TOA's Phantom Draft (long post)

Remove this Banner Ad

TOA.

Premiership Player
Oct 30, 2006
4,165
3,732
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
EDIT: Added my more 'preferred' outcome (with correct draft order). Followed by my original effort.

Round 1

Pick 1 – Carlton – Matthew Kreuzer
Pick 2 – Richmond – Trent Cotchin
Pick 3 – WC – Chris Masten
Pick 4 – Melb – Cale Morton
Pick 5 – Bulldogs – Jarred Grant
Pick 6 – Ess – David Myers
Pick 7 – Fremantle – Rhys Palmer
Pick 8 – Brisbane – Brad Ebert
Pick 9 – Saints – Ben McEvoy
Pick 10 – Adelaide – Alex Rance
Pick 11 – Sydney – Tayte Pears
Pick 12 – Hawks – Cyril Rioli
Pick 13 – WC – Jack Grimes
Pick 14 – Melb – Lachlan Henderson
Pick 15 – Roos – Scott Selwood
Pick 16 – Port – David Gourdis
Pick 17 – Cats – Patrick Vezspremi

Round 2

Pick 18 – Richmond – Patrick Dangerfield
Pick 19 – Bulldogs – Tony Notte
Pick 20 – WC – Callan Ward
Pick 21 – Melb – Chris Kangars
Pick 22 – WC – Levi Greenwood
Pick 23 – Ess – Addam Maric
Pick 24 – Fremantle – Steven Browne
Pick 25 – Brisbane – Brendan Whitecross
Pick 26 – Sydney – Tom Collier
Pick 27 – Adelaide – Andrew Otten
Pick 28 – Port – Marlon Motlop
Pick 29 – Hawthorn – Jackson Hall
Pick 30 – Adelaide – Mitch Farmer
Pick 31 – Pies – Steven Gaertner
Pick 32 – Roos – Robert Tarrant
Pick 33 – Port – Aaron Joseph
Pick 34 – Geelong – Dan McKenna

Round 3

Pick 35 – Bulldogs – Sam Reid
Pick 36 – Carlton – Ashley Arrowsmith
Pick 37 – Kangaroos – Tom Rockliff
Pick 38 – Adelaide – Tom McNamara
Pick 39 – Essendon – Darcy Daniher
Pick 40 – Fremantle – Dawson Simpson
Pick 41 – Brisbane – James Mulligan
Pick 42 – Saints – Brent Connelly
Pick 43 – Bulldogs – Jarrhan Jacky
Pick 44 – Geelong – Joseph Daye
Pick 45 – Hawthorn – Harry Croft
Pick 46 – Carlton – Scott Simpson
Pick 47 – Pies – Jack Steven
Pick 48 – Bulldogs – Jarred Petrenko
Pick 49 – Port – Pass
Pick 50 – Geelong – Matthew Lobbe

Round 4

Pick 51 – Richmond – Patrick McGinnity
Pick 52 – Brisbane – Hugh Sandilands
Pick 53 – Melb – Dean Putt
Pick 54 – Ess – Tom Bellchambers
Pick 55 – Fremantle – James Moss
Pick 56 – Brisbane – Harry Taylor
Pick 57 – St Kilda – John McCarthy
Pick 58 – Adelaide – Nick Salter
Pick 59 – Sydney – Craig Bird
Pick 60 – Geelong – Adam Donoghue
Pick 61 – Collingwood – Jaxson Barham
Pick 62 – Roos – Dayne Zorko
Pick 63 – Western Bulldogs – Easton Wood

Round 5

Pick 64 – Richmond – Pass
Pick 65 – Carlton – Pass
Pick 66 – Melbourne – Cruize Gartlett
Pick 67 – Western Bulldogs – Pass
Pick 68 – Essendon – Pass
Pick 69 – Fremantle – Kepler Bradley
Pick 70 – St Kilda – Pass
Pick 71 – Adelaide – John McDonald
Pick 72 – Ross – Pass
Pick 73 – Melbourne – Pass
Pick 74 – Fremantle – Pass
Pick 75 – Adelaide – Taylor Walker

