H.Shaw, C.Cornes, Drummond, Houlihan, Raines, Grimes

Bartel(c), Judd(vc), Kirk, Cross, T.Tuck, Rich

Hille, McIntosh

Pavlich, Deledio, Chapman, B.Johnson, Higgins, Skipworth, Ziebell

E: Hill, Suban, Beams, Robinson, J.White, Currie, Gumbleton, J.Grant

I had Kirk last year after Dal Santo got dropped and he was good. Age maybe a concern but he won't miss any! Good solid cash cow bench. I'm not sure on Shaw. Could drop alot of cash so could pick up later on maybe?Drummond's risky but potentially worth it.

Like the post before mine, I had no luck in the Version 2 either! So we will see.

Team 1
Goddard, Fisher, C Cornes, Malceski, Houlihan, Raines, Hill (Petrenko, Suban)
Ablett, Cross, Judd, Gibbs, T Tuck, Rich(beams, robinson)
Harvey, Pav, Deledio, Roughead/Stokes, Higgins, Skipworth, Ziebell (Gumbleton, Walker)

Team 2
Goddard, Fisher, Bock, Malceski, Houlihan, Raines, Hill (Petrenko, Suban)
Ablett, Cross, Judd, Gibbs, Bartel, Rich(beams, robinson)
O' Keefe, Pav, Deledio, N Krackour/Henschel, Higgins, Skipworth, Ziebell (Gumbleton, Walker)

I'm excited at Team 2's midfield but feel it could be unbalanced in the fwd line?Fwd line would be cash cow city and a fair bit risky.. so who dares wins?? haha any opinons and critiscism will appreciated!

 

[not quite rite]

backs hodge goddard drummond
malceski hurn raines

mids ableet judd ben johnson
kerr rich polo

rucks hille mcintosh

fowards pavlich leon davis roughead
steve johnson fevola ziebell mcphee


(suban,rance,beams,robinson,sellar,currie,nahas,gumbleton)

ant thoughts??

 

[dplggr47]

Backs: Fisher, Newman, Bock, Cornes,Malceski, Raines & Grimes
(Hill & Petrenko)

When is first started picking my side this was the area which worried me the most so whilst i have put a little more into my bench than planed i think its worth it for that peace of mind. I've got Petrenko in on nothing more than a hunch but if he isn't picked Round 1 he will probably be gone.

Mids: Ablett, Judd, Gibbs, T Tuck, Masten & Rich (Dangerfield & Beams/Swfit)

I think Ablett & Judd will be the two highest scoring players this year so I want them from the start will aim for Bartel or Selwood mid year when Masten or Rich top out price wise. The two other players i was considering was C Knights & C Morton but both got squeezed out a few drafts ago.

Rucks: Cox & Jolly (White & Currie)

Lock & leave hoping not to need to trade anything here all year (injury permitting)

Forwards: O'Keefe, Goodwin, Fevola, J Riewoldt, Higgins, Skipworth & Ziebell (Walker & Ballantyne)

This area is worring me now because O'keefe aside the rest aren't those massive premiums. I'm tempted to swap Goodwin for Delidio but then I'll have 4 Richmond players in my starting line up. Also tempted to swap Roughead in for Fevola or J Riewoldt (I have $176,400 left over). Also keen on Sidebottom but don't know if he'll play early on now.

Tried posting this in the V.2 thread but got nothing so i'ld really appreciate any feedback good or bad.

as an Adelaide fan, i don't know why you'd have Dangerfield there, other than for the cool name on the bench. nothing from pre-season has shown that he'll play round 1...so most likely, he'll have to earn a spot in the side with consistent solid performances in the SANFL.

 

[Hot Tiges]

backs hodge goddard drummond
malceski hurn raines

midsableet judd ben johnson
kerr rich polo

rucks hille mcintosh

fowards pavlich leon davis roughead
steve johnson fevola ziebell mcphee


(suban,rance,beams,robinson,sellar,currie,nahas,gumbleton)

ant thoughts??

Have you given an opinion on someone else's team?you may get a talking too
Very unique picks though! Hurn = Burn for me last year. I can't see much love for him this year, Ben Johnson is an interesting one. Can rack 'em up but with that ugly left foot it can turn into ugly SC scores possibly. Why Polo? Rucks at the moment are fine. Forward line is an interesting one too. Very good players on it, not sure if all are great SC picks though.
Good luck

 

[not quite rite]

Have you given an opinion on someone else's team?you may get a talking too
Very unique picks though! Hurn = Burn for me last year. I can't see much love for him this year, Ben Johnson is an interesting one. Can rack 'em up but with that ugly left foot it can turn into ugly SC scores possibly. Why Polo? Rucks at the moment are fine. Forward line is an interesting one too. Very good players on it, not sure if all are great SC picks though.
Good luck

its my first supercoach so i dont know to much about it there for im not sure if i qualify to commant on others teams
ben johnson im prepared to take a gamble on he now has a bit of pressure on him to keep his spot......
polo im not sure call it a gut feeling i dont know ????? any suggestions

 

[Hot Tiges]

its my first supercoach so i dont know to much about it there for im not sure if i qualify to commant on others teams
ben johnson im prepared to take a gamble on he now has a bit of pressure on him to keep his spot......
polo im not sure call it a gut feeling i dont know ????? any suggestions

Polo > one of Masten, T Tuck or if you wanna keep up the uniqueness then Adam Thomson of Richmond. Heard good reports and he can tackle well. I'm not sure Polo has found his niche yet.Back/Midfield/Utility/Bench.. maybe reserves lol..

