Should be fun.
Out: English, Dale, Gallagher
In: Lobb on one legg, Garcia, Harmes
Out: English, Dale, Gallagher
In: Lobb on one legg, Garcia, Harmes
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 9
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round 8 Winner: bearweger
Preview Rd: 6 - Dogs @ Saints, Marvel Stadium, 7:30pm Thursday 18 April
- Thread starter TiAn_
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Chalky White
All Australian
- Sep 30, 2019
- 773
- 1,216
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Out: Gallagher, VDM, potentially Dale
In: Garcia, Freijah potentially Busslinger
English very lucky
Time to give kids a run
In: Garcia, Freijah potentially Busslinger
English very lucky
Time to give kids a run
If Bevo is fair dinkum about senior players needing to earn spots blah blah and let’s not play Dale or Daniel, then English is dropped against Saints. Worst game I have seen him play since his year 2.
Out from 22,
English, Libba (looked like he had a head knock), then looks like Sanders and Gallagher need a rest
In Lobb (try something different in ruck), Garcia, Harmes, Dale.
Maybe Sanders or Gallagher as sub
Maybe some merit in going a little smaller, this week we put in ODonnell and dropped Dale from 22 and looked slow. We are playing one too many talls. Don’t know who, maybe Buku but he has been going well. Then bring back Daniel ?
Out from 22,
English, Libba (looked like he had a head knock), then looks like Sanders and Gallagher need a rest
In Lobb (try something different in ruck), Garcia, Harmes, Dale.
Maybe Sanders or Gallagher as sub
Maybe some merit in going a little smaller, this week we put in ODonnell and dropped Dale from 22 and looked slow. We are playing one too many talls. Don’t know who, maybe Buku but he has been going well. Then bring back Daniel ?
lachy
Norm Smith Medallist
Agree Gallagher needs a spell but there are many who should simply be dropped, English, Dale, Baker, Williams. Buku and JOD could also be replaced.
JJ, Bramble and Durea had good stats but not sure about their games.
There were many who put their hand up in the VFL which should provide some earned opportunities
On SM-S926B using BigFooty.com mobile app
- Oct 9, 2014
- 12,154
- 21,392
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Out: Williams, Baker, Libba (has to be something in that fall and will be worried about the medical team if they actually say it's just the ankle)
In: Garcia, Harmes, Clarke
In: Garcia, Harmes, Clarke
- Sep 27, 2005
- 14,727
- 22,208
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Footscray
How bad is it when you want your team to fall further into the mire so it fast tracks the sacking of the coach? That's where I'm at right now. Players checked out, so has the coach and so have I.
lachy
Norm Smith Medallist
West is really playing a great role up forward now, would have him in the rotation but not the main rotation
On SM-S926B using BigFooty.com mobile app
I agree he's come on good in the small forward role over the past little while. I still think he is a midfielder though. He's the only one apart from Bont and Bailey Smith (2021 version) who can break a tackle.
Out:
Gallagher - looks cooked for the moment and a couple of lacklustre efforts
Libba - gotta be more to that stumble
Duryea - love the bloke and he reads the play better than any, but there are a lot of "old man-falls" happening out there. If we are serious about being amongst it this year he shouldn't be in our best 22 come September.
In:
Garcia - reward the form
Daniel - lets see how he bounces back
Freijah - if ever we needed someone new to get around, this is the week
On notice: English (I'd dump him for Smith if he wasn't injured), Weightman (needs a rocket and to be told not to fly against 6ft8 team mates)
On SM-A505YN using BigFooty.com mobile app
Gallagher - looks cooked for the moment and a couple of lacklustre efforts
Libba - gotta be more to that stumble
Duryea - love the bloke and he reads the play better than any, but there are a lot of "old man-falls" happening out there. If we are serious about being amongst it this year he shouldn't be in our best 22 come September.
In:
Garcia - reward the form
Daniel - lets see how he bounces back
Freijah - if ever we needed someone new to get around, this is the week
On notice: English (I'd dump him for Smith if he wasn't injured), Weightman (needs a rocket and to be told not to fly against 6ft8 team mates)
On SM-A505YN using BigFooty.com mobile app
CarnTheScray
Norm Smith Medallist
“Come September” lol.
Greater chance of the Queen being resurrected then us making finals.
Out: Dale, Duryea, English, Libba (not quite right)
In: Freijah, Garcia, Dunkley (ruck), Harmes, more midfield rotations
Bramble Jones Khamis
Richards JOD Freijah
Baker Garcia Gallagher
Sanders Naughton West
Weightman JUH VDM
Darcy Bont Treloar
Macrae Dunkley (ruck) JJ Harmes Williams (sub)
In: Freijah, Garcia, Dunkley (ruck), Harmes, more midfield rotations
Bramble Jones Khamis
Richards JOD Freijah
Baker Garcia Gallagher
Sanders Naughton West
Weightman JUH VDM
Darcy Bont Treloar
Macrae Dunkley (ruck) JJ Harmes Williams (sub)
Out : Cody Weightman the downhill skier and to be replaced by the more consistent Cody Weightman
On CPH2305 using BigFooty.com mobile app
On CPH2305 using BigFooty.com mobile app
West to have more time in the middle and bring in Clarke. Please.