-----------------------------------------

Note:
- Firstly, this is not how I want it ordered in an ideal world but I started these write ups about a week ago and don’t have time to change them because of uni exams (see De Boer still in there). Just wanted to post what I’d done. I will probably re-post my actual preferred order sometime over the next week (will only be marginally different anyway). My apologies that the profiles are shortened after the third round but as I said, I ran out of time and also at that stage, it’s a lucky dip and a lot of the guys I have listed could easily not get drafted.
- Second, this draft is near on impossible to predict. Many people are saying it could go completely different to what is ‘expected’. Part of the reason why I didn’t waste time corrected the selections.
- Thirdly, I have based my selections on various whispers I have heard. I have tried to align players who clubs who I know are interested, in the process I might be by-passing other clubs who could be interested but that’s how it goes. With most of the players I only know that a few clubs are talking to him, I don’t know how interested that club is or all the other clubs that have spoken to them (in most cases).

Priority Selection

Pick 1 – Carlton – Matthew KREUZER (13/05/89) 200/94
Kreuzer is a talented ruckman with good skills around the ground who has improved his intensity and physical presence this year. However, he is not the lock at pick one that many believe. There have been strong whispers over the past few weeks that the Blues are wavering on Kreuzer and are strongly considering fellow Victorian Trent Cochin or Claremont’s Cale Morton. The issue has been made even more cloudy after Carlton coach Brett Ratten stated publicly that Morton is the best prospect in the draft. When you combine this comment from the coach and the fact that the Blues recruiter Wayne Hughes has shown a strong penchant for tall athletic types, Morton is not to be discounted. Neither should Cotchin who is a player of immense talent. That said, my gut feeling is that the Blues will go with Kreuzer. If only for the fact that their midfield is looking very strong, and they are light on for quality ruckmen. The thought of Kreuzer linking up with the likes of Judd, Murphy and Stevens in the future will be too good to pass up. Carlton will also be aware that quality ruckmen are hard to come by for a side finishing in the top 8, which no doubt they plan to do from 2008 forward. So if they want a quality ruck, it might be now or never.

Round 1

Pick 2 – Richmond – Trent COTCHIN (07/04/89) 185/80
Cotchin ticks a lot of boxes; bottom-age, quality skills off both feet, good pace and footy smart. He has suffered from various injuries this year and has probably only shown form as a half forward pushing up onto the ball. Will he be the Tigers selection at 2? Who knows, it will probably be easier to flip a coin than decide. Assuming Kreuzer is selected by the Blues, then it looks like a race in two between Cotchin and Morton. There have been varying rumours on who the Tigers will select here. Some say they wouldn’t have traded for Mitch Morton if they didn’t want Cale and that Cale is very much a Richmond type of player because of his height and athleticism. Others argue that Cotchin is just what they need and is the better prospect because of his inside ability. There is little doubt that Cale has received interest from the Tigers, he was the first player they approached at the draft camp and there are rumours that head recruiter prefers him to Cotchin. However I will back the Tigers to go with the local boy based only on a hunch. Although it must be said I’m not doing it with any confidence whatsoever.

Pick 3 – West Coast – Chris MASTEN (02/05/89) 180/77
Make no mistake, West Coast want Trent Cotchin at this selection. Recruiting manager Trevor Woodhouse has signalled his intention more than once throughout the year. Cotchin is at the top of the WC draft list, there will be pleanty of fingers crossed on draft day he will slide down to pick 3. If he doesn’t, then expect West Coast to select young sharks on-baller Chris Masten. Masten has strong links with the club, both through Woodhouse and having worked at the club in the past 2 years. He is an inside player, with clean hands who can run all day – a genuine onballer. Masten has also been linked with Melb who have pick 4. His Sharks comrade Rhys Palmer and the highly regarded Cale Morton are also in the mix although WC may be wary of Morton after their experience with Mitch. A roughie this pick is young tall Ben McEvoy who has been linked with WC, although there is an outside chance he could last until their next pick at 13.

Pick 4 – Melbourne – Cale MORTON (18/01/90) 192/79

Considered by many a top 3 pick, Melbourne hadn’t expected Morton to be available until late in the year when WC secured pick 3. Its believed they have increased their interest in Cale over the past few weeks in the expectation he will be available at their first pick. Cale is bottom-age, very attractive height for AFL, highly skilled and very athletic both in terms of speed and endurance. It is believed Melbourne rate Chris Masten very highly along with his team mate Rhys Palmer. And without doubt Cameron would take Cotchin in the very unlikely event he slides to 4. Giving further weight to the notion the Dees will select one of the WA boys, they have apparently told a host family to prepare for a kid from Perth. Having secured pick 14, it seems certain they will go small here and tall at their second pick. If they did go tall then Lachlan Henderson and Ben McEvoy have been linked the Demons.

