Random Best Sportsperson discussion

[Keyter]

bradman was overrated at the swans...on par with dermot b. imo

 

[The King!]

Bradman to me is one of sports biggest statistical outliers miles ahead of the next best in his sport, not sure there is such an AFL player ever

 

[caesar88]

bradman was overrated at the swans...on par with dermot b. imo

Went alright at the SCG, could do with him in recent years

 

[caesar88]

Bradman to me is one of sports biggest statistical outliers miles ahead of the next best in his sport, not sure there is such an AFL player ever

To be fair AFL is much harder sport I reckon.

 

[SGBeach]

50+ innings
Bradman 99.94
Steve Smith 64.56
Sutcliffe 60.73

No one in any game gets even close to Bradman
Plugger was more like

 

[caesar88]

50+ innings
Bradman 99.94
Steve Smith 64.56
Sutcliffe 60.73

No one in any game gets even close to Bradman
Plugger was more like

As I said though cricket is an easier sport.

It's harder to dominate a sport that's as difficult as AFL because you have to basically be a sci-fi superhero to do so.

 

[SSwans2011]

Average points per game:
Bradman: 99.94
Plugger: 31.14

Incomparable

 

[The King!]

As I said though cricket is an easier sport.

It's harder to dominate a sport that's as difficult as AFL because you have to basically be a sci-fi superhero to do so.

cricket is harder than footy is not a fact though

 

[SSwans2011]

As I said though cricket is an easier sport.

It's harder to dominate a sport that's as difficult as AFL because you have to basically be a sci-fi superhero to do so.

I don't know, mate. I'm pretty shit at both, but feel like I could at least get one effective disposal in if you gave me a full AFL season.

Don't think I'd score many runs or take many catches with the ball flying around at 140km/hr though.

 

[RobbieK]

As I said though cricket is an easier sport.

It's harder to dominate a sport that's as difficult as AFL because you have to basically be a sci-fi superhero to do so.

This doesn't explain why Bradman is so far ahead of his closest competition.

Seriously, Bradman is a crazy outlier, the kind of which simply does not exist in basically any other sports.

 

[Mick Oxlong]

50+ innings
Bradman 99.94
Steve Smith 64.56
Sutcliffe 60.73

No one in any game gets even close to Bradman
Plugger was more like

Steve Smith being compared to Bradman is a joke. None of these ‘heroes’ of today would play on uncovered pitches in fading light!

 

[The King!]

Steve Smith being compared to Bradman is a joke. None of these ‘heroes’ of today would play on uncovered pitches in fading light!

Bradman never went to India though

And past 300 he used to lose concentration

 

[swansfan51]

As I said though cricket is an easier sport.

It's harder to dominate a sport that's as difficult as AFL because you have to basically be a sci-fi superhero to do so.

Cricket is played by 1/3 of the planet and Aussie Rules is played by half of one pretty small country

Fair bit more competition

 

[ScrewInStuds]

Bradman to me is one of sports biggest statistical outliers miles ahead of the next best in his sport, not sure there is such an AFL player ever

Only valid comparison is Gretzky in ice hockey imo

 

[Mick Oxlong]

Bradman never went to India though

And past 300 he used to lose concentration

Probably would’ve struggled on their flat tracks I guess, Tendulkar did.

 

[Mick Oxlong]

Only valid comparison is Gretzky in ice hockey imo

Johnno at the pub is pretty good at darts...he doesn’t play but he’s good for 3 packets per day!

 

[DobmusEdge]

Bradman never went to India though

And past 300 he used to lose concentration

Or constantly adapt to other formats and then readapt back to test mode again

 

[DobmusEdge]

Don't want to take the thread off track but will just finish by saying plenty of people over the journey have made the same points you have here Kingy but they forget one important thing. Lockett missed nearly 100 games through injury and suspension. **** knows how many Goals he would have finished his career on. Call him Bradman, Roy Hobbs The Natural or whatever the **** but Imo He is The GOAT.

Bradman lost eight years due to WW2

 

[swansfan51]

Only valid comparison is Gretzky in ice hockey imo

Aleksandr Karelin might make things interesting

Bradman still the best though

 

[ScrewInStuds]

Johnno at the pub is pretty good at darts...he doesn’t play but he’s good for 3 packets per day!

My mate Barry used to do the same, *before* filters were mandatory. Doubt anyone from today's pubs could do the same.

 

[Mick Oxlong]

My mate Barry used to do the same, *before* filters were mandatory. Doubt anyone from today's pubs could do the same.

Bet they can vape

 

[ScrewInStuds]

Aleksandr Karelin might make things interesting

Bradman still the best though

Have to admit that I hadn't heard of Karelin but just did some quick reading and he sounds like a beast. I don't have much of a frame of reference for greco Roman so will take your word for it

 

[The King!]

jordan is up there

 

[mikey_san]

bradman was overrated at the swans...on par with dermot b. imo

Silly bugger turned up to training 50 years early once too.

 

[Tesla Tenet]

That Walter Lindrum bloke could play.

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk