Opinion The Evolution of Your Best 23 for 2024

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
RossFC

RossFC

Moderator
Veteran 30k Posts HBF's Milk Crate - 70k Posts EPL Tipping Winner TheBrownDog WWE Board Bring Back the Bars Soccer Board Poster of the Year
May 23, 2012
88,903
145,003
Alberton Oval
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Liverpool
Will edit when list changes are made

Port Adelaide POWER - Round 1 vs ?
F: Lord - Dixon - Rioli
HF: Powell-Pepper - Marshall - Horne-Francis
C: Bergman - Wines - Duursma
HB: Farrell - Aliir - Houston
B: Burton - McKenzie - Williams
R: Visentini - Butters - Rozee
INT: Drew - Boak - Jones - Finlayson
EMERG: Narkle (SUB) - Georgiades - Evans - Byrne-Jones

Port Adelaide MAGPIES - Round 1 vs ?
F: Lycett - Scully - Evans
HF: McEntee - Georgiades - Fantasia
C: Sinn - Mead - Bonner
HB: Dumont - K.Marshall - Byrne-Jones
B: Pasini - Clurey - Burgoyne
R: Hayes - Jackson - Narkle
INT: Teakle - Sutcliffe (C) - Barkla - McCallum
EMERG: Moore - Hagan
DEPTH: Szust - Montgomery - Short - Carter - Kirk - Aldridge - W.Ferrari - H.Ferrari - Lee - Cheesman - Weidemann - Turner - Wilson - Francou - McArthur - Cockatoo-Collins - Motlop - Wildman - Miller

Unavailable:
AFL: NONE
SANFL: NONE
 
Last edited:
My ideal team for next year (not necessarily Round 1)

B: BZT - Ratugolea - Burton
HB: Williams - Aliir - Houston
C: Bergman - JHF - Farrell
HF: Georgiades - Marshall - SPP
FF: Rioli - Lord - NEW
R: Sweet - Butters - Rozee
INT: Drew - Jones - Jackson - Sinn

Bring in BZT, Ratugolea, Sweet, and a small forward. Look at trading guys like Wines, DBJ and Duursma.

BZT plays third tall and releases Bergman to the wing.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

-I want to see Rozee play 50/50 Forward and mid with wines back inside.( kind of In the Petracca mould)
  • Farrell to wing or Forward.
  • Don't Know what to do with DBJ.
  • Even though Burgoyne looks like a wing/ Half back. Could be worth a shot up Foward.
-If Dixon Plays he needs to be fit enough to be able to ruck. His best minutes are when he plays 10 Min inside.
- I wish we had two Bergmans, he's becoming a Mr fixit or little Goddard like without kick though.
 
So where do Soldo, Sweet, Ratagolea (and possibly Zerk-Thatcher) sit within your best 22?
 
B: BZT Ratugolea Jones
HB: Burton Aliir Houston
C: Bergman Wines Farrell
HF: SPP Marshall JHF
F: Georgiades Dixon Rioli
FOLL: Soldo Butters Rozee
INT: Williams Drew Evans Finlayson
SUB: Sinn

Would ideally like to see Lord take Dixon's spot by the end of the season, with Finlayson moving to a roaming Westhoff type role on the wing.
 
RossFC said:
Port Adelaide POWER - Round 1 vs ?
F: Lord - Dixon - Rioli
HF: Powell-Pepper - Marshall - Horne-Francis
C: Bergman - Wines - Jones
HB: Farrell - Aliir - Houston
B: Zerk-Thatcher - Ratugolea - Williams
R: Soldo - Butters - Rozee
INT: Drew - Boak - Finlayson - Burton
EMERG: Byrne-Jones (SUB) - Georgiades - Sweet - McKenzie

Port Adelaide MAGPIES - Round 1 vs ?
F: Visentini - Scully - Fantasia
HF: Evans - Georgiades - McEntee
C: Jackson - Moore (C) - Burgoyne
HB: Sinn - K.Marshall - Byrne-Jones
B: Clurey - McKenzie - Pasini
R: Sweet - Mead - Narkle
INT: Lycett - Hayes - McCallum - Hagan
EMERG: Szust - Montgomery
DEPTH: Short - Carter - Kirk - Aldridge - W.Ferrari - H.Ferrari - Lee - Cheesman - Weidemann - Turner - Wilson - Francou - McArthur - Cockatoo-Collins - Motlop - Wildman - Miller

