Nahas ( poll added )

[_RT_]

The salaries of afl players are really skewed these days & if true how a Robin Nahas type of player could possibly be offered $400k for 5 years is bewildering to say the least !!

Travis cloke $1mill ..................... FFS thats a joke , No way near worth that sort of dollars

Then you have a ball magnet & in my opinion a much better player than both, I would take Dayne Beams over Nahas & Cloke
signed today ........ 3 years for 1.1 million

How does that work !

Its quite simple, Beams has put team success over money, Cloke it would appear is after the cash and secondly success.

 

[THE_GUN]

What if i said that we could get Rioli or Yarran for the pick we get for Nahas - Would that convince you guys

Christopher Yarran (WA – Fwd/Mid)
Height: 183cm, Weight: 80kg, DOB: 27/04/1994
Recruited from: Perth Football Club

Ben or Willy Rioli
Ben and Willie jr, cousins of Hawthorn's Cyril, were among the best players in the Territory's maiden win against traditional powerhouse Vic Metro.

 

[torn]

Can confirm this is true.. Will be moving interstate on $400+ over 4 years.

 

[THE_GUN]

Can confirm this is true.. Will be moving interstate on $400+ over 4 years.

If you can confirm - which state/club

 

[torn]

QLD based.. It'll come out after finals anyway.

 

[richolovesgoal]

Can confirm this is true.. Will be moving interstate on $400+ over 4 years.

How can you confirm?

 

[City Search]

I can see Nahas playing in a finals side

 

[Ned_Flanders]

QLD based.. It'll come out after finals anyway.

Given he's under contract, does this mean he intends to move subject to the club agreeing to the trade, or has the trade been agreed to in principle?

If the latter, you know what we are getting (player, pick)?

 

[richolovesgoal]

I don't know how a Collingwood supporter would know this, but to play along, if it was out of Brisbane and Gold Coast surely it would be GC. Brisbane have a lot of small-medium forwards and I don't think they would offer Nahas a 4 year deal.

 

[Tigerrific]

Hopefully he stays, getting rid of a player approaching his peak and replacing him with an untried rookie will be a backwards step for our finals aspirations next year.

 

[NZ_Tiger]

Still sounds like bullshit. I can't see what value he would add to either of the Queensland sides especially.

But hey, good on Robby if it's true. Big turn around for a guy of his size to come off a rookie list and make big $$$.

 

[richolovesgoal]

Hopefully he stays, getting rid of a player approaching his peak and replacing him with an untried rookie will be a backwards step for our finals aspirations next year.

Or is his best past him? He's kicking goals but he's a shadow of himself from the last 2 years.

 

[_RT_]

Hmm Gold Coast pick 22 for Nahas, suits me fine.

 

[rammbo]

Hes not super quick anymore like a few years back

 

[johnno77]

I didn't mind your comedy but, but unfortunately it cannot happen - Nahas signed a 2 year deal last year. GWS cannot pick him up unless we do a regular trade for him (i.e. no compo pick)

Exactly. Comedy. This whole thread is comedy gold.

That was exactly how I treated it. And I don't recall ever mentioning GWS.

 

[richmond_14]

Hes not super quick anymore like a few years back

Yeh man when he hit 24 he just slowed right down hey?

 

[richmond_14]

Also this "Torn" guy offers up no new information and doesnt have many posts. Sounds like a troll to me.

 

[THE_GUN]

Lets just wait & see

Last year there was a bit of interest in nahas at trade time but not from GC or brisbane, But as a previous post mentions i really cant see brisbane being a suiter which leaves gold coast.

If it is gold coast that is interested then we have hit the jackpot -Josh caddy welcome home

 

[Dustin Credible]

Lets just wait & see

Last year there was a bit of interest in nahas at trade time but not from GC or brisbane, But as a previous post mentions i really cant see brisbane being a suiter which leaves gold coast.

If it is gold coast that is interested then we have hit the jackpot -Josh caddy welcome home

If true, which seems dubious, I doubt we'd get a Caddy, Toy perhaps + extra but not Caddy.

GCS will be interesting to watch in trade week, as IIRC they need to prune their list down to a smaller total number.

 

[CHIMP MAGNET]

Weren't North interested in Nahas last year?

 

[Ned_Flanders]

Exactly. Comedy. This whole thread is comedy gold.

That was exactly how I treated it. And I don't recall ever mentioning GWS.

sorry - typo - meant GC

be interesting to see of the 4x$400k rumour is true - still sounds too high to be true, but ive been wrong too often before to write it off 100%

 

[TigerFaithful]

Would not accept.

 

[THE_GUN]

If true, which seems dubious, I doubt we'd get a Caddy, Toy perhaps + extra but not Caddy.

GCS will be interesting to watch in trade week, as IIRC they need to prune their list down to a smaller total number.

If it is GC that are offering Nahas $400k - That means they really rate him and will want him , even if it means paying overs which is a 2nd year player that wants to go home.

You see there isnt really anything we could offer gc that would sweeten the deal as far as draft picks , they have more than they will use anyway & we cant improve their postition in the draft either.

Nahas - Caddy ............... Im Driving Robin to Carrara & picking up josh on the way back

 

[Stylo]

Howbout Nahas + our 3rd rounder for Toy + their 2nd rounder.

 

[RichoLedio]

I'm curious about Toy, if we were to trade Nahas for him what role do people think he will play? And does anyone think he might come on quickly if given a decent run of games?