Pick 5 – WBS – Jarred GRANT (06/06/89) 192/77
Dogs could pull the first mini surprise of the draft and select Grant at pick 5. Word is that Scotty Clayton is very interested in this young forward. While some might argue the Doggies would be paying slightly ‘over the odds’, Clayton has shown in the past that doesn’t bother him as long as he rates the kid high enough. Clayton also made an interesting comment on radio a couple of months back when he was certain they bloke he wanted 5 (and 19) would be available at his respective selections. If Clayton wants Grant, he will have to take him at 5 because there is little chance he will be available at 19. An extremely athletic forward who is very creative and clever he will be an interesting player to watch on draft day. Young forward/ruck Ben McEvoy will also be in the Dogs thinking along with Vic tall Lachie Henderson. Its also believed the Dogs rate Masten and Morton highly, if they were available, it would be tough call for Clayton, although it seems his mind is made up.

Pick 6 – Ess – Ben McEVOY (11/07/89) 200/95

This may seem like a surprise selection given the Bombers need for midfielders but list manager Adrian Dodoro has said he will pick the best available, be it a midfielder, KPP or ruck. He also noted the number of midfielders the Bombers took in the 2006 draft. Essendon has been strongly linked with McEvoy for months and is very highly regarded. McEvoy is an accomplished ruckman/forward with good ruck ability, smarts and ethic. His pace off the mark isn’t great and if he slide on draft day, that could be the reason. He is a slight chance to go to WC or Melbourne and a very strong chance to end up at the Dogs at pick 5. If he did last until this selection the Bombers will have a ‘toss of the coin decision’ between he and Rhys Palmer. Brad Ebert and Cyril Rioli might come into play if both Palmer and McEvoy are gone.

Pick 7 – Fremantle – Rhys PALMER (13/02/89) 181/80
Fremantle have stated publicly their desire for midfielders. Phil Smart will be eyeing off Chris Masten and Rhys Palmer, neither could be available but the likelihood is one will slide. If that is the case, it’s hard to see Fremantle overlooking Palmer at 7. Palmer is a top-age hard at it midfielder who has the endurance of an AFL midfielder who showed outstanding form at WAFL level earlier this year. There is reasonable likelihood that both East Fremantle midfielders will be gone, if that is the case then expect the Dockers to consider taller types like Myers or possibly Ebert (although they are one of 2 clubs not to have spoken to Ebert).

Pick 8 – Brisbane – Lachlan HENDERSON (14/12/89) 196/92
Henderson has been seen as one of the standouts of this draft since the u16s, and even though his progress has been slowed by a broken leg he has undoubted talent. When on song he is quick, much quicker than his draft camp results suggest and he has potential to play CHB, CHF or FF. Many might see him as an unorthodox selection here however the Lions have shown reasonable interest in him and they have proven each year they will pick the best player available with the first selection, regardless of position. The fact Henderson could easily develop into a quality CHB should remove the pain for Lions supporters gunning for a midfielder. Henderson has also received strong interest from the Saints, so he might go at the next selection. If not, he shouldn’t get pas the Swans at 11.

Pick 9 – Saints – Cyril RIOLI (14/07/89) 177/79
Saints have shown significant interest in Cyril Rioli and David Myers while one would think they would be keen on Ben McEvoy if he lasted until this selection. But at this stage Rioli looks a good bet because of the pace, skill and goal kicking he will add to the Saints midfield in the future. He has been a very popular player with only two clubs choosing not to speak to him at the draft camp (Brisbane and Fremantle) while the Crows have shown the most interest followed by the Saints. There is a train of thought that he could slide because of a fear that he might only end up a forward pocket but a player of his pace and skill are few and far between in this draft. Brad Ebert will probably be in their thoughts as well. If the Saints decide to go for all then they have been linked strongly to Henderson and Gourdis.

