Astro Bomber
Club Legend
- Mar 27, 2011
- 2,152
- 1,194
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Iwould take it but, I dont think Freo would go for it. Might have to add something extra as a sweetener.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List of Trade Rumours for 2012
- Thread starter RossFC
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
The good folks at the Herald sun footy pages wouldn't exaggerate things, surely?
Yeah yeah, you're very clever. Just like jonathon brown who needs facial reconstructions after training sessions. I reckon he is one more away from Brisbane needing to go after gumbleton themselves
If he turns out to be as good as vickery I reckon he could be a huge win for a club like Richmond
You want to be reamed even harder than last Friday?? Wow. Masochist.
Gumbleton will never be much chop. Gee, even Hansen has him covered now
Third rounder maybe? Even then, he's still a longshot project player is Gumby
If I was a masochist I would be supporting a club like Richmond that has garnered so much respect and success over the past three decades or so.
Are you being sarcastic about Hansen? Kid is a star - heard he even has champions like Petrie playing a 'decoy' role for him.
Easily impressed, you are. Dear me.
Care to answer my query about Gumby's value? He is approaching Cale Hooker status in terms of Dons fans seeking to offload him. Regrettably, he is one pinger away from concluding his career.
They are only unhappy because they know they won't be on our list next year.
Both have had excellent seasons at VFL level, Warren in particular has been excellent coming 2nd in the VFL's goal kicking. Mckinley was in the top 10 too. Would really like to see Warren at another club, really think he would excel if given 10-12 games on the trot.
Thanks muchly.
That was a rumour, and is kinda what the thread is about. Gossip, if you like. Apologies, it was a lazy post
As to how Richmond rates Toy, I would defer always to tigs2010. If he says we don't rate him, that's good enough for me. Certainly the manchild issue was a concern even a year ago
Please tell me we wont get Moloney, we already have a number of slow midfielders.
We wants either quick midfielder with good skills or KPF or draft picks.
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
Ewwwww, no thanks. Why would we want or need Strauss...it is the one position we have a zillion options!
We've got a worse mid-field than yours and that's saying something so you're not going to get a mid-fielder trade - it'd have to be a draft pick I think.
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
I don't think Gumbleton will be even traded, he will re-sign as he is well and truely part of the future at our club. That said Strauss (whom I rate) is the worst idea I have seen, we already have too many back flankers and you want to give us another one.
Gumbleton is an interesting one. Being mentioned that Melbourne interested. Initial thoughts no way. But considering we will have 4 picks in top 25 of draft we can consider trading our 3rd rounder which will be about pick 40.
We are in need of another key forward but his injuries are a massive concern and i wouldn't want to pay too much.
We are in need of another key forward but his injuries are a massive concern and i wouldn't want to pay too much.
Dwight Schrute
Club Legend
The thing is, Gumby isn't going to leave. The team getting him would have to pay overs.
vast
Hall of Famer
No club will give more than a 3rd rounder for Gumbleton. Essendon may as well keep him for a 1 one year contract.
Eastern Rangers
2015 Worsfold Medalist - Rowen Powell
We have a couple of young forwards that will do well with Lynch out of the way.
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
Hibberd is not a midfielder, neither is Dempsey, as it is we are stacked with flankers, we don't need another one!
Asgardian
Bigfooty Jedi
Gumbleton's trade value has to be way down, maybe he could do with a change, just like Port tall forward, Daniel Stewart?
Gumbleton -- 24 this year, 197cm 97kg, 28 games, 33 goals
Stewart -- 24 this year, 200cm 93kg, 35 games, 31 goals
Gumbleton -- 24 this year, 197cm 97kg, 28 games, 33 goals
Stewart -- 24 this year, 200cm 93kg, 35 games, 31 goals
I wouldn't trust him to get the day of the week right, myself.
I don't see what Warren has to offer at the top level.
He's basically a 6'1 full forward.
Just like Little or Galea or Sautner or whoever else, he's strong enough & good enough to play as a key tall on a succession of skinny kids & fat slow buggers in the ressies, but doesn't have anywhere near the skill level to succeed as a mid-size player (which is what he really is) at the top grade.
He's done.
Same with McKinley.
Edwards will be there in another year or two as well, IMHO.
North are *that much* better off with actual key-sized key targets. Tells a fair tale.
Tell me more about Stewart. What's holding him back? He seems to have got a few games in a row this year, but can't quite break out
I have mild interest and will watch him closely on Sunday. Others zone off him pretty easily, but he looks to have the tools.
As a roll of the dice, I'd prefer him to Gumby
- Status
Similar threads
