2009 Carlton Board Player of the Year

Remove this Banner Ad

Based on weekly votes of 5(best)-4-3-2-1.

votesu.jpg
 

Log in to remove this ad.

LEADER BOARD AFTER FIVE ROUNDS:
1. Marc Murphy (19)
2. Chris Judd (13)
3. Jarrad Waite (10)
=4. Bryce Gibbs (7)
=4. Matthew Kreuzer (7)
6. Richard Hadley (6)
=7. Kade Simpson (3)
=7. Eddie Betts (3)
=7. Jordan Russell (3)
=10. Paul Bower (2)
=10. Simon Wiggins (2)
12. Ryan Houlihan (1)


Marc Murphy clear leader at the moment - the only player to poll in all five games, including twice BOG and twice 2nd BOG.

As an aside, in the "Our best after 5 rounds?", players with multiple votes were:
1. Murphy (29)
2. Judd (16)
3. Betts (10)
4. Gibbs (6)
5. Waite (4)

Odd one out is Betts, who's received only 3 votes thus far, however has been fairly consistent kicking multiple goals every week.

Mods - sticky?
 
Mods - sticky?



LEADER BOARD AFTER SIX ROUNDS:
1. Marc Murphy (19)
2. Chris Judd (17)
3. Jarrad Waite (10)
4. Matthew Kreuzer (9)
5. Bryce Gibbs (7)
6. Richard Hadley (6)
=7. Paul Bower (5)
=7. Brendan Fevola (5)
=9. Kade Simpson (3)
=9. Eddie Betts (3)
=9. Jordan Russell (3)
12. Simon Wiggins (2)
=13. Ryan Houlihan (1)
=13. Nick Stevens (1)
 
Seems about right to me. Murphy has been sensational this year. Reckon he'll be in the best again this week vs Fremantle. Their best tagger is out injured, and of course, then their "best of the rest" will go to Judd. Look for our midfield to be on fire on Saturday night.
 
LEADER BOARD AFTER SEVEN ROUNDS:
1. Marc Murphy (23)
2. Chris Judd (22)
3. Jarrad Waite (13)
4. Matthew Kreuzer (9)
5. Bryce Gibbs (8)
6. Paul Bower (7)
=7. Richard Hadley (6)
=7. Brendan Fevola (5)
=9. Kade Simpson (3)
=9. Eddie Betts (3)
=9. Jordan Russell (3)
12. Simon Wiggins (2)
=13. Ryan Houlihan (1)
=13. Nick Stevens (1)


Marc Murphy and Chris Judd continue to break away from the pack - both players have had votes in 6 of our 7 matches. Murphy has been voted in our top 2 in 5 of those games, an incredible effort.

Good to see Paul Bower's good work in defence being recognised, picking up five votes in the past two weeks for his work on Franklin and Pavlich. Waite has really come on as a player in the past 18 months and it's being reflected on the leaderboard.

I'll say it again: mods, please sticky.
 
LEADER BOARD AFTER EIGHT ROUNDS:
1. Chris Judd (27)
2. Marc Murphy (23)
3. Jarrad Waite (16)
4. Matthew Kreuzer (9)
5. Bryce Gibbs (8)
=6. Paul Bower (7)
=6. Kade Simpson (7)
8. Richard Hadley (6)
=9. Brendan Fevola (5)
=9. Eddie Betts (5)
11. Jordan Russell (3)
12. Simon Wiggins (2)
=13. Ryan Houlihan (1)
=13. Nick Stevens (1)
=13. Bret Thornton (1)

After leading for seven rounds, Murphy finds himself second after not polling a vote against the Pies, despite racking up 24 touches and kicking 2.2 goals in an even team performance.

Chris Judd has jumped to first, four points clear, after trailing by 6 votes after 5 rounds. Has polled 14 out of a possible 15 in the last three weeks, bringing that to 23 out of a possible 30 votes since round 3. Brilliant footballer in brilliant form.

Jarrad Waite yet again polled votes (has polled in 5/8 matches) and while a bit behind of the two leaders, finds himself in third 7 votes clear of Matthew Kreuzer, who is amazingly sitting in fourth as a second year ruckman.
 
LEADER BOARD AFTER NINE ROUNDS:
1. Chris Judd (27)
2. Marc Murphy (25)
3. Jarrad Waite (16)
4. Matthew Kreuzer (12)
5. Paul Bower (11)
6. Bryce Gibbs (8)
7. Kade Simpson (7)
=8. Nick Stevens (6)
=8. Richard Hadley (6)
=10. Brendan Fevola (5)
=10. Eddie Betts (5)
12. Jordan Russell (3)
13. Simon Wiggins (2)
=14. Ryan Houlihan (1)
=14. Bret Thornton (1)
=14. Aaron Joseph (1)

Murphy polls 2 votes in round 9 bringing him closer to Judd, who played arguably his worst game for the season.

