St.Kilda Clash Jumper

the-shamus-the · May 31, 2007

Which one of these two jumpers do you think look better for St.Kilda's clash jumper and which one would you most likely buy?

OR

Thanks to Mero for the pic

BABYBOMBERS2007 · May 31, 2007

The second one is sooooo much better.

Fitz roos · May 31, 2007

Second one is a really good one, first not to bad but 2nd better

saintsownthedome · May 31, 2007

I prefer the look of the first one, and its also a clear 'CLASH' jumper, which is kind of the idea.

the-shamus-the · May 31, 2007

saintsownthedome said:
I prefer the look of the first one, and its also a clear 'CLASH' jumper, which is kind of the idea.

Which teams would the second one clash with?

nintiwirri · May 31, 2007

Second looks the better .
Bring back the yellow one I reckon.

Groove · May 31, 2007

second easily

Kram · May 31, 2007

Second one by daylight . . .

Jabso · May 31, 2007

Oohhhh but the first one's logo is actually faded it looks sooooo cool.

The 2nd one wins hands down. In fact I think you can add some adjustments and change it to Bad Religion's infamous crossbuster logo and get them on board as sponsors.

PumpyChowdown · May 31, 2007

Both are good, but then again, the Sainters jersey has always been good.

Second is the best, by a margin.

Grimfang · May 31, 2007

2nd one looks better. The design that lost out to the current clash jumper looked better. Anything looks better.

The faded logo is disgraceful.

the-shamus-the · May 31, 2007

nintiwirri said:
Second looks the better .
Bring back the yellow one I reckon.

Yeah the yellow one was awesome

Red Crow · May 31, 2007

Probably the second one looks better but maybe still a bit too much black in terms of a ratio of light to dark.

My preference/idea is for something like this, which still keeps the traditional design in some way but adds a lot more white.

PumpyChowdown · May 31, 2007

crow28 said:
Probably the second one looks better but maybe still a bit too much black in terms of a ratio of light to dark.

My preference/idea is for something like this, which still keeps the traditional design in some way but adds a lot more white.

Crow, you keep this up and you'll be designing for the entire AFL soon. You're good!

Red Crow · May 31, 2007

PumpyChowdown said:
Crow, you keep this up and you'll be designing for the entire AFL soon. You're good!

well that would be nice! it'd be a better job than making subs :thumbsu:

FootyJunkie · May 31, 2007

Have always loved the cross design for St.Kilda (they wore it in the '97 GF). Should never have been discarded. That jumpers shows me that they are the saints while all the others...tri colour, lollipop stripes, don't.

juddy_Like · May 31, 2007

Somehow i have a feeling that the collie-wobbles would go ape sh1t if Crow's one is approved.

LiterallyNobody · May 31, 2007

FootyJunkie said:
Have always loved the cross design for St.Kilda (they wore it in the '97 GF). Should never have been discarded. That jumpers shows me that they are the saints while all the others...tri colour, lollipop stripes, don't.

Totally agree, it seems more traditional than any other geurnsey we wear (except of course our regular geurnsey) I would love to see them bring it or something like it back - and Crow, that design was incredible... I really liked it.... :thumbsu:

Mero · May 31, 2007

There's a long sleeve version of something very similar in the Saints Museum at Moorabbin.
When they first adopted the panels like they have now, they didn't extend to the sides, the sides were White.
And the way some were made was like Crow28's pic.
So they could argue it's a Heritage jumper.
I think I might even have a pic of it somewhere.
If I find it, I'll post it.

dan warna · Jun 1, 2007

the current one sucks too much. looks like a training jumper.

FWIW I like the candy coat, it sold well but the AFL said no to it ><

I can see their point though vertical stripes.

I wouldn't mind 3 jumpers, the candy coat, the traditional and say the hot cross but.

the current one is very ordinary and looks like other 'white' jumpers

NRL Finals week 2 🏉 Sharks v NQ 🏉 Roosters v Manly

St.Kilda Clash Jumper

Debutant

Norm Smith Medallist

Team Captain

All Australian

Debutant

Club Legend

Cancelled

I'll brik u

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Team Captain

Debutant

Modrarator

Norm Smith Medallist

Modrarator

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Cancelled due to poster being a Campaigner

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

St.Kilda Clash Jumper

Similar threads

Log In or Create New Account