Reply to thread

I get strong JHF vibes from Reid. Both are all but unstoppable on their day, but both have significant temperament issues.

Reid never recovered from the massive dummy spit against St Kilda and suspension.

West Coast also now have a rookie coach who lacks foundation in the club, similar to Noble.

If he's not going to be round for the next flag tilt, and I doubt he is, then cash him now and get someone who helps build the group.

Thing with Harley and JHF is they're both absolute rolled gold class finishing players.

They're who you go out and get to cap off a list, they're not guys you build around because they don't like losing nor do they like hard work.

If he's not going to commit long term to the build like a Sheezel, get players who will.