Search results for query: *

We should be looking to keep our best players not trade them because they have value...

We are happy for him at the Pies. :)

No idea what you are going on about, but got better things to do... McAsey was pick 6.

You don't need him as you have Billy.... & no we won't swap then back.

So you prefer Butts over Keane? What limitations concern you, given he still learning & developing?

Everyone at the Pies does... & they can plenty of the ball too...

Surely this is the nail in the coffin for any return. He just needs to concentrate on becoming a better person with some serious counselling.

Thanks. We won't have a shortage of spots to upgrade him to the main list next trade period.

McAsey.

Think he is on the main list now. Vader can probably confirm.

Assuming Murray comes back ok, we should consider trading Butts as there are sides in need of a key defender. Then keep Borlase as depth. Also, have Worrell capable of as key defender, but prefer him as 3rd tall.

Out of his own mouth how much he likes Adelaide.

Exactly. So who is looking potentially better than Rankine at pick 6. 8 Amiss 11 Wanganeen-Milera 33 Owens 36 Soligo Rankine likely to be top 10 & decent value, unlike our other recent pick 6...

I already know that. Probably more likely... Ins: Schoenberg, Burgess Outs: Rankine, Himmelberg

Time to bring in some of out best young players. ROB survives with Berg out. Ins: Ryan, Curtin, Schoenberg, Gollant, Dowling, Berry Outs: Smith, Jones, Rankine inj, Himmelberg inj, Murphy, McHenry B: Michaelanny, Butts, Hamill HB: Laird, Keane, Hinge C: Sholl, Soligo, Nankervis HF...

No! Sign him up to a longer deal.

We can easily extend him & match anything Pies are offering. He is happy here.

Pretty sure he is happy here. Reckon we will extend his contract & consider trading Butts.

Prefer Gollant, but that means they are likely to pick Burgess. Then rest Tex when Berg is back to give Gollant some continuity.

Then lock Nicks & the coaching group out to take over match day coaching lol.

Yeah, I wouldn't be swapping them. Mac Andrew still looks very raw... & not a need for us.

Hmmm, that's debatable as there are a few around... but yeah, not everyone is stupid... but the truth is in between imo.

Yeah, now contains posters who are happy to comment on games they haven't even watched or left early... ;)

Oh crap, no Berg is out. Reckon we go with Gollant, but means Fog likely to get a better opponent now.

There is no doubt ROB does some very good things off field. Younger players talk highly how he has supported them. My issue with him is his on field performances.

I'm not saying get rid of all our experienced players & solely play youth. We still play a core of experienced players, most of whom are still performing at a decent level. I'm saying don't play (much) those with a limited future. Smith should not be playing most games as performances have been...

Perhaps repeat late in the game several times to watch what we did wrong so we don't repeat the same decision errors again Watch what the Pies do.

I will once again feel truly positive about this club when we play finals again... which sadly won't be this year thanks to wasting our 1st month of football with a terrible game plan.

Apparently headless chickens have shape..

Having players in our bloated leadership group who are not necessarily best 22 does cause us a selection dilemma...