List Mgmt. Dayne Beams, (FAIR) trade thread (oppo fans welcome if respectful - DONT TROLL!!)

[Anzacday]

Pies supporters place their suggestions and posters from that club can respond.
Opposition supporters are welcome to post, (bid) and reasonable offers will be considered.
Let's try and keep it civil/respectable and see if we can do what the Lions wouldn't allow us to and that's GET A FAIR TRADE.

 

[ThisIsJake]

Treloar straight swap.

 

[Aed0s]

My avatar.

Very reasonable and entirely fair.

 

[hellfire]

Get any of WHE, Cameron, Shiel or Treloar... I'll be stoked. Some worth more than others of course... Fingers crossed one wants to come back to Vic.

 

[danielnajdek]

Treloar.

 

[Stifler's mom]

Hoskin Elliott please.

 

[Stifler's mom]

Aish plus 5 for Beams and Keefe.

 

[Bring_Back_Brad]

Melbourne were offering pick 2 and 3 for dangerfield.. Could we give them beams?
2 and 3 would be nice.

 

[Anzacday]

Aish plus 5 for Beams and Keefe.

Wash your mouth out

 

[Ricky90]

I'll trade Beams to the Dogs for their 9th round pick now.

 

[MeisterBot]

8 + Lonergan + 29

Treloar straight swap

WHE + 19

 

[Stifler's mom]

Wash your mouth out!

Brown, Reid, Frost, Moore >>>>>>>Keefe.

 

[_GT_]

First issue is, would Beams have any interest in a move to GWS over GCS? If he has any genuine interest in getting to Brisbane area, why not see what GCS players are interested?

Second, all four GWS players listed above are unlikely to be traded. Treloar least likey, followed by Cameron. Not worried at all about these two. Shiel an outside chance, ahead of WHE. Shiel would be our biggest flight risk.

 

[Anzacday]

Brown, Reid, Frost, Moore >>>>>>>Keefe.

Don't agree however, we need spares in case of injuries again.
We want 5 & Aish for Beams straight up

 

[ksardog]

In WHE/Treloar and Stewart
Out Beams pick 29

 

[Anzacday]

First issue is, would Beams have any interest in a move to GWS over GCS? If he has any genuine interest in getting to Brisbane area, why not see what GCS players are interested?
Second, all four GWS players listed above are unlikely to be traded. Treloar least likey, followed by Cameron. Not worried at all about these two. Shiel an outside chance, ahead of WHE. Shiel would be our biggest flight risk.

Don't be fooled by all the media, the QLD/Dad thing was rubbish it was $$$.
The next most attractive place for him would be with his best mate Heater.
We are open to a fair and reasonable trade, in fact I'll go out on a limb and say if you managed to get 4 & 7 we'd probably take it

 

[Bay Pie]

GWS & Gold Coast are both interested. Both have been quoted as saying " Beam$ wants to get to Brisbane but we'll keep an eye on it". I.e. We want him.

Trying to be realistic and note that the club has said it wants players not picks. I'm just nominating better trades than the one the Bears have offered.

GWS
1) Picks 4 and 19 ( may be out with the Jaksch trade)
2) pick 4 or 7 & a decent player
3) Adam Treloar (I think he'd be off the table)

Gold Coast
1) Picks 8 & 15
2) pick 8 & Jesse Lonergan

 

[BoxMatrix]

Ooooh a no opposition thread. Haven't had one on this board. Should change the other mega thread to only Collingwood supporters...

My ideal trade would be:

Redden + 5 for beams.

Or, treloar straight swap.

I would like a deal not to be with the Lions just to give it to their greedy supporters

 

[_GT_]

Don't be fooled by all the media, the QLD/Dad thing was rubbish it was $$$.
The next most attractive place for him would be with his best mate Heater.
We are open to a fair and reasonable trade, in fact I'll go out on a limb and say if you managed to get 4 & 7 we'd probably take it

A few of us would swallow 4 & 7 for Griff.

4 & 7 for Beams would certainly swing many more. I'd personally throw in a carton of smokes, shake your hand and say thank you kindly.

 

[Apex36]

Would love Treloar. Doubt GWS would want to trade him, but at the same time, he's made it pretty clear that he's keen to get back to Vic.

I reckon a straight swap for Beams is the best trade they could hope to get for him, and the prospect of having Griffin and Beams running through their midfield must be tantalising for them.
It would fast forward their midfield development by about 5 years imo, and make them a serious competitor rather than the joke side they currently are.

Please let it happen.

 

[Tazzaye]

Treloar that good?

 

[Ricky90]

Treloar that good?

Better.

 

[dubber]

Treloar is not going to happen guyzzz, what about Shiels and pick 7?

 

[partypie]

Shiels isn't going to happen either.

 

[Cory]

Trade to GWS for Shaw