4 favourite and 4 least favourite footy media people

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Favourite
Abbey Holmes
Chief
Bucks
Molloy

Least
Healey
Mcclure Sam
Precious
Jobe

Forgot Robbo. Fake emotion at the same minutes in on 360 just scripted bullshit. 360 is a great show whenever he’s away
 
Last edited:
Favourite:
David King
Dermott Brereton
Kane Cornes
Jason Dunstall

Least Favourite:
All the pencil neck virgin/ nerd reporters McClure, Twomey etc.
 
Meh I'll play..

Faves:

Papalia.
Bennett.
Cornes.
Lloyd.

Least fave:

Derrrrwayne.
JB.
Dwayne Russell.
Healy.

Let it be said I don't dislike these people I just think they are terribly shit at there jobs.
 
favorite:

N/A

least favorite:

Garry Lyon
Sarah Jones
Kelli Underwood
Kath Loughnan
Jonathan Brown
Nick Riewoldt
Gerard Whateley
Mark Robinson
Tony Jones
Matthew Richardson
Patrick Dangerfield
Andrew Mah
Sam Pang
Mick Molloy
Sam McClure
Jon Ralph
Caroline Wilson
Jimmy Bartel
Leigh Matthews
Luke Hodge
Wayne Carey
Jobe Watson
Tim Watson
Cameron Ling
James Brayshaw

+ all the other ones
 
My 2024 Rankings

Bruce Mcevaney is the Gold standard.

Top 4

1. Cal Twomey
2. Abbey Holmes
3. Nathan Buckley
4. Kane Cornes
5. Matthew Lloyd
6. Jason Dunstall

Bottom 4

1. David King - Worst by a million miles. Struts around like he owns the place, talks over everyone, made some really stupid calls this year. I can't stand the guy.
2. Sam Mclure
3. Nathan G Brown
4. Daisy Thomas, Luke Darcy, Luke Hodge
 
Like:
Lloydy
Dermie
Kane Cornes
Cal Twomey

flogs:
David King
BT
Dwayne
Eddie
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Favourite

Kane Cornes- always loved listening to him. Knowledgeable, has a go back, doesn’t back down to daisy and Luke Darcy. Does the research. And seems like a good bloke

Mitch cleary- I listen to him quite a bit on various podcasts. Pretty knowledgeable, gets majority of his stuff right, only negative is he doesn’t challenge McClure back

David king- I find him reslly funny on sen. I do appreciate the time he puts into things before he says it. Probably went too hard on fagan but was sortve fair at the time?
Leigh Montagna- he seems pretty balanced in his views. Genuinely believes what he says.
Cal twomey- best journalist in the afl.

Least-
Sam mcclure - need I say more
Andy maher smug prick. Think he’s some legend
Jon ralph- smug prick can’t stand him
Dale Thomas
Luke Darcy- ****wit
 
Last edited:
Fav. Abbey Holmes.
Erin Phillips.
Sarah Jones.
Kate Massey.


Least. Caroline Wilson.
Kelli Underwood.
Susan Alberti.
Trent Cotchin
 
Favourite
Cornes - Runs the media, is a troll
Kingy - Like Cornes different to everyone else
Morris - Best journo, very sharp, rarely wrong.
Papala - Good caller, refreshing and can create excitement

Least
McLure - In a league of his own, not a single redeeming feature
Maher - Terrible in every regard
Whately - Good caller but his ego controlls him. AFL and Hinkley mouthpiece. Can feel how full of shit he is through the TV.
D.Thomas - One of those blokes who gets outraged easily.
 
Favourites:

Leigh Matthews: still speaks more sense and simplifies any topic far better than most

Matt Hill: best tv caller by a long way for mine, clear and accurate

Sarah Jones: best game day and/or studio host by a fair margin

Jason Dunstall: clear, no nonsense analysis. Bounce role definitely excluded from this rating!

Worst:

Mark Robinson: long overdue sacking from 360 should improve that show immensely. Has done / did well to last as long as he has in multiple highly paid, high profile media roles with very little talent for any of them. His bias and total lack of professionalism in relation to Essendon / Hird / Sheedy matters alone should have been enough to see him fired long ago

Caroline Wilson: used to regularly break big stories and occasionally still does, but for the most part now comes across as bitter and vengeful. Makes a living from a game and industry in which she seems to hate most of the participants

Damien Barrett: makes the two above look fair and measured by comparison. Just a gutter 'journo' of the worst kind.

David King: manages to be significantly wrong very regularly for someone so arrogantly dismissive of the opinions of others. Laptop prop doesn't make him look smarter or better informed than his peers, it just makes him look like a flog.
 
Least:
'Huddo'
Brayshaw
Brownless
Hasleby

Faves:
Lynch
J. Reiwoldt
Hill
Matthews

Andy 'Birrarung' Maher gets a special mention - I actually like his game commentary, but is unlistenable on his SEN afternoon show.
 
Favourites:

Matt Hill
Adam Papalia
Tony Leonard
Sarah Jones

Least Favourite

Brian Taylor
James Brayshaw
Luke Darcy
Mark Ruiciutto

See if anyone can spot a pattern
 

Remove this Banner Ad

4 favourite and 4 least favourite footy media people

Similar threads

T
media your favourite to least
2
Replies
43
Views
4K
TheJanuaryMan
T
Reg Grundy35
Where are the big media boys on the GWS issue?
Replies
2
Views
531
XhazzafootyX
XhazzafootyX
GOTHELIONS16
When is 4K coming to 7AFL coverage?
Replies
5
Views
667
enzso
E
Tandy
FTA-TV Footy Furnace
2 3
Replies
52
Views
5K
MC Extra Dollop
MC Extra Dollop
reubski23
The football media family tree
Replies
14
Views
2K
stmookeyj
S
T
Moved Thread Media outlets and commentators that are against your team
2 3
Replies
61
Views
3K
Nat Fyfe
Nat Fyfe
T
Media outlets and commentors that are against your team
Replies
24
Views
2K
windyhill
windyhill

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top