Pick 10 – Adelaide – Brad EBERT (02/04/90) 188/85
Ebert is a bottom-age inside midfielder who could go as early as pick 4 but you wouldn’t think he’d last longer than the Crows first selection at 10. You could say he’s an ideal recruit for the Crows, a local who will provide leadership in the future and an option through the midfield. The Crows have been burnt by first rounders in the past and they would love to get a sure fire bet like Ebert. The Crows have publicly confirmed their interest in Ebert through club president John Reid and only 3 clubs haven’t spoken to him (Richmond, Fremantle and Bulldogs). If Ebert is gone, then the Crows will strongly consider Rioli who they have shown a lot of interest in (as mentioned above). In the unlikely event that both players are gone or the Crows decide to go tall then they have shown significant interest in Tayte Pears, having been in regular contact since early in the season.

Pick 11 – Sydney – Tayte PEARS (24/03/90) 190/92
Pears is a bottom-age key defender with outstanding pace (2.92 for 20m) who shapes as a potential full back in the future. The Swans are very likely to go tall with this selection because they need some tall depth in their list and also because they have secured Craig Bird later in this draft through promotion from their rookie list. Swans have shown a lot of interest in Pears (along with the Crows) and he shapes as a likely option at this selection. If the Swans decide to go down a different path then young Subiaco forward David Gourdis and Lachlan Henderson will come under consideration.

Pick 12 – Hawks – David MYERS (30/06/89) 191/86
Myers is a classy half-back/midfielder who has a very well rounded game. He has good pace, quality disposal, poise and footy smarts. Doubts on him ever becoming a 100min a game clearance winning midfielder might see him slide further than his ability should allow. He will probably be in the mix for all picks from pick 6 onwards. The Hawks rate him as the fifth best player in the draft and would be delighted to snare Myers at 12. He spoke to Collingwood, Hawthorn, WCE, Melbourne and the Saints at the draft camp. If he did slide to this range, its hard to see him getting past West Coast at the next selection.

Pick 13 – West Coast – Callan WARD (10/04/90) 185/73
Ward is somewhat of a bolter in this draft, his form improved as the year went on and could even push the top 10 on draft day. And its not hard to see why, he is very bottom-age, inside midfielder/forward with outstanding disposal. Clubs will hope that he will end up a prized goal kicking midfielder in the future. West Coast have been in regular contact with Ward this year but they have not been alone with a lot of clubs showing interest in him (11 clubs spoke to him at the draft camp including WC). Ward will be in the mix for West Coast’s second pick as its unlikely he will be available at their third (20 overall). Other players in the mix could be Jack Grimes, Scott Selwood, Tayte Pears or Patrick Veszpremi.

Pick 14 – Melb – Alex RANCE (09/10/89) 192/88
Rance is going to be a very interesting player to follow on draft day. There is a well founded belief he will slide down the expected order and could even fall into the 20s which might be surprise some junior footy followers. Rance is a key defender who finds a lot of the ball on the rebound and would be a good fit for a side like Melbourne who are always on the look out for tall defenders. And will probably look to take one at 14 after selecting a midfielder at pick 4. There is little doubt Rance is highly regarded with only the Saints opting not to talk to him at the draft camp. Its also expected the Rance family will follow Alex to wherever football takes him which removes the homesickness issue from the minds of interstate clubs.

Pick 15 – Roos – Scott SELWOOD (27/03/90) 185/80
Roos are believed to be very keen on Selwood and will consider him very strongly at this selection. He is a hardened, bottom-age half back flanker cum midfielder who has more pace than his brothers (X:XX), although he is still not quick per se. He is a solid selection and a good bet to become an AFL player, especially when you take into account his bloodlines. Port are believed to be keen on Selwood at the next selection if he gets past the Roos at 15. If the Roos decide against Selwood then a tall forward like Dave Gourdis or inside midfielders Jack Grimes or Patrick Veszpremi could be in their thinking.

Pick 16 – Port – Dave GOURDIS (24/03/89) 192/89
Gourdis is the x-factor of the 2007 draft, both in terms of his ability and where he could end up. His athletic capabilities are undoubted, his time of 2.83 for the 20m is outstanding for a midfielder, let alone a key position player. Some believe he could go top 10, others say he could slide out to the 20s. Being top-age, history indicates he will slide somewhat but his draft camp results may make him an exception to this trend. Port are keen on adding a key position player from one of their three selections and they have been linked to Gourdis and will look long and hard at him if he is available at their first pick. Gourdis has attracted the interest of the Swans and Crows so its conceivable he could go earlier in the first round.

