Both much maligned players for various reasons but who do you think is the better player??
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Justin Koschitzke V Travis Cloke
- Thread starter charcoalchicken
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Kosi is lucky to be getting games this year, enough said.
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
One's average and one's a spud. Therefore, Cloke wins.
The poll has two options, not three. For what it's worth, Cloke would be your starting centre half-forward.Neither. Kosi has a lot more talent, but looks completely lost at the moment. They should play him in the ruck. Problem is they have no other KP forwards.
The poll has two options, not three. For what it's worth, Cloke would be your starting centre half-forward.
Parrot clearly has very little knowledge on anything related to Aussie Rules Football. Don't feed the trolls
Cloke had one v good year and looks alright this year, the rest pretty poor. Kosi had one good year (his first) thus Cloke > Kosi but not by much
gb
gb
Based on this year, Cloke easily.
Kosi is struggling a lot. Hopefully he can turn his form around.
Kosi is struggling a lot. Hopefully he can turn his form around.
- May 29, 2009
- 29,828
- 14,928
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- LA Lakers
Instead of Jarrad Waite? Keep dreaming champ. Waite kicked as many goals against St Kilda as the whole Collingwood team.The poll has two options, not three. For what it's worth, Cloke would be your starting centre half-forward.
Keep dreaming.
Waite ended v us as he always does, trying to buy a touch in the backline.
- Banned
- #14
not much between them imo
you wouldn't win a premiership with either as your no 1 kpf
you wouldn't win a premiership with either as your no 1 kpf
Wow, Waite a decent game, stop the press.
I'm not sure if you're aware, but I'll inform you anyway. Cloke averages more disposals, goals, marks, goal assists and inside 50's than your spud Waite. Oh and, Waite's only played a total of 14 games in the past two seasons. How 'bout you wake up from your dream, pal.
- Sep 25, 2006
- 18,373
- 14,647
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- FC Barcelona, Liverpool, FC Bayern
Neither. Kosi has a lot more talent, but looks completely lost at the moment. They should play him in the ruck. Problem is they have no other KP forwards.
Is that you Wallsy?
D I D A K #4
Debutant
Do you mean that you have to have a better kpf than cloke to win a premiership
Because if so how did your club win two with Mooney and Hawkins
- Banned
- #19
Do you mean that you have to have a better kpf than cloke to win a premiership
Because if so how did your club win two with Mooney and Hawkins
because mooney is twice the player cloke is
btw we have won 1 with hawkins, do some research before firing off ill informed trolls
Similar threads
