Does Izak Rankine have the highest natural talent in the AFL?

Remove this Banner Ad

Cleric

Cleric

Brownlow Medallist
Veteran 10k Posts
Oct 14, 2011
15,556
17,614
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
There are players who are great because of their work rate and discipline, and then there are players who are just natural freaks. Cyril Rioli, Eddie Betts, Darren Jarman type players.
As it stands, is Izak Rankine the most naturally talented player in the AFL now?.
It's not about where he sits now, it's about his freakish talent.

Who else is up there?
 
Cleric said:
There are players who are great because of their work rate and discipline, and then there are players who are just natural freaks. Cyril Rioli, Eddie Betts, Darren Jarman type players.
As it stands, is Izak Rankine the most naturally talented player in the AFL now?.
It's not about where he sits now, it's about his freakish talent.

Who else is up there?
Click to expand...
Hate the bloke and he plays for my side, but Shai Bolton?

Only thing would be we haven't seen what Rankine can do in a side that is flying. Bolton when in those sides is a top 5 in the league player, in a shit side he is useless.
 
Rankine and Bolton are very good early mentions

Others:
Sheezel
N Daicos
Wiz
Wanganeen-Millera
Jezza
Curnow
Gulden
Bailey
Merrett
K Pickett
W Rioli
Liam Ryan

And probably for me, the biggest freak:
Toby Greene
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Please don't be a crows fan
Please don't be a crows fan
Please don't be a crows fan

Season 3 Wtf GIF by The Simpsons
 
I remember watching him in the Sanfl in the years before he was drafted thinking he was the most talented junior I'd seen.

There are a bigger of other players already mentioned that would be on a similar level of talent.
 
Has to be near the top love watching him play.
A dark horse who is one of those players like Hird who just makes the hard look easy is Hayden Young in terms of kicking and smooth decisions he is a Rolls Royce.
 
Cleric said:
There are players who are great because of their work rate and discipline, and then there are players who are just natural freaks. Cyril Rioli, Eddie Betts, Darren Jarman type players.
As it stands, is Izak Rankine the most naturally talented player in the AFL now?.
It's not about where he sits now, it's about his freakish talent.

Who else is up there?
Click to expand...
natural talent = doesn't train hard enough

give me preternatural talent of gagf
 
BringFevBack2021 said:
Rankine and Bolton are very good early mentions

Others:
Sheezel
N Daicos
Wiz
Wanganeen-Millera
Jezza
Curnow
Gulden
Bailey
Merrett
K Pickett
W Rioli
Liam Ryan

And probably for me, the biggest freak:
Toby Greene
Click to expand...
THere's only 1 Wizard and that's Jeff Farmer. What have you seen from nick Watson? Horrendous accuracy in front of goal. Hell he even missed a shot from the goal square when Sicily yelled at him.
 
Jammara does things for his size that are way too natural, It has always annoyed me when I hear in basketball discussions about guys like shaq that he has no skill, being big powerful or fast is a skill in my mind, It is something you are better at than someone else.
 
Id have to say Curnow is the best 'talent'

Best contested mark in the comp, strong, good runner, huge leap, extremely good 1 on 1, probably the best KPF once the ball hits the deck and can kick it 60m off a step. And that's all after almost 3 years of repeat knee injuries.

Bont would be another, can just about do it all.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

danster168 said:
THere's only 1 Wizard and that's Jeff Farmer. What have you seen from nick Watson? Horrendous accuracy in front of goal. Hell he even missed a shot from the goal square when Sicily yelled at him.
Click to expand...
He didn't give himself the nickname...

If you want to compare Farmer's and Watson's first seasons in the AFL, Watson averages more: Kicks, handballs, goals, behinds, tackles and marks.

What more did you want the kid to do?
 
Cleric said:
There are players who are great because of their work rate and discipline, and then there are players who are just natural freaks. Cyril Rioli, Eddie Betts, Darren Jarman type players.
As it stands, is Izak Rankine the most naturally talented player in the AFL now?.
It's not about where he sits now, it's about his freakish talent.

Who else is up there?
Click to expand...
I honestly think yes.

I said a while ago that I think rankine will be the games best player once he develops a tank and moves permanently into the midfield and I got laughed at.
 
danster168 said:
THere's only 1 Wizard and that's Jeff Farmer. What have you seen from nick Watson? Horrendous accuracy in front of goal. Hell he even missed a shot from the goal square when Sicily yelled at him.
Click to expand...

Sirlemsip said:
He didn't give himself the nickname...

