Opinion Your Clubs best 20 Ever

Remove this Banner Ad

Collingwood Best 20 since 2000
FB James Clement - Simon Prestigiacomo - Brayden Maynard
HB Scott Burns - Darcy Moore - Nick Maxwell (Captain)
C Steele Sidebottom - Dane Swan - Dale Thomas
HF Jamie Elliot - Chris Tarrant - Tarkyn Lockyer
FF Leon Davis - Travis Cloke - Alan Didak
FOLL Brodie Grundy - Nathan Buckley - Scott Pendlebury
BENCH Anthony Rocca - Ben Johnson
 
Liam_The_Latvian said:
If we're being fair and just talking Brisbane Lions exclusively

FB: Chris Johnson, Harris Andrews, Jed Adcock
HB: Daniel Rich, Justin Leppitsch, Martin Pike
C: Hugh McCluggage, Michael Voss, Nigel Lappin
HF: Shaun Hart, Jonathan Brown, Dayne Zorko
FF: Charlie Cameron, Alastair Lynch, Jason Akermanis
Foll: Stefan Martin, Simon Black, Lachie Neale

Int: Luke Power, Brad Scott, Daryl White, Joel Patfull
Click to expand...
Ashcroft stiff
 

Log in to remove this ad.

GoldenMagpie16 said:
Collingwood Best 20 since 2000
FB James Clement - Simon Prestigiacomo - Brayden Maynard
HB Scott Burns - Darcy Moore - Nick Maxwell (Captain)
C Steele Sidebottom - Dane Swan - Dale Thomas
HF Jamie Elliot - Chris Tarrant - Tarkyn Lockyer
FF Leon Davis - Travis Cloke - Alan Didak
FOLL Brodie Grundy - Nathan Buckley - Scott Pendlebury
BENCH Anthony Rocca - Ben Johnson
Click to expand...

Hard to disagree so moving the goal posts and adding 2 on bench, Licuria and Leigh brown


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Procrastinator35 said:
I guess the pertinent question remains: Is 84 games ample enough to be included in a club's Best 20 ever?

Peter Hudson played the fewest @129 in my best of 20 at Hawthorn....But he kicked 727 goals at the highest average in VFL/aFL history, including 5 tonnes from 6 full seasons....The next fewest was Buckenara on 154 games in 9 seasons, kicking almost 300 goals, & playing in 4 Premierships.

Buddy & Brereton are the only other 2 players in my Best 20, not to have reached the 200 game milestone with us.
Click to expand...

I'm probably finding a spot for both Jarryd Roughead and Shaun Burgoyne.
 
Buckley
A Collier
G Coventry
Daicos
Pendlebury
Swan
P Moore
Len Thompson
H Collier
Rose
McKenna
Millane
S Coventry
Regan
Fothergill
Kyne
T Shaw
Weideman
Gavin Brown
Thorold Merrett

What a list.
 
For Richmond. Off the top of my head - 5 minutes thought. Criticism accepted. Top 15 I'm pretty happy with. From there, pick 5 out of perhaps 30 possibilities. (Still can't believe Dale Weightman missed out. Might have to do it again).

Dyer
Bartlett
Hart
Bourke
Wright
Martin
Titus
Bentley
Richardson
McCormack
Thorp
Rance
Crowe
Cotchin
Riewoldt
Morris
Dean
Branton
Des Rowe
Harris
 
The Cryptkeeper said:
I'm probably finding a spot for both Jarryd Roughead and Shaun Burgoyne.
Click to expand...

Hard to find space for Hodge, Mitchell, Crawf, Rough, and Buddy in our TotC. 5 brilliant players need to come out.

Adding Burgoyne as well....

It would be easy to just take out the much older players but Mills, Austen, Edwards, Arthur, Law should probably all be there. Maybe Simmonds comes out as he didnt win a flag but I dont know how good he was. Mills too. Austen was our first Brownlow medallist so its hard to remove him.

Then you have Gibbo who won a B&F in 2 Premierships years so clearly he is in the running...

We have had so many brilliant players over the last 60 years.
 
Can't decide....but offer this.... Premierships in brackets

Backs David Parkin (1) or Gary Ayres(5) Kelvin Moore(3) or Chris Langford (4) Josh Gibson (3) or Andy Collins (3)

H Backs Grant Birchall (5) or Shaun Burgoyne (3) Peter Knights (3) or Chris Mew (5) Luke Hodge (4) or John Kennedy Jnr (4)

Centres Robert Dipierdomenico (5) or Darrin Pritchard (3) Brendan Edwards (1) or Sam Mitchell (4) Rodney Eade (4) or Cyril Rioli (4)

H Forwards Gary Buckenara (4) or Luke Breust (3) Dermott Brereton (5) or Lance Franklin (2) John Hendrie (2) or Jordan Lewis (4)

Forwards John Platten (4) or Peter Crimmins (1) Peter Hudson (1) or Jason Dunstall (4) Jarryd Roughead (4) or Jack Gunston (3)

Followers Don Scott (3) or John Kennedy Snr (0) Michael Tuck (7) or Graham Arthur (1) Leigh Matthews (4) or Shane Crawford (1)

Interchange from.... John Peck (1) Ian Law (1) Terry Wallace (3) David O'Halloran (2) Alan Martello (3) Ben Stratton (3)

Brian Lake (3) James Morrisey (3) Liam Shiels (3)..... and many others too numerous to mention...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

The_Eagles
Champions in 2023
Replies
0
Views
659
The_Eagles
The_Eagles
Jackington
Opinion The Back Pocket - 2023 Defensive List Previews
Replies
13
Views
875
Jackington
Jackington
Hoops
Opinion 2022 retiring team
Replies
3
Views
858
Marcel Proust
Marcel Proust

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top