Would also love to see Freijah get a run.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Would also love to see Freijah get a run.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Planet Dogs
Senior List
- Aug 12, 2022
- 257
- 613
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Libba; VDM: Out
Harmes; Garcia: In
Harmes; Garcia: In
You can’t drop Timmy as no one to ruck as both Lobb and Lachie Smith are now injured.
I think Baker has been good since he come back in, but was pretty horrible last night and probably makes way for a more polished senior player e.g. Daniel/Harmes
Rather than throwing the toys out the cot and playing the youth, I would do the opposite. Play all our senior, experienced well paid players - give them 3-5 weeks, with a sprinkling of elite young talent (Sanders, Darcy etc.). If we still look lost, then play the kids and the season is a write off anyway.
A few role players would be a bit unlucky, as they have been good at times, but I think it should be the Bramble, Baker, Gallagher, Khamis/O’Donnell types who make way for Keath, Daniel, Harmes etc.
Don’t get me wrong - Khamis, Bramble and Gallagher in particular have impressed me this season, and are quickly becoming a couple of my favourites. But let’s load up for a dip in the next couple of weeks and see if we can officially draw a line through half of these experienced seasoned players.
I think Baker has been good since he come back in, but was pretty horrible last night and probably makes way for a more polished senior player e.g. Daniel/Harmes
Rather than throwing the toys out the cot and playing the youth, I would do the opposite. Play all our senior, experienced well paid players - give them 3-5 weeks, with a sprinkling of elite young talent (Sanders, Darcy etc.). If we still look lost, then play the kids and the season is a write off anyway.
A few role players would be a bit unlucky, as they have been good at times, but I think it should be the Bramble, Baker, Gallagher, Khamis/O’Donnell types who make way for Keath, Daniel, Harmes etc.
Don’t get me wrong - Khamis, Bramble and Gallagher in particular have impressed me this season, and are quickly becoming a couple of my favourites. But let’s load up for a dip in the next couple of weeks and see if we can officially draw a line through half of these experienced seasoned players.
DognBones
Premium Gold
Western Bulldogs - Ed Richards Player Sponsor 2024
Western Bulldogs - Bailey Dale Player Sponsor 2024
Veteran
Western Bulldogs - Bailey Dale Player Sponsor 2023
Western Bulldogs - Ed Richards Player Sponsor 2023
Western Bulldogs - Bailey Dale Player Sponsor 2022
Western Bulldogs - Ed Richards Player Sponsor 2022
Western Bulldogs - Bailey Dale Player Sponsor 2021
Out: Gallagher (just doesn't know where to position himself), Baker (VFL traits becoming obvious), O'Donnell (clearly underdone, was blowing hard by half time). Several others: Williams, Weightman, Dale, Vandermeer all lucky we have little quality depth.
In: Garcia (at the very least, he's a goer and will add some spark to the midfield, must play), Harmes (not a huge fan but his good VFL form should be rewarded), Daniel (now seems on the outer but still a useful contributor if played in the right position).
PS English played the worst game from a Bulldog No 1 ruck I've seen in decades last night but we have no option than to keep him in the side and hope for something better.
In: Garcia (at the very least, he's a goer and will add some spark to the midfield, must play), Harmes (not a huge fan but his good VFL form should be rewarded), Daniel (now seems on the outer but still a useful contributor if played in the right position).
PS English played the worst game from a Bulldog No 1 ruck I've seen in decades last night but we have no option than to keep him in the side and hope for something better.
Mofra
Moderator
- Dec 6, 2005
- 67,195
- 198,608
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Footscray, Coney Island Warriors
- Moderator
- #19
Out:
Bramble (the mix isn't right, we're 1 defender too many)
Libba (do not risk him)
English (if you don't compete in the air as a ruck, you've broken a non-negotiable)
In:
Garcia (selection integrity)
Lobb (50/50 ruck/forward with Darcy)
Harmes (integrity and he tackles)
I'm not sure Daniel was good enough in the VFL to earn a recall.
Not sure what to do with Gags & Sanders - do we give them a run in the VFL? Clarke debut may be on the cards and West plays further up the ground because we really need a 'spark' and Clarke seems like the type of annoying bastard to give us one.
I'd be tempted to give one of them a week off - perhaps get Sanders to rack it up at VFL level for 1 week - just because Clarke might get rid of the team lethargy in the way Arty's energy rubbed off on teammates last year.
Bramble (the mix isn't right, we're 1 defender too many)
Libba (do not risk him)
English (if you don't compete in the air as a ruck, you've broken a non-negotiable)
In:
Garcia (selection integrity)
Lobb (50/50 ruck/forward with Darcy)
Harmes (integrity and he tackles)
I'm not sure Daniel was good enough in the VFL to earn a recall.
Not sure what to do with Gags & Sanders - do we give them a run in the VFL? Clarke debut may be on the cards and West plays further up the ground because we really need a 'spark' and Clarke seems like the type of annoying bastard to give us one.
I'd be tempted to give one of them a week off - perhaps get Sanders to rack it up at VFL level for 1 week - just because Clarke might get rid of the team lethargy in the way Arty's energy rubbed off on teammates last year.
Reminds me Stuart Dew with Sam Flanders.
Refused to play him, then when King took over Flanders was a gun.
- Oct 11, 2014
- 3,242
- 5,568
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
I have it on good authority Libba was suffering from leather poisoning from the cats game that caused him to fall over at the end of the game.
