Don't agree with this.
AA is more tainted than the Brownlow.
I think there's genuine merit to making the AA40 because it tends to be a good selection of players who have performed well. Those that 'make' the team always raise eyebrows but the 40 NEVER does.
Stuff the jackets.
Unfortunately I think it has become like this. Those the media adore get them, those they don't have to work twice as hard. Then afterwards, the sheer number is held up like some justification that just cannot be questioned.
It's mattered a lot less the last few seasons.