 

[harro37]

Backs: Gilbee S.Fisher C.Cornes H.Taylor Houlihan Raines S.Selwood
Rance Dawson

Mids: Judd Cross Pendlebury Thompson Ray Higgins
Dangerfield Robinson

Ruck Jolly Kruezer Sellar Currie

Fwds Delidio Roughead Fevola T.Cloke Varcoe J.Riewoldt Hentschel
Reid Gumbleton

Any thought first season tryin to get a good even spread any criticism is welcome good and bad
thanx

 

[Baxter23]

Backs: Gilbee S.Fisher C.Cornes H.Taylor Houlihan Raines S.Selwood
Rance Dawson

Mids: Judd Cross Pendlebury Thompson Ray Higgins
Dangerfield Robinson

Ruck Jolly Kruezer Sellar Currie

Fwds Delidio Roughead Fevola T.Cloke Varcoe J.Riewoldt Hentschel
Reid Gumbleton

Any thought first season tryin to get a good even spread any criticism is welcome good and bad
thanx

Back and Mids are good, Ray is a bit of a gamble though.
Rucks aren't bad but no Hille or Cox.

Fwds struggle a little.
Cloke & Fev are generally inconsistent.
IMO you have a fwd line made up of players that need to kick goals and if they don't they won't score. Otherwise they are 1 dimensional players.
Try and look at players that can play on the ball as well as kick goals ie- Harvey, Deledio, didak, Gia etc.



Any comments on my team?

Goddard, Gilbee, Cornes, Malceski, Bock, Raines & Grimes- Hill & Rance

Judd, Bartel, Pendles, Masten (WCE), Tuck, Rich- Robinson & Beames

Cox, McIntosh- White & Sellar

Harvey, Deledio, Gia, Didak, Skippy, Higgins, Gumby- Ziebell & Sidebottom

 

[peter_ford]

Backs: Gilbee S.Fisher C.Cornes H.Taylor Houlihan Raines S.Selwood
Rance Dawson

Mids: Judd Cross Pendlebury Thompson Ray Higgins
Dangerfield Robinson

Ruck Jolly Kruezer Sellar Currie

Fwds Delidio Roughead Fevola T.Cloke Varcoe J.Riewoldt Hentschel
Reid Gumbleton

Any thought first season tryin to get a good even spread any criticism is welcome good and bad
thanx

i reckon downgrade selwood to hill or somebody similar and spend money else where.
don't bother with varcoe; he will struggle to cement a spot in the 22. j.riewoldt won't do much. try lucas, ziebell, etc.

 

[ozzyoslo]

BACKS Goddard, S.Fisher, Cornes, Drummond, Houlihan, Raines, Grimes (Hill, Petrenko)
MIDS Bartlett, S.Tuck, J.Selwood, Gibbs, Hasleby, Beams (Robinson, Anthony)
RUCKS Cox, Ottens (White, Currie)
FORWARDS O'Keefe, Deledio, Didak, B.Johnson, Higgins, Skipworth, Sidebottom (Gumbleton, Ballantyne/Walker)

Posted in the other thread, but no critiques.

Someone...anyone...please?

backs.....I dont like drummond,chose between raines or houlihan not both.

mids...bartlett?? bartel or ablett?? hmmm is he a blend of both players?? or the old champ working on sen ?? either way mids are good.

rucks......keep white find another cheap ruck to replace currie

forwards...... bj is old and feel his best is over, and too many mids priced players.

I hope this helps alittle.

 

[Flying Higher37]

its my first time ive taken SC seriously and was wondering if anyone could give me a friendly hand with my side

backs : H. Shaw, C. Cornes, Lockyer, Mackie, Adcock, Raines, Malceski (hill, Grimes)

MIDS : Corey, J Selwood, Dalziell, Mclean, Haselby, Rich, (Robinson, Beams)

Rucks: Hille, Kruezer (Currie, White)

Fowards: Deledio, Richardson, Medhurst, Lucas, Houliahan, Higgins, Skipworth (Ziebell, Gumbleton)

any advice would be helpfull
cheers

 

[AFLROCKS]

My team is as follows.. all feedback will be appreciated..

Backs: S.Fisher, C.Cornes, M.Clarke, R.Houlihan, J.Adcock, N.Malceski, D.Myers
Emerg: D.O'keefe, A.Rance

Mids: C.Judd, L.Power, J.Selwood, B.Gibbs, P.Hassleby, D.Rich
Emerg: S.Sidebottom, P.Dangerfield

Rucks: A.Sandilands, H.Macintosh
Emerg: J.Seller, J.Trengrove

Forwards: N.Riewoldt, M.Pavlich, A.Walker, T.Cloke, T.Hawkins, S.Higgins, J.Ziebell
Emerg: H.Ballantyne, M.Brown

30k in bank.. Any oppinions??