If you want to compare Farmer's and Watson's first seasons in the AFL, Watson averages more: Kicks, handballs, goals, behinds, tackles and marks.

What more did you want the kid to do?
Click to expand...
He is dynamic, powerful and skilful

His finishing infront of goal hasn’t been great but you cannot deny his ability
 
I find it oddly amusing that there are so many Aboriginal players that are being claimed as having the "highest natural talent".

I think a few people here dismiss some Aboriginal players hard work and dedication in favour of "he is just born talented" - especially considering some of those players arent even close to the best in the AFL.

FYI I think the highest natural talent in the AFL currently is: Patrick Dangerfield (explosive & big bodied - supposedly his socks didn't fit properly around his calves they are so big.. just a genetic freak)
 
carndapies said:
I find it oddly amusing that there are so many Aboriginal players that are being claimed as having the "highest natural talent".

I think a few people here dismiss some Aboriginal players hard work and dedication in favour of "he is just born talented" - especially considering some of those players arent even close to the best in the AFL.

FYI I think the highest natural talent in the AFL currently is: Patrick Dangerfield (explosive & big bodied - supposedly his socks didn't fit properly around his calves they are so big.. just a genetic freak)
Click to expand...
I would argue that athletic ability and skill execution is the differentiation here, not the race of the player or your implication that posters like myself are asserting that indigenous players aren’t hard workers (point to where anyone said that)

Do you think that Nasiah, K Pickett, W Rioli and L Ryan are not freak talents? Nasiah hits the hardest kicks at his best, K Pickett has an innate ability around goal, W Rioli is amazing on both feet and is so quick hand to foot and Liam Ryan has a leap and incredible foot skills
 
It's very hard to compare talls and smalls here.

Charlie Cameron does both but took a bit of time to hit his straps so there's a fair bit of work he needed to reach his current ceiling.

Jeremy Cameron does it on the ground and in the air. Sam Darcy is a freak on the ground for a 209cm bloke. Luke Jackson worthy of a mention.

I love watching The Lizard and his kicking at pace is incredible so he deserves to be named here too.
 
Sirlemsip said:
He didn't give himself the nickname...

If you want to compare Farmer's and Watson's first seasons in the AFL, Watson averages more: Kicks, handballs, goals, behinds, tackles and marks.

What more did you want the kid to do?
Click to expand...
dude, he's kicked like 2 more goals than Windsor who doesn't even play in the forward line. And good luck comparing Watson to the real Wizard who kicked 9 goals in a half, took marks of the century contenders, goal of the years and almost 500 goals over a long career.

Correct, he didn't give himself the nickname. But people shouldn't be calling him that. It's disrespectful to an all time great. Or do we start calling Grainger-barass the 'G-train' while we're at it?
 
I mean, if we're speaking about 'natural talent' it probably isn't worth mentioning guys who took multiple years to come on, as clearly they needed development work. Rankine is still only borderline elite and he's 24.

Harry Sheezel is probably the best and most versatile first and now second year player I've ever seen. Bloke stepped into the competition averaging 30 touches, with elite disposal, and has now played at an elite level as a defender and midfielder, when the position he was drafted for was as a forward. With the minimal amount of 'development' time he's had in the AFL, he's one of the few players you can say were elite straight off the bat on talent.

People do seem to be conflating agility and evasiveness with natural talent in general in this thread though.

AFL is such a multifaceted sport, being talented at avoiding tackles and getting shots at goal is a small fraction of the skills required to play the game.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Does Izak Rankine have the highest natural talent in the AFL?

Similar threads

G
  • Poll
Does Geelong have the worst midfield in the AFL?
6 7 8 9 10
Replies
243
Views
8K
Cleansweep17
Cleansweep17
GC2015
  • Poll
Opinion Question for Victorians - Does it bother you not having a Vic team in the GF?
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
143
Views
4K
Seahound
S
Eastdog
The Victorian suburbs where all 18 AFL clubs have their most members
Replies
9
Views
1K
Falchoon
Falchoon
J
Who are the S-Tier Under-23 talents of the competition?
Replies
21
Views
835
thistimeforsure
thistimeforsure
LordLucifer
Roast "Forget Fairness : AFL’s Fixture Of Inequities & Quirks Does The Sport Few Favours" (The Guardian)
Replies
6
Views
499
Billy ray
Billy ray
Taper
Does Nathan Buckley deserve credit for the 2023 premiership?
Replies
20
Views
585
76woodenspooners
76woodenspooners
mattwa
Where does Marcus Bontempelli sit in the players of this era
12 13 14 15 16
Replies
396
Views
14K
Fadge
F

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top