Pick 17 – Cats – Jack GRIMES (11/05/89) 186/82
Grimes is an inside midfielder who is very strong in the contest and shows leadership potential. He has very good endurance (recoded beep of 15.10 earlier in the year) and although he may not look quick, his testing times were above average for a midfielder over the shorter distances. The Cats will probably look to draft the best available with this first selection and then look to replenish their tall stocks as the draft progresses. Grimes would have to be in the mix if this was the case as he is the safe, solid pick that the Cats have preferred over past seasons with their early selections. If not Grimes, then smalls like Selwood, Veszpremi and Dangerfield would be in the mix. If the Cats decide to go tall then Gourdis (if available), Rance, Pears or Notte will be in their thinking.
 
Priority Selection

Pick 18 – Richmond – Steven GAERTNER (02/01/90) 198/85
Gaertner is X-factor personified. Bottom-age, seriously quick, very tall and extremely agile, he could be something very special. He could go anywhere from pick 5 to 40, the one thing holding him back is his kicking, and it will be the club who is surest they can correct this flaw that will take him. Among others, the Tigers, WC and Adelaide have shown interest. The Tigers ideally want to get a key defender at this selection and Gaertner has the pace which Miller and co have emphasised in the past. If available then you’d expect they’d consider Pears (who they have spoken to on more than one occasion) or Rance strongly. If they decided to go small then Tigers have been strongly linked to Dangerfield, and also Addam Maric.

Round 2

Pick 19 – Bulldogs – Tony NOTTE (15/04/90) 194/70
Notte has a lot of potential, he is very bottom-age, has sticky hands, good kick and if he can add the weight he should be a very handy player. His weight is almost a show stopper but that hasn’t concerned Dogs recruiting manager Scott Clayton in the past if he thinks the player has enough talent (see Everitt, Williams, Walsh, Ray etc). It also worth remembering that Clayton has made his mind up on who he will select at pick 19, implying he knows the player will be available which seemingly rules out him taking a slider. This may seem unusual but if you look at Clayton’s previous drafts, he doesn’t mind taking players earlier than predicted to ensure he gets them. It is also worth noting he has said that he expects those two players to be athletic tall forwards and Notte seems a good bet. Another player who fits bill is Robbie Tarrant who had a very impressive draft camp. If the Dogs decide to go small then Sam Reid and Callan Ward have been linked to the Dogs.

Pick 20 – WC – Levi GREENWOOD (19/02/89) 181/93
Greenwood is a top-age, strong bodied midfielder who shone at the u18 carnival and also in the SANFL this year. His contested work and kicking are above average and he tested very well for pace for a guy his size. His skin fold test was very good, dismissing any fears that he he is overweight. Similar to Shannon Hurn, WC will look to ‘fine down’ his physique and look to give him more endurance. West Coast have shown reasonable interest in Greenwood and it would not surprise to see him taken at 20 or 22. Other players linked to WC at these selections are Maric, Veszpremi, Selwood and Ward (if he lasts).

Pick 21 – Melb – Patrick VESZPREMI (01/07/89) 181/85
Veszpremi is another player hard to place in this years draft. He was a standout last year as a below-age kid at the u18 championships and seemed assured of being a top 5 selection in the 2007 draft. However, he has stagnated somewhat this year (many would argue because of injury), and other players have arguably surpassed him. Veszpremi is still very talented and clubs would love his style of play but doubts on his body shape and endurance may see him slide to this range. That said, he could still go a lot earlier. West Coast and Richmond are believed to be keen on him but he might be too good for a side like Melbourne to pass up. Having taken an outside type at pick 4, the Dees would love a hard nut like Veszpremi to balance their list additions. Melbourne could also consider someone like Tom Collier, Patrick Dangerfield or Addam Maric.

