Reply to thread

What the shit are you talking about? The vast majority of coaches who won a premiership haven't won one before. It's much rarer for an experienced premiership coach to win another one at a second club.

It's completely without any precedent for someone to win one, when they haven't even made a grand final in 12 years.

Changing coaches doesn't guarantee you a flag. Of course not. It doesn't guarantee you'll get better. But it gives you a chance.

Chance of ken Hinkley winning a flag after 11 years and no grand finals, doing something that no one has ever done in 130+ years of AFL history: maybe 2%.

Chance of port winning a flag at some point in the next 4 years, with a stacked midfield of butters, Rozee and JHF with a new coach: at least 25%.

We have no hope. Despite another top 4 finish looking likely, basically no one thinks we're a chance, because we've got the same inefficient game style, and the same mentally weak coach instilling his anxiety and fears in the players.

Was getting rid of Leon Cameron a bad move? Kingsley spanked ken in the semi final last year and GWS are now flag favourites.