Resource 2023 AFL Draft Discussion...

[StonesThrow]

No he doesn't, not even close yet.

JHF also entered the AFL far more physically developed and game ready than Dangerfield.

JHF has it all in front of him to achieve...

View attachment 1673335

Agree to disagree on this one

 

[FR0GGY]

Anyone wanting a look at Harley Reid he's playuing for Carlton's VFL team right now...quiet so far..#78

AFL Streaming - AFL.com.au

Watch the latest streams on the official website of the Australian Football League.

www.afl.com.au

How is that allowed?
Could we get Moir to play for our sanfl side?

 

[morris086]

How is that allowed?
Could we get Moir to play for our sanfl side?

Of course not, unlikely we'll get Welsh or any other father sons in our side prior to drafting, even though there's potential for that to happen

 

[FR0GGY]

No because he's indentured to Glenelg...all SANFL draftees have a club they're zoned to, the SANFL will allow F/S's or NGA Academy players to play for the Crows SANFL or Port Adelaide if their clubs are agreeable.

Same applies to AFL Academy players in Victoria with each Coates League team being designated to a VFL club....Phiactides is playing for the Tigers VFL and Zane Duursma for the Demons VFL this weekend with there being no Coates League games for them this weekend.

Soligo played for Richmond under the same conditions in 2021.

Thanks for the explanation

 

[George Kramer]

Mutineer I went to Norwood v Glenelg today, hard to gauge because Glenelg dominated, but was impressed by Glenelgs Anders McShane, know much about him?

 

[Jeffcrowe]

No he doesn't, not even close yet.

JHF also entered the AFL far more physically developed and game ready than Dangerfield.

JHF has it all in front of him to achieve...

View attachment 1673335

At the same age JHF is more advanced on Dangerfield and that’s all he can do at this point

Of course he needs to keep developing to match dangerfields achievements in time but right now he’s doing all he can for a 2nd year player

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

What sort of player is Logan Evans?

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Is Tom Wheaton popping up on mock drafts?

I see he was BOG for Westminster who took it up to PAC all day before PAC kicked a few at the end to run out 20 point winners. Tim Weatherald coaching at Westminster I'm pretty sure

 

[pushintheback]

Riley Sanders has the ball on a string early.

Agree but his decision making hasn’t been great.

 

[Danger in Texas]

If McAdam wants a trade at the end of the year... I wouldn't mind looking at Delean with one of our 2nds. Absolutely has something as a forward

 

[Danger in Texas]

Watson is as much a one-touch player as I've seen

 

[Danger in Texas]

Moir hasn't lifted as the class has gone up, nice being a dual sided elite kick but boy does he need to lift his competiteness especially with contested ground ball.

Yeah can't say he's imposed himself on the game. Not top 10 for me currently

Duursma, on the other hand, seems to have lifted. Still getting shades of Jaidyn Stephenson, but the class at this level is evident

 

[Danger in Texas]

Rogers looks like an excellent midfield prospect

GCS aligned though, and also small (172cm I think)

 

[Danger in Texas]

Mitch Edwards pushing top 5 for mine. Definitely top 10. Such a clean tap ruckman, and athletic for his size

 

[rabidcrow]

Moir hasn't lifted as the class has gone up, nice being a dual sided elite kick but boy does he need to lift his competiteness especially with contested ground ball.

Did they end winning? Looked like it but I missed the last 10 minutes

Does that happen often - the kids beating a VFL side? I would have thought those Carlton’s boys would feel pretty embarrassed losing to a bunch of kids - even elite ones


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[johnnypanther]

View attachment 1673335

Brings back memories of the Dangerfield over Brad Ebert meltdowns

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Mitch Edwards pushing top 5 for mine. Definitely top 10. Such a clean tap ruckman, and athletic for his size

Would be happy if we drafted him

He’s special

 

[maxlilly]

Would be happy if we drafted him

He’s special

It seems strange WCE taking Barnett last year when Edwards is coming along this year.
Surely they wont take two ruckman in two years ?

 

[DJ75]

Moir sliding right into our draft zone. Well played by him

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Moir hasn't lifted as the class has gone up, nice being a dual sided elite kick but boy does he need to lift his competiteness especially with contested ground ball.

Does this surprise you .....going too early on kids, predicting huge futures, when they are only 16 YO ......often backfires.

It's only when youngsters play against those of equal talent at the Nationals, in their Draft Year ....that we see, skills under true pressure ....even then, we can't see their internal motivations

 

[jackster83]

Once the ball hits the deck he's been very very ordinary this year so far....as the class has gone up he hasn't risen with it...

Is playing with an injury atm, from what I heard.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Is playing with an injury atm, from what I heard.

Perfect

 

[pushintheback]

I think we take Edwards before Moir. He's in our range.

 

[BunjiMac]

We clearly still need midfield talent and something which is different from what we already have.

So we need pick wisely.

Size, power, skills and class.

 

[Danger in Texas]

I think we take Edwards before Moir. He's in our range.

Edwards as an elite ruck talent to eventually replace ROB would be a decent shout

My hope for our first is still a mid, if possible, though