Pick 22 – West Coast – Dawson SIMPSON (17/02/89) 206/105
This is going to be a very interesting pick because it will be West Coast’s final selection and as a result they might have to pick for need as opposed to the best available. There is no doubt West Coast need a young ruckman on their list, whether it is worth spending pick 22 on one will be Trevor Woodhouse and John Worsfold’s call. However, they have shown significant interest in Simpson, and while it might be a big call to use 22 on him, they may pull the trigger and snare the giant ruckman who has good skills and tap ability. If West Coast decide to go for the best available then Maric, Tarrant, Notte have been linked to the club.

Pick 23 – Ess – Addam MARIC (19/04/90) 178/77
Maric is a very clever bottom-age forward who could develop into a quality smart midfielder in time. It’s the doubt on his ability to play up the ground and his work ethic which could see Maric slide into the 20s. Maric has received significant of interest from other clubs with Essendon, West Coast, Richmond, Roos and Saints all showing interest at or around the draft camp. While some might see this as a slightly unusual selection, the Bombers are closely considering Maric and would probably view him as the best available at this stage. Bombers have also shown interest in Patrick Dangerfield and Scott Selwood.

Pick 24 – Fremantle – Steven BROWNE (01/02/89) 180/75
Fremantle will be looking for another quality midfielder at this selection and Browne looks a good fit. Super classy, hard at it, skilled and smart, he will add some defensive pressure to the Freo midfield. Ideally Fremantle would want a tall outside midfielder but there is little like that on offer this year and a good bet like Browne is a good fall back option. Other options include Whitecross, Reid and Dangerfield but they could go anywhere.

Pick 25 – Brisbane – Brendan WHITECROSS (25/01/90) 183/79
Whitecross is a bottom-age inside midfielder who has good scope for improvement in the future. Solid all round player, good in the air, long kick, doesn’t mind the hard stuff. He impressed at the draft camp this year in numerous tests, with his speed being the standout (2.91 for the 20m). Whitecross should be in the mix for the Lions second selection along with any number of players including fellow Queenslander Sam Reid, or Tom Collier, Dangerfield or Patrick McGinnity.

Pick 26 – Sydney – Tom COLLIER (12/03/89) 192/84
Collier is a top-age tall who played well in the VFL this year after being overlooked for last years draft. This traditionally means a kid will fall further than expected so it will be interesting to watch him on draft day. He has shown an ability to play CHB but will probably turn out to be a running defender/midfielder at AFL level which will suit the Swans game style. Collier has also attracted the interest of the Lions, Roos and Melbourne so he could easily go in the preceding selections. Alternatives for the Swans include a young tall forward like Robbie Tarrant,

Pick 27 – Adelaide – Patrick DANGERFIELD (05/04/90) 187/83
Dangerfield is a bottom-age, hard at it HBF/midfielder, who is an attractive height with very good pace. His smarts and skills may see him slide somewhat as could the fact he is looking to spend next year in Melbourne to finish school. This is probably the latest he could go, while he could go as early as the Crows first pick at 10. The Crows have shown a lot of interest and will be all over him if he lasts this long. Richmond and Sydney have also expressed reasonable interest. Crows have shown an interest in Mitch Farmer and Andy Otten who will also be in the mix for this selection, along with Levi Greenwood if he slides.

Pick 28 – Port – Marlon MOTLOP (17/04/90) 179/75
Motlop is the forgotten man of the 2007 draft. He shone at u16 level last year but has struggled with injury all season and only played a handful of games, most of those being the u18 carnival which he played under serious duress from back stress fractures. His coach later commented he shouldn’t have played at all. He is viewed by those in the know as a real top 20 chance and Port are believed to be keen on him, and there is a very real chance he could be their first round selection (16 overall). If Motlop isn’t available or Port chose to go down another path, then they will be hoping Levi Greenwood is available as they would love a big bodied midfielder.

Pick 29 – Hawthorn – Jackson HALL (06/09/89) 188/76
Hall is a tall athletic wing/HBF who is ideally suited to the modern game with his height and running capacity. The Hawks seem to like this type of player and should go in this range on draft day. They are a very hard club to predict. Might be hoping for Motlop to slide down to order to give them some crumbing power.

Pick 30 – Adelaide – Andrew OTTEN (15/05/89) 192/86
Otten is a very attractive size for a modern player and can play through the midfield and up forward. He should be taken somewhere in the second round with Hawthorn, Adelaide, Sydney and Kangaroos all showing interest. Adelaide have also shown an interest in Mitch Farmer he’s a good chance to get selected here or at 27. Its possible the Crows might go tall here so guys like Kangers or Tarrant might come under consideration if that is the case.

