VFL VFL Round 5 v Essendon. Saturday April 27. 2:05pm @ Victoria Park
- Thread starter Jen2310
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I'll be watching with great anticipation. Actually looking forward to seeing Hutchison
- Apr 17, 2017
- 1,542
- 2,041
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Can you imagine Hutchinson out there today?…. Jeez….
Watching him and realising he will be gone in a month depresses me.
ElliottsMaggies
Premium Platinum
- Mar 28, 2023
- 8,325
- 16,370
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Cannot. wait. to. see. Harry.
Harry seems to have the strong body and electric pace we need. I hope he strings a few good games together and gets a debut sooner rather than later.
Is DeMattia available this week? If so, looking forward to watching him, as he looks like a ready made senior player, physically wise.
Jen2310
Moderator
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #7
VFL-listed players Cooper Macdonald, Harrison Kennedy, Tom Wilson, and Patrick Farrant are the four outs for Saturday’s game.
Saturday April 27
Collingwood v Essendon
Victoria Park, Wurundjeri
2:05pm (AEST)
Saturday April 27
Collingwood v Essendon
Victoria Park, Wurundjeri
2:05pm (AEST)
| COLLINGWOOD V ESSENDON | |||
| B | Ash Johnson | Charlie Dean | Jakob Ryan |
| HB | Tew Jiath | Oleg Markov | Wil Parker |
| C | Jack Bytel | Ned Long | Ed Allan |
| HF | Jack Hutchinson | Joe Richards | Josh Carmichael |
| F | Liam Purcell | Reef McInnes | Sam Glover |
| R | Aiden Begg | Finlay Macrae | Lachie Sullivan |
| INT | Harry DeMattia | Campbell Lane | Ryan Sparkes |
| Conor Willis | Ben Crocker | ||
| EMG | Harrison Kennedy |
High hopes that Demattia, Harrison, Allan & Macrae are our next wave of young mids to crack into seniors and impact.
memoryofmchale
Club Legend
- Feb 11, 2024
- 1,200
- 1,527
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
AJ in the backline is because Glover is a more natural and better key forward (at least this season).
To be really cynical, it’s because there are other defenders who can hide him and the sting of Glover up front is more than AJ. Cooper MacDonald is unlucky to be dropped but you can’t drop AFL players from the VFL for form reasons alone.
I have little hope for AJ in defence.
The Coburg loss was embarrassing - lose to Essendon and that’s the season.
To be really cynical, it’s because there are other defenders who can hide him and the sting of Glover up front is more than AJ. Cooper MacDonald is unlucky to be dropped but you can’t drop AFL players from the VFL for form reasons alone.
I have little hope for AJ in defence.
The Coburg loss was embarrassing - lose to Essendon and that’s the season.
Jen2310
Moderator
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #13
I def would prefer glover in defence, as we havent seen Ash in that position. Ideally you'd like two Glovers. One forward and one back
If ash does line up there as it suggests here, we'll get an idea one way or another.
The vfl players dropped are unlucky but thats just the nature when you are mostly a healthy list. And one vfl players accept to be on an afl affiliated vfl list.
If ash does line up there as it suggests here, we'll get an idea one way or another.
The vfl players dropped are unlucky but thats just the nature when you are mostly a healthy list. And one vfl players accept to be on an afl affiliated vfl list.
barrackers
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 4, 2016
- 11,793
- 20,927
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Hopefully it’s not just chook lotto with the team list and he actually plays there. It’s something I’ve been wanting to see as I don’t think he’ll make it as an AFL forward, even in the VFL his best games have been with significant time in the ruck.
Has similar physical attributes to Howe, so there’s a senior role if he can develop some defensive nous.
Also not the worst thing to give him a new challenge with his confidence low.
memoryofmchale
Club Legend
- Feb 11, 2024
- 1,200
- 1,527
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Glover forward is something I’d take. We need avenues to score. Purcell is young so that’s why they need another key who’s ready to play there.
Lewis Hayes will play on Glover. He’d leave the remains of AJ on Vic Park.
I’m thrilled to see Ash being named in the backline, thinks it’s absolutely worth a try.
Totally different mind set required and you just get the feeling it could be a really good fit for him.
Fingers crossed for him.
Go Ash!
Also, have really high hopes for Harry de Mattia as a long term high quality player and leader of our club , so all in all, can’t wait for the game, another trip to Vic Park as well (and hope Ash is truly been given a go on the backline!)
Go well Pies
Totally different mind set required and you just get the feeling it could be a really good fit for him.
Fingers crossed for him.
Go Ash!
Also, have really high hopes for Harry de Mattia as a long term high quality player and leader of our club , so all in all, can’t wait for the game, another trip to Vic Park as well (and hope Ash is truly been given a go on the backline!)
Go well Pies
ElliottsMaggies
Premium Platinum
- Mar 28, 2023
- 8,325
- 16,370
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Didn't you just say on the AJ thread, criticism is fine as long as it's respectful? How is that respectful?
It's like you couldn't wait to get stuck into Ash again before he's even played this week.
memoryofmchale
Club Legend
- Feb 11, 2024
- 1,200
- 1,527
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
He would dominate on AJ. I’d say that about any player who’s had the season AJ has had versus a player near AFL standard and consistently in Essendon’s best.
Or it’s like I’m just stating the facts.
ElliottsMaggies
Premium Platinum
- Mar 28, 2023
- 8,325
- 16,370
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Yeah righto.
Here we go again.
If we know a player is struggling with off field issues, would we keep banging on about how it's affecting their on field performances? Calling them useless, s**t, delist them, reveal how oppo coaches mocked them? And 'leave his remains on Vic Park'. I don't think so. That's not respectful criticism. It's a pile on. And it's started again before he's even played.
He's already been dropped from the seniors.
Clearly he's struggling. And we know why he's down on confidence . And we also all know he's very talented.
memoryofmchale
Club Legend
- Feb 11, 2024
- 1,200
- 1,527
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
No coach or analyst would have positive things to say after how AJ has played. I’ve never called him useless or s**t. Why shouldn’t I challenge his contract and ask for him to be delisted? Ruscoe had a more inspiring season at VFL level but went, so did Bianco. Cal Brown, the perineal whipping boy, has looked better than AJ at VFL level this year and so has Will Kelly. Different positions but the point remains.
If he’s struggling, take mental health leave as he has every right to. No different to other injuries.
JuniorB
Premiership Player
Looking forward to seeing how he goes.
And a better perfomance across the board after last week's debacle.
TradeDraft
Post-Human
Spots up for Grabs in the AFL Side
ElliottsMaggies
Premium Platinum
- Mar 28, 2023
- 8,325
- 16,370
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I'm sure the club are looking after him & know what is best for his mental health. And that's obviously being around the club, his mates and playing football.
It's not in dispute that he's down on form and playing poorly. No one is suggesting otherwise.
But we also know why he's down on form & struggling. That's the point being missed. Banging on about how poorly he's playing, and now before he's even played is not constructive criticism.
That's quite a decent looking side, with 15 AFL-listed players, and hopefully it will be strong enough to win, something we need after last week's disappointing loss. I'm very keen to see DeMattia, and of course more of Parker. The lack of a genuine ruckman is likely to be an issue again, but I'm hoping we can get around that.
Here's what we're up against: https://www.essendonfc.com.au/news/1538964/vfl-rd-5-team-selection-v-collingwood
That looks like 12 from Essendon's AFL list.
Similar threads
