Reply to thread

How much evidence do you want?

The only objective ratings system available to us rates 6 of Dusty's finals performaces above the only one of 3 that was rated of Buddy's that you say were ALL better than Dusty's best.

Coaches votes.  Smith Medals.  Opinions from greats of the game.  Player ratings.

All up against the might and power of 1 x Hawthorn supporter named H00t who says otherwise.