Pick 31 – Pies – Matthew DeBOER (10/03/90) 186/81
De Boer a similar type to what the Derek Hine has sounded out in the past. Bottom-age, good pace, nice height and from WA where Collingwood has had a full time recruiter watching the talent in 2007. There have been doubts whether De Boer will nominate and there seem to be conflicting reports coming from different parties. Port, Collingwood and Kangaroos has shown interest in Scott, however it seems the local WA teams have not and this may have prompted him to question whether to nominate or not. NOTE: No longer nominating.

Pick 32 – Roos – Robert TARRANT (25/04/89) 196/90
Tarrant is a top-age tall forward who could be boom or bust. Like his brother, he shapes as a type who looks good but rarely delivers. His draft camp was very good for a player of his size and increased his value to a point where he should go somewhere before pick 40. If the Roos go small with their first selection, it seems likely the will go tall with their second and Tarrant should in the mix. Tarrant has attracted the interest of West Coast and Sydney among others so he may well go earlier.

Pick 33 – Port – Patrick McGINNITY (18/02/89) 184/78
McGinnity is a top-age strong bodied midfielder who goes very hard it at. His effort tagging Cotchin at the championships put his name under the spotlight and his WAFL form following that successful effort would have really put recruiters on notice. He has attracted interest from Essendon and Richmond but they don’t seem to have picks suitable to get him. Port will be on the look out for a strong bodied type like him to help out their quick outside types and McGinnity fits the bill.

Pick 34 – Geelong – Chris KANGERS (01/08/89) 193/85
Kangers is tall defender who is extremely athletic and raw. Clubs will look at him as being able capable of going with athletic forwards like Riewoldt in the future. His kicking needs work and his footy smarts need improving but he has an attractive package and should be reasonably highly sought after. The Cats are in need for key position players and the local boy Kangers could easily be in the mix at this selection. Melbourne and the Roos have shown interest and would be an outside chance to go at 21 if the Dees rate him high enough because its doubtful he will last until their next pick in the third round.
 
Round 3

Pick 35 – Bulldogs – Sam REID (07/11/89) 188/79
Nice size for a modern player, he has added 3cm this year. Trained with the Dogs as part of the AIS and they have kept in touch.

Pick 36 – Carlton –Mitchell FARMER (04/01/89) 180/77
Top-age back pocket who could go earlier if clubs think he has midfield potential. Crows and Pies have expressed interest.

Pick 37 – Kangaroos – Jarrhan JACKY (05/04/89) 178/75
Quick indigenous forward who seems to be quite highly regarded. Roos might continue to add pace to supplement their running game plan last year.

Pick 38 – Adelaide – Dan McKENNA (29/06/89) 195/85

Athletic smooth moving KPP who could go closer to pick 20. Melbourne and Cats have shown interest, might come under consideration for the Crows who may be looking to go tall here after going small earlier.

Pick 39 – Essendon – Darcy DANIHER f/s

Pick 40 – Fremantle – Tom McNAMARA (29/04/90) 189/84
Very athletic defender who tests very well for the 20m sprint. Adds the height and pace to the Freo linup.

Pick 41 – Brisbane – James MULLIGAN (14/06/1989) 201/96
Very talented and athletic ruckman/forward with a big kick who needs to put it all together. His 20m time could see him rise up the rankings considerably on draft day. Might be in the mix for Lions pick at 25.

Pick 42 – Saints – Aaron JOESEPH (04/07/89) 181/78
Attractive combination of pace and hardness, will be interesting to see when he goes given he came through Div 2 at the Champs. Another who could go earlier.

Pick 43 – Bulldogs – Scott SIMPSON (19/10/89) 196/92
Tall with good hands but mobility question/ DC times should see him slide.

Pick 44 – Geelong – Toby THOOLAN (23/02/90) 195/92
Bottom-age tall who clubs might be willing to take a punt on given the weak depth in the key position players this year.

Pick 45 – Hawthorn – Harry CROFT (24/10/89) 192/82
Tall defender who has attracted the interest of various clubs including Roos, Hawks and Cats. Hawks will probably look to snare