At the moment, both are well ahead of the pack and with Waite seemingly gone for the season, it'll be hard seeing anyone else posing much threat.

Great to see Bower continue polling well - has developed in a very solid defender and just missed out on his first BOG, though does overtake Gibbs and move into fifth spot.

Kreuzer continues polling well, his efforts as a second year ruckman explemary. Definitely wouldn't have believed he and Bower would be where they are, votes ahead of Gibbs.

Joseph gets some recognition this week, which is pleasing. Has consistently done a great tagging job and unless I'm mistaken, is our only debutant to play all 9 games this season. Great job on Andrew Mcleod. :thumbsu:
 
LEADER BOARD AFTER TEN ROUNDS:
1. Chris Judd (31)
2. Marc Murphy (30)
3. Jarrad Waite (16)
4. Matthew Kreuzer (12)
5. Paul Bower (11)
6. Kade Simpson (9)
=7. Bryce Gibbs (8)
=7. Brendan Fevola (8)
=9. Nick Stevens (6)
=9. Richard Hadley (6)
11. Eddie Betts (5)
12. Jordan Russell (3)
=13. Simon Wiggins (2)
=13. Aaron Joseph (2)
=15. Ryan Houlihan (1)
=15. Bret Thornton (1)


Murphy voted BOG in front of Judd to put him within a vote of the leader. Neck and neck and both players deserving - have each polled in 8 of our 10 matches this season. The next best is the injured Waite, who polled in 5 games.

Both Murphy and Judd have been BOG 3 times this season, while each has also received the four votes thrice. Far and away our best players in 09, as the leaderboard reflects.

Fev's 6 goals netted him the three votes while Simpson looks to be gaining some good form after being maligned earlier in the season.

Aaron Joseph picks up the 1 vote two weeks straight - good to see him getting some recognition for the tagging jobs he's performing. Now if only he'd be rewarded with a RS nomination...
 
LEADER BOARD AFTER ELEVEN ROUNDS:
1. Chris Judd (35)
2. Marc Murphy (32)
3. Jarrad Waite (16)
4. Brendan Fevola (13)
5. Matthew Kreuzer (12)
6. Paul Bower (11)
7. Bryce Gibbs (10)
8. Kade Simpson (9)
=9. Nick Stevens (6)
=9. Richard Hadley (6)
=11. Aaron Joseph (5)
=11. Eddie Betts (5)
13. Jordan Russell (3)
14. Simon Wiggins (2)
=15. Ryan Houlihan (1)
=15. Bret Thornton (1)


Once again, Chris Judd and Marc Murphy feature, though Judd's 4 votes see him pull 3 votes clear of the leader.

Amazingly, the two of them share more top 2 finishes than the rest of team combined - Judd (7), Murph (6) for a total of 13 top 2 finishes. 9 combined for the rest of the team.

Fevola gets his second BOG - in more favourable circumstances than his first one. Has polled 8 votes in the last fortnight to propel him into 4th.

Great to see AJ getting some recognition - has now polled 3 weeks straight. Not getting much notice from the wider footy community but what he's done for us and himself has been brilliant. :thumbsu:

Gibbs polled for the first time since the Freo game to hopefully end an indifferent match of football from him. Spent more time in the midfield than he has in weeks and doesn't he look so much better around the ball and forward of centre.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

considering I have been voting in reverse ie BOG =1
sorry for my stupidity (however you are all accustomed to that by now)

Jesus, Guns! Any wonder my prescription medication for premature ejaculation has had such unfortun.... aaaaaggghhhh!!!!
 
Don't worry guns, I didn't read yours backwards - even though your votes tend to be a bit biased towards our WA boys. :D

What WA bias? I think you're dreaming! :p

LEADER BOARD AFTER ELEVEN ROUNDS:
=1. Chris Judd (35)
=1. David Ellard (35)
3. Marc Murphy (32)
4. Jarrad Waite (16)
5. Brendan Fevola (13)
6. Matthew Kreuzer (12)
7. Paul Bower (11)
8. Bryce Gibbs (10)
9. Kade Simpson (9)
=10. Nick Stevens (6)
=10. Richard Hadley (6)
=12. Aaron Joseph (5)
=12. Eddie Betts (5)
14. Jordan Russell (3)
15. Simon Wiggins (2)
=16. Ryan Houlihan (1)
=16. Bret Thornton (1)
 
