blue gunslinger
Hall of Famer
Can we also do one of these for the Ants? I think Ellard must have been in the Bests the most this season!
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 9
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round 8 Winner: bearweger
2009 Carlton Board Player of the Year
- Thread starter blues4flag
- Start date
- Tagged users None
thylacine60
Premium Platinum
- Banned
- #27
Has to be close to favourite for B & F along with Banno, Robbo and Cloko. 
blue gunslinger
Hall of Famer
Would be nice for Ellardo to get the prizeHas to be close to favourite for B & F along with Banno, Robbo and Cloko.
No point in a Bullants B&F.
Ellard would win by so much, you could roll over his votes into 2010 while hes playing Seniors and he'd still win.
Ellard would win by so much, you could roll over his votes into 2010 while hes playing Seniors and he'd still win.
- Oct 18, 2008
- 1,892
- 1,037
- AFL Club
- Carlton
if the blue dont promote him at the end of the year (i think they will) will you cry?
blue gunslinger
Hall of Famer
No - but if they do not they should set him adrift to find someone who will or to fade away.
- Thread starter
- #33
I've changed my mind on Ellard. At first I thought he had no chance but after a brilliant season in the Ants it'll be cruel if we don't at the very least give him a go at AFL level to show what he's got.
- Thread starter
- #34
Updated the OP with the votes for the Magpies game. Will do the votes vs. Collingwood some time during the week but expect to see Murphy be within a vote or two of Judd.
- Thread starter
- #35
Opening post updated for round 18.
Murphy moves back within only a vote of Chris Judd after polling 7 in the last fortnight to Judd's none.
His 4 goals saw him voted as BOG just in front of Bryce Gibbs, who now moves into 3rd place ahead of Fevola. Has worked his way into form in the second half of the season, polling 14 votes in the last 7 games.
Good to see Stevens play very well on return to pick up 3 votes. Hopefully it isn't a one off but signs of things to come as we approach finals.
Thornton getting some recognition - polled 4 against Collingwood and 2 again on the weekend after going forward to double his career goals tally. I think he's unfairly maligned by some. Still a very important part of our 22.
Armfield picks up his first votes of the season after doing a very good defensive job and providing run from defence.
Murphy moves back within only a vote of Chris Judd after polling 7 in the last fortnight to Judd's none.
His 4 goals saw him voted as BOG just in front of Bryce Gibbs, who now moves into 3rd place ahead of Fevola. Has worked his way into form in the second half of the season, polling 14 votes in the last 7 games.
Good to see Stevens play very well on return to pick up 3 votes. Hopefully it isn't a one off but signs of things to come as we approach finals.
Thornton getting some recognition - polled 4 against Collingwood and 2 again on the weekend after going forward to double his career goals tally. I think he's unfairly maligned by some. Still a very important part of our 22.
Armfield picks up his first votes of the season after doing a very good defensive job and providing run from defence.
blue gunslinger
Hall of Famer
I noticed this thread even got a play on the bay
Hats off!
Hats off!
- Thread starter
- #38
Hello Alpha.
Guess this is as good a time as any to update for round 19. As soon as I get my next batch of biscotti into the oven.
Guess this is as good a time as any to update for round 19. As soon as I get my next batch of biscotti into the oven.
thylacine60
Premium Platinum
- Banned
- #39
Sniper Cat bakes as well? This puss has major scope.
- Thread starter
- #40
Edited for round 19. Thornton and Gibbs are flying at the moment and Juddy kicks four votes clear of Murphy.
- Thread starter
- #41
Opening post updated for round 20. Sure took a while - by far the most votes we've had for the season. Thanks guns.
Murphy's brilliant 33 touches and 3 goal performance sees him move 1 vote ahead of Judd into first. Very, very close going into the last two rounds.
Murphy has now polled in an amazing 15 of 20 matches, ahead of Judd who's polled in 13. His consistency has been remarkable and you'd think it'll hold him in good stead in the club B&F (and AA for that matter but perception will count against him).
Gibbs is in brilliant form of late - he's polled 13 of a possible 15 votes in the last three weeks. His first half of the season was poor by his standards but he and Fev have played a big roll in us winning 6 of our last 7 games.
Hadley polls two after an excellent game through the midfield while Thornton continues playing great footy having polled in four consecutive games now.
Murphy's brilliant 33 touches and 3 goal performance sees him move 1 vote ahead of Judd into first. Very, very close going into the last two rounds.
Murphy has now polled in an amazing 15 of 20 matches, ahead of Judd who's polled in 13. His consistency has been remarkable and you'd think it'll hold him in good stead in the club B&F (and AA for that matter but perception will count against him).
Gibbs is in brilliant form of late - he's polled 13 of a possible 15 votes in the last three weeks. His first half of the season was poor by his standards but he and Fev have played a big roll in us winning 6 of our last 7 games.
Hadley polls two after an excellent game through the midfield while Thornton continues playing great footy having polled in four consecutive games now.
- Thread starter
- #42
Updated for round 21.
Great to see young Garlett poll his first votes for the season (3) - only to follow it up by being suspended for the week.
Gibbs continues his sensational form of late. His 18 votes in the last month makes it the best four week period of any player this season. Brilliant player who continues to get better and is a clear third.
Fev polls 2 after 7 goals and will finish fourth after next week.
Judd polls 1 to bring him up to 51. Unfortunately for him, Murphy's 4 puts him 4 ahead. Murphy will be tough to beat from here but Judd could still take it out if Murphy polls 0/1 votes and Judd polls 4/5. Will be tough against the Crows.
Great to see young Garlett poll his first votes for the season (3) - only to follow it up by being suspended for the week.
Gibbs continues his sensational form of late. His 18 votes in the last month makes it the best four week period of any player this season. Brilliant player who continues to get better and is a clear third.
Fev polls 2 after 7 goals and will finish fourth after next week.
Judd polls 1 to bring him up to 51. Unfortunately for him, Murphy's 4 puts him 4 ahead. Murphy will be tough to beat from here but Judd could still take it out if Murphy polls 0/1 votes and Judd polls 4/5. Will be tough against the Crows.
blue gunslinger
Hall of Famer
great work once again
- Thread starter
- #44
Was going to end it after 22 rounds but I've decided to keep the POTY till our season's done and dusted. Will be interesting to see who does what in finals.
blue gunslinger
Hall of Famer
amazing the drop off in number of people who bother to vote after a loss
poor form!
poor form!
- Thread starter
- #47
Don't know. Wasn't quite as interested in football last time we were in finals.
Was only 11.
Was only 11.
season's not over. continue vote taking imo.
blue gunslinger
Hall of Famer
considering it is your pride and joy blues4flag you make your own rules!
