Now what do we get?
[Confirmed as Judd's preferred club: http://abc.net.au/news/stories/2007/10/02/2049029.htm - Mr E.]
[Confirmed as Judd's preferred club: http://abc.net.au/news/stories/2007/10/02/2049029.htm - Mr E.]
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
The official Judd Trade With Carlton thread
- Thread starter WaDsY
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Star_is_Braun
Senior List
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
what you mean carlton it is?? is it official where and when??
what you mean carlton it is?? is it official where and when??
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
Just confirmed on the radio through a media statement from the Carlton Football Club.
what is it going to take to get the deal done?
Just confirmed on the radio through a media statement from the Carlton Football Club.
what is it going to take to get the deal done?
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
I imagine deal has already been struck, but won't be announced until trade week officially begins.
I imagine deal has already been struck, but won't be announced until trade week officially begins.
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
SEN said he is going to announce Carlton as his preferred club this afternoon. Notice, preferred club...
Its obviously all the money. Him saying he wanted to move to a club who has a good chance of playing in finals is all bullsh*t...
SEN said he is going to announce Carlton as his preferred club this afternoon. Notice, preferred club...
Its obviously all the money. Him saying he wanted to move to a club who has a good chance of playing in finals is all bullsh*t...
- Thread starter
- #8
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
Maybe, but the club is busy with other issues at the moment. Eagles will still try and get other clubs involved.
Maybe, but the club is busy with other issues at the moment. Eagles will still try and get other clubs involved.
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
I'm sure a lot of dealing would of been going on behind the scenes for this one to come off! Gonna be really interesting to see what we get in return! Still, I'm happy it's Carlton and not the Pies!
I'm sure a lot of dealing would of been going on behind the scenes for this one to come off! Gonna be really interesting to see what we get in return! Still, I'm happy it's Carlton and not the Pies!
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
You? You get the crabs
Ah well, you might get something decent in return
Im like a kid at christmas!!
Wadda we get, wadda we get!!
You? You get the crabs
Ah well, you might get something decent in return
Star_is_Braun
Senior List
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
hhhmmmm....... choices choices choices.
hhhmmmm....... choices choices choices.
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
mate , i was telling you from just about day 1
3 , kennedy and probably 20
its been done for ages
Im like a kid at christmas!!
Wadda we get, wadda we get!!
mate , i was telling you from just about day 1
3 , kennedy and probably 20
its been done for ages
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
Good.
Now if the Pies want him they'll have to come up with a damn good offer,not the crap they would of come up with if Pieland was his preferred home.
Hope it turns into a bidding war.
People invariably end up paying too much at an auction.
Good.
Now if the Pies want him they'll have to come up with a damn good offer,not the crap they would of come up with if Pieland was his preferred home.
Hope it turns into a bidding war.
People invariably end up paying too much at an auction.
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
So what's the minimum you think your club should take? I'd say it's a given that pick 3 will be involved, but what else? 3,20 & Kennedy has been the popular guess, but I think Carlton will get someone else involved to get pick 3 up a bit, maybe early teens. I'd say 3 & about 13 might be minimum.
So what's the minimum you think your club should take? I'd say it's a given that pick 3 will be involved, but what else? 3,20 & Kennedy has been the popular guess, but I think Carlton will get someone else involved to get pick 3 up a bit, maybe early teens. I'd say 3 & about 13 might be minimum.
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
I am very very happy he chose carlton over collingwood. As someone above me wisely said, it is only a preferred option. He would still go to collingwood if we couldn't get a deal done with carlton. Hopefully the competition to get him combined with the egos of Pratt and Eddie will push his price up. And seeing the eagles saying 1 and 3 is a minimum is also encouraging.
I am very very happy he chose carlton over collingwood. As someone above me wisely said, it is only a preferred option. He would still go to collingwood if we couldn't get a deal done with carlton. Hopefully the competition to get him combined with the egos of Pratt and Eddie will push his price up. And seeing the eagles saying 1 and 3 is a minimum is also encouraging.
- Banned
- #17
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
You guys have to deal for Pick 1 and Pick 3.
That's what Judd is worth, you guys are getting done over if you accept less.
You guys have to deal for Pick 1 and Pick 3.
That's what Judd is worth, you guys are getting done over if you accept less.
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
I'm sure the recruitment boys will try their best but I think 3 + 20 + JK is the deal
I'm sure the recruitment boys will try their best but I think 3 + 20 + JK is the deal
Alphanumeric
Premiership Player
Flukey!
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 23, 2005
- 10,551
- 12,126
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Toronto BlueJays
- Banned
- #23
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
Just heard on SEN Rusell, Wiggins and pick 3 for Judd. Can't see that happening myself but who knows.
Just heard on SEN Rusell, Wiggins and pick 3 for Judd. Can't see that happening myself but who knows.
- May 22, 2006
- 2,693
- 3,009
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
Are we allowed to negotiate with Richmond too - try and play Carlton and Richmond off against each other??
Are we allowed to negotiate with Richmond too - try and play Carlton and Richmond off against each other??
Looking For 4th
Senior List
- Aug 29, 2007
- 252
- 0
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Sharks,49ers, Glenelg,
Re: Carlton it is.!!!
www.news.com.au/heraldsun/story/0,21985,22517108-661,00.html
Confirmation (Well sort of)
www.news.com.au/heraldsun/story/0,21985,22517108-661,00.html