LEADER BOARD AFTER TWELVE ROUNDS:
1. Chris Judd (35)
2. Marc Murphy (32)
3. Jarrad Waite (16)
4. Kade Simpson (14)
5. Brendan Fevola (13)
=6. Matthew Kreuzer (12)
=6. Paul Bower (12)
8. Bryce Gibbs (11)
9. Aaron Joseph (9)
=10. Nick Stevens (6)
=10. Richard Hadley (6)
=12. Eddie Betts (5)
=13. Shaun Grigg (3)
=13. Jordan Russell (3)
=15. Simon Wiggins (2)
=15. Michael Jamison (2)
=17. Ryan Houlihan (1)
=17. Bret Thornton (1)

Neither of the top 3 polled a vote this round - Waite hasn't polled for a month and won't poll again for the season yet still remains in third, such as his form in the early part of the season. :(

Good to see Kade continue his good form after an indifferent start to the season. He's been a bit inconsistent but he was brilliant on the weekend and moves into 4th place after 12 rounds.

AJ has now polled 4 weeks straight. Only Murphy has polled 5 straight and Judd is the other player to poll 4. Some good company there. Becoming a favourite around these parts - hard to hate somebody who comprehensively squashes Milne.

Jamison gets his first 2 votes of the season for an excellent job on the in-form Kosi while Bower and Gibbs share the 1 vote in a week were all the boys contributed something.
 
Don't worry guns, I didn't read yours backwards - even though your votes tend to be a bit biased towards our WA boys. :D

who me?
Jesus, Guns! Any wonder my prescription medication for premature ejaculation has had such unfortun.... aaaaaggghhhh!!!!
Thy with the temp around zero in kinglake I would keep that python in hibernation if I was you!
 
LEADER BOARD AFTER TWELVE ROUNDS:
1. Marc Murphy (37)
2. Chris Judd (35)
3. Jarrad Waite (16)
4. Bryce Gibbs (15)
5. Kade Simpson (14)
6. Brendan Fevola (13)
=7. Matthew Kreuzer (12)
=7. Paul Bower (12)
9. Aaron Joseph (9)
10. Eddie Betts (8)
=11. Nick Stevens (6)
=11. Richard Hadley (6)
=13. Shaun Grigg (3)
=13. Jordan Russell (3)
=15. Simon Wiggins (2)
=15. Andrew Carrazzo (2)
=15. Michael Jamison (2)
=18. Ryan Houlihan (1)
=18. Brad Fisher (1)
=18. Bret Thornton (1)

Took me a while to post the Essendon game votes but didn't feel up to it last week. Much happier this week for whatever reason :)rolleyes:) and will get onto the Freo game.

Murphy's game against the Dons sees him overtake Judd and move into first place. Not sure if it'll last the week but I'll tally up the Freo votes and see.
 
LEADER BOARD AFTER FOURTEEN ROUNDS:
1. Chris Judd (39)
2. Marc Murphy (38)
3. Bryce Gibbs (20)
4. Jarrad Waite (16)
5. Kade Simpson (14)
6. Brendan Fevola (13)
=7. Matthew Kreuzer (12)
=7. Paul Bower (12)
9. Aaron Joseph (9)
10. Eddie Betts (8)
=11. Nick Stevens (6)
=11. Richard Hadley (6)
13. Andrew Carrazzo (4)
=14. Shaun Grigg (3)
=14. Jordan Russell (3)
=14. Setanta O'hAilpin (3)
=17. Simon Wiggins (2)
=17. Michael Jamison (2)
=19. Ryan Houlihan (1)
=19. Brad Fisher (1)
=19. Bret Thornton (1)

Judd back into first after polling four, while Gibbs moves into third - Waite finally being overtaken after 5 rounds injured.
 
Round 15 votes edited in the opening post. Took me a while to whip that up but listing each game after the other was making the OP too long. I apologise to those of you with lowish resolution monitors.

Fevola's 9 goals gets him his third BOG for the year, as you'd expect it would. Judd was voted 2nd BOG, extending his lead over Murphy to 5 votes.

Carrazzo has now polled three weeks straight - many were surprised when he won the B&F a couple years back but he's very solid and consistent, as is being reflected in the votes.
 
Round 16 votes vs. Sydney edited in the OP.

Chris Judd just keeps on keeping on. Extends his lead over Murphy to 8 votes now. Will be hard to be from here on in, barring injuries.

Kade Simpson moves into 5th place now, proving just how valuable a player he is to us with his run and carry. I'd suggest that a 5th place year these days would be equivalent to a top 2 finish a few years back.

Fevola just edges in front of Gibbs to take 3rd place. After polling only once in the first nine rounds, Fev has now polled in 4 of the last 7 games, showing signs that he's hitting form at the right end of the season. :thumbsu:

Been a long time between votes for big Kreuz, whose efforts in the ruck this season have I think it's fair to say, exceeded all expectations. How much time he's able to spend up forward in the remaining rounds might just determine where we end up on the ladder this season.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top