Unavailable:
AFL: NONE
SANFL: NONE
Click to expand...
Pretty spot on teams look pretty decent too
 
B: Burton, Ratugolea, Zerk-Thatcher
HB: Houston, Aliir, Williams
C: Farrell, Butters, Bergman
HF: Horne-Francis, Marshall, Powell-Pepper
F: Georgiadis, Dixon, Rioli
Foll: Soldo, Wines, Rozee
B: Boak, Drew, Jones, Finnlayson
S: Byrne-Jones

Depth
Clurey, Burgoyne, McKenzie, Sinn, Narkle, Jackson, Evans, McEntee, Lord, Sweet

33 players (maybe more) all capable of playing first team footy next year is a huge win. I think we’re a little short for midfield depth so I expect us to draft smaller types but ultimately adding the talls we did and Georgiadis coming back from injury just allows our smalls across the ground to play their natural positions and be more damaging. Still think we’re 1 small forward short but realistically if Ollie plays his natural position in and under we should be able to cover a small forward through our midfield resting. I’m overly satisfied with how this all worked out. Losing Duursma will be a win ultimately because Farrell and Bergman are far superior players.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
full forward: Pick 94

Coach: Josh Carr

Bench bum-slapper and finger-wiggler: daddy donuts
 
B: Burgoyne, Ratugolea, Z-T
HB: Williams, Aliir, Houston
C: Farrell, Wines, Bergman
HF: Butters, Marshall, Powell-Pepper
F: Georgiadis, Dixon, Rioli
Foll: Soldo, H-F, Rozee
Int: Jackson, Drew, Jones, Finlayson
Sub: Burton/Boak/DBJ
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

B: McKenzie Ratugolea Burton
HB: Houston Aliir Jones
C: Farrell Horne-Francis Bergman
HF: Powell-Pepper Dixon Byrne-Jones
F: Rioli Lord Marshall

R: Soldo Rozee Butters

INT: Finlayson Wines Drew Williams

SUB: Boak

Forward line is the toughest part. I've got Byrne-Jones starting ahead of McEntee and Lord starting ahead of Georgiades but you could easily flip those.
 
Can Farrell really play wing? Feel like we've tried it and he just gets lost. His main weapon is his kick, which is utilised way better from HBF as others can easily get the ball into his hands. It's probably between him and Williams for the 7th defender slot.

However, I am intrigued by the idea of Finlayson on a wing.
 
melanChronic said:
Can Farrell really play wing? Feel like we've tried it and he just gets lost. His main weapon is his kick, which is utilised way better from HBF as others can easily get the ball into his hands. It's probably between him and Williams for the 7th defender slot.

However, I am intrigued by the idea of Finlayson on a wing.
Click to expand...

The only other options are Burgoyne, Boak and Burton, all of whom also have question marks over their ability to play the role.
 
melanChronic said:
Can Farrell really play wing? Feel like we've tried it and he just gets lost. His main weapon is his kick, which is utilised way better from HBF as others can easily get the ball into his hands. It's probably between him and Williams for the 7th defender slot.

However, I am intrigued by the idea of Finlayson on a wing.
Click to expand...
They'll pile 15-20 games into Sinn and trade him out because we think all wingmen smell funny
 
FB: Brandon Zerk-Thatcher | Esava Ratagolea | Ryan Burton
HB: Dan Houston | Aliir Aliir | Dylan Williams
C: Miles Bergman | Willem Drew | Kane Farrell
R: Ivan Soldo | Zak Butters | Connor Rozee
HF: Jason Horne-Francis | Charlie Dixon | Sam Powell-Pepper
FF: Mitch Georgiades | Todd Marshall | Willie Rioli
I: Lachie Jones | Ollie Wines | Francis Evans | Josh Sinn
S: Darcy Byrne-Jones
E: Jeremy Finlayson | Travis Boak | Jase Burgoyne
 
FB: T. McKenzie, E. Ratugolea, D. Williams
HB: D. Houston, A. Aliir, R. Burton
C: M. Bergman, O. Wines, K. Farrell
HF: J. Horne-Francis, T. Marshall, S. Powell-Pepper
F: W. Rioli, C. Dixon, J. Finlayson
R: I. Soldo, C. Rozee, Z. Butters
INT: W. Drew, D. Byrne-Jones, L. Jones, T. Boak
SUB: F. Evans

J. Burgoyne, Q. Narkle, M. Georgiades, O. Lord others under consideration, and hopefully Sinn makes his way into that group too. I'm assuming Fantasia will either be delisted and/or injured, which seems a pretty safe bet.

