Reply to thread

Moore wouldn't be best 22.  We'd play Cloke and Reid forward and one of White or Grundy with Witts being the number one ruck.  I'd pick Grundy over White.

We can't play both Brown and Frost in the same backline.  They are both pure shut down players and offer no rebound.  On top of that they are both ordinary kicks and decision makers (especially Frost).  Frost is more athletic than Brown but Brown is bigger.  So I'd pick Brown.  Keeffe plays CHB to allow Reid to play forward.  Keeffe rebounding ability will allow Reid to play forward.  The three tall defenders I'd have is Brown, Keeffe and Goldsack.  Goldsack/Toovey.  Goldsack and Toovey are players that can play tall and small no problem so they'd be the third talls.

I'd have Swan as a forward, not sure why his named on a wing he's a centre mid.  Adams is a direct replacement for Luke Ball and at the end of last year showed really good form and went ahead of Ball.  He's starting 18.

Also Varcoe will spend allot of time on the wing.

Spot on

Frost is a bit one dimensional.  I think he'll play allot of VFL and add more strings to his bow.  Clinton Young I'd have best 22 after losing Lumumba.  Blair is best 22 as long as Buckley is still coaching.  If Reid play forward I think Blair will go better.

I'd go with:

B: Tyson Goldsack ~ Nathan Brown ~ Marley Williams

HB: Tom Langdon ~ Lachlan Keeffe ~ Paul Seedsman

C: Steele Sidebottom ~ Taylor Adams ~ Clinton Young

HF: Travis Varcoe ~ Travis Cloke ~ Dane Swan

F: Brodie Grundy ~ Ben Reid ~ Jamie Elliott

R: Jarrod Witts ~ Levi Greenwood ~ Scott Pendlebury

INT: Jarryd Blair ~ Timothy Broomhead ~ Tony Armstrong

Sub: Nathan Freeman