Player Watch #30: Charlie Comben - defender or forward? CC T5 in the AFL for avg. intercept marks per game

[Moti]

Charlie plays the same back or forward. Should have been moved today.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[The Nostradamus]

Agree
Time to trial him forward again

Much rather that then play pink the plodder

 

[giantroo]

 

[giantroo]

 

[The acurate one]

If he wants to avoid a chance of injury, stay at home.

 

[muttley45]

Considering his injury history, you couldn't possibly argue with Clarko's strategy here, way too valuable an asset to be using for a short term sugar hit playing forward, 22yo with a total of 16 games so far, stay the course.

 

[Passmore]

If he wants to avoid a chance of injury, stay at home.

It's probably not Chalky's call. The mad campaigner would be up for anything.

Sent from my SM-A908B using Tapatalk

 

[Moti]

Best news all day. He is a forward and should be played there. Don’t care about this year so happy for him to play back.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Passmore]

Best news all day. He is a forward and should be played there. Don’t care about this year so happy for him to play back.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Mick Barlow mentioned before the season that this wasn't necessarily a long term move.

Sent from my SM-A908B using Tapatalk

 

[amaz199]

Comben playing back releases Corr and the third tall. It's the height we've been missing.

 

[RightWingRoo]

Still rather him down back, because he could develop to AA level imo. Will never be better than serviceable as a forward, due to his lack of forward craft and poor goal-kicking.

 

[Moti]

Still rather him down back, because he could develop to AA level imo. Will never be better than serviceable as a forward, due to his lack of forward craft and poor goal-kicking.

He doesn’t have any defensive craft either. He is going to be a see ball get ball player until he gets at least 50 games under the belt. Then he may develop some more craft or may just end up staying the same/.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[wazza03]

He should be a staple of our defence for many years to come. I wouldn’t be moving him forward after seeing how much he has grown as a key back.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[RightWingRoo]

He doesn’t have any defensive craft either. He is going to be a see ball get ball player until he gets at least 50 games under the belt. Then he may develop some more craft or may just end up staying the same/.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Get what you're saying, he's still raw. But just see a much higher ceiling for him down back. He's numbers are comparable to McKay's who has 4 years and 60 odd games on him.

We desperately need a 2nd key forward, but I wouldn't be moving Chom.

 

[Forever North]

He looks and feels more of a defender than a forward at the moment. Has a great attitude and very competitive . He hates losing a contest, always cursing and kicking himself when outmarked or turning it over. He’s a 200 gamer for sure.

 

[Chadwiko]

Still rather him down back, because he could develop to AA level imo. Will never be better than serviceable as a forward, due to his lack of forward craft and poor goal-kicking.

I agree.

Comben has surprised me with his usefulness down back.

His strength is that he plays tall and can crash a pack, including taking a decent intercept mark. We badly needed that down back, and he's done well.

His weaknesses, as we've seen, are his foot skills and decision making with the ball in hand. Those do not fill me with confidence in terms of becoming as good a forward as he has been in defense.

In his (obviously limited) career to date, his set shot accuracy has been... not good.

He's shown far more as a defender than he ever did as a forward, in my humble opinion.

 

[Moti]

He looks and feels more of a defender than a forward at the moment. Has a great attitude and very competitive . He hates losing a contest, always cursing and kicking himself when outmarked or turning it over. He’s a 200 gamer for sure.

Well he does play in the backline so that is a good thing.

 

[kirbonavich]

He looks really good as a defender because he goes at it with reckless abandonment. Going toe-to-toe with the leagues best forwards for a year is a much better education to be a better forward than being an active 'forward' for North this year.

Chom will get some tradecraft from a little bit of everyone this year, coupled with his own development will only make him better.
The brutality of the way he plays isn't going anywhere.

Really like what he is turning into this season.

 

[tazaa]

Well beaten by “checks notes” Guelfi?
Yeh maybe time to move him back up front

 

[Possession]

Comben playing back releases Corr and the third tall. It's the height we've been missing.

This was striking about yesterday. We had two 200cm defenders out there and suddenly Corr and McDonald played well too.

 

[DesertRoo]

Just stop the nonsense, move him to CHF, I've had enough of this rot.
Enough is enough, play Pink as the CHB or no one.
This is our best option to see us best prepared to be competitive. Or dare i suggest, win a game.
We have tried CCJ, Pink, Greenwood and no one at CHF. All failed and in this order. CCJ, Greenwood, No One and Pink.

Seriously, this is ******* with my head. It is like we don't want to win.

lol, Charlie's intercept marking is the one reason we haven't been done by over 100 points in a few games.
move him forward to get frost bite? and completely destroy the little confidence some of the young playing list has.

Set and forget, address the midfielders(major issue), small forwards, go for a second key forward during trade week.

 

[The acurate one]

lol, Charlie is the one reason we haven't been done by over 100 points in a few games.
move him forward to get frost bite?

Set and forget, address the midfielders(major issue), small forwards, go for a second key forward during trade week.

The midfield will be fine; Smillie, LDU, Simpkin, Wardlaw & Powell. Then Sheezel & McKercher

Fwd line

??? Comben Curtis
Duursma Larkey Ford (Zurhaar if he stays)

Backs

Logue 193cm, Corr 195cm, K.Dawson 196cm, W. Dawson 201cm and of course Comben 199cm.

KPF - Larkey 198cm

 

[DesertRoo]

The midfield will be fine; Smillie, LDU, Simpkin, Wardlaw & Powell. Then Sheezel & McKercher

Fwd line

??? Comben Curtis
Duursma Larkey Ford (Zurhaar if he stays)

Backs

Logue 193cm, Corr 195cm, K.Dawson 196cm, W. Dawson 201cm and of course Comben 199cm.

KPF - Larkey 198cm

We can't bank on Smilie at this stage.
Corr is 30 and Logue is coming off a knee.

Larkey is one out but like everything with norths list build, it seems to be an after thought.
We desperately need structure, for the life of me I couldn't understand why we didn't go hard for a Casboult type. He aint the answer long term but at least he give you structure for 24 months till we can figure it out and I don't know recruit a key forward in the draft.
Swapping Charlie out now is insane, its robbing Peter to pay Paul, when Paul doesn't exist.

 

[Passmore]

The midfield will be fine; Smillie, LDU, Simpkin, Wardlaw & Powell. Then Sheezel & McKercher

Fwd line

??? Comben Curtis
Duursma Larkey Ford (Zurhaar if he stays)

Backs

Logue 193cm, Corr 195cm, K.Dawson 196cm, W. Dawson 201cm and of course Comben 199cm.

KPF - Larkey 198cm

Don’t forget Henry, Scrimshaw, Battle….oh….

 

[The acurate one]

Don’t forget Henry, Scrimshaw, Battle….oh….

Yes good call, well we are pretty good at getting other clubs players a pay rise. Out of all of them over the years, how many actually went elsewhere.
I'd suggest not many lol.

Player Manager - right it's contract time.
Player - ok
Player - what's the plan.
PM - same as last time
Player - ring Brady?
PM/player - (high five)