Realistically I'm sure BZT will be picked over McKenzie and spud McEntee will probably be in there somewhere, but the thread title says my best 23, not the club's.
 
Trent McKenzie Aliir Aliir Brandon Zerk-Thatcher
Dylan Williams Esava Ratugolea Dan Houston
Miles Bergman Zak Butters Ryan Burton
Sam Powell-Pepper Todd Marshall Connor Rozee
Willie Rioli Ollie Lord Charlie Dixon

R: Ivan Soldo Willam Drew Jason Horne-Francis
Int: Lachie Jones, Jordon Sweet, Jeremy Finlayson, Ollie Wines

Em: Mitch Georgiadis, Hugh Jackson, Quinton Narkle, Kane Farrell
 
Zerk-Thatcher, Ratugolea, Williams
Jones, Aliir, Houston
Bergman, Horne-Francis, Burgoyne
Powell-Pepper, Marshall, Finlayson
Rioli, Lord, Byrne-Jones
Soldo, Rozee, Butters
Drew, Wines, Farrell, Sweet
Sub - Sinn

I'm going young.
 
Last edited:
RangaInTeal said:
FB: BZT, Rat, Williams
HB: Burton, Aliir, Farrell
C: Bergman, Wines, Jackson
HF: SPP, Marshall, Rozee
FF: Rioli, Dixon, Finlayson
Fol: Soldo, JHF, Butters
Int: Drew, Boak, Jones, DBJ
Click to expand...
How have I missed Houston?

Houston Half Back, Faz to the Wing Jackson/Sinn to sub.
 
Best 22:
FBDylan WilliamsEsava RatugoleaBrendon Zerk-Thatcher
HBDan HoustonAliir AliirRyan Burton
CMiles BergmanJason Horne FrancisWilliem Drew
HFJeremy FinlaysonTodd MarshallSam Powell Pepper
FFOrazio FantasiaCharlie DixonWillie Rioli
FOLJordon SweetZak ButtersConnor Rozee
INTOllie WinesKane FarrellDarcy Byrne JonesIvan Soldo
SUBFrancis Evans
2nd Team:
FBTom ClureyTrent McKenzieTom McCallum
HBLachie JonesKyle MarshallJase Burgoyne
CTravis BoakJackson MeadJosh Sinn
HFMitch GeorgiadesOllie Lord
FFThomas ScullyJed McEntee
FOLDante VisentiniHugh JacksonQuinton Narkle
INTScott LycettSam HayesJake Pasini

I'm thinking something like this. Drew on the wing but will also play on ball. Finlayson/Marshall/Dixon for R1 but injuries and form will most likely mix that up. Imo Sweet > Soldo but also play Soldo as back up ruck so 5 talls. Orazio starts because he is good enough but probably won't be here next year and he'll have injuries. Tbh anything for McEntee not to start.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

RossFC
Opinion The Evolution of Your Best 23 for 2025
2 3 4
Replies
80
Views
4K
RossFC
RossFC
RossFC
Official Club Stuff 2024 AGM - to be held on Friday 6th December 2024, 1 director to be elected by members. Nominations called for.
5 6 7 8 9
Replies
213
Views
8K
El_Scorcho
El_Scorcho
RussellEbertHandball
Resource Exodus - movement of Jah people. 2004 vs 2024
Replies
22
Views
854
Portology
Portology
El Zorro
  • Locked
Game Day Game Day Thread for QF2, 2024 vs Geelong
75 76 77 78 79
Replies
2K
Views
48K
philreich
philreich
RangaInTeal
  • Locked
Preview Changes & Preview Thread for QF2, 2024 vs Geelong
31 32 33 34 35
Replies
865
Views
34K
Addy23
A
Holden Hillbilly
Brownlow 2024 Brownlow Medal
6 7 8 9 10
Replies
236
Views
6K
Lefti93
Lefti93
Marmozet
  • Locked
Preview Changes & Preview Thread for 2024 Preliminary Final vs Sydney @ SCG
31 32 33 34 35
Replies
859
Views
32K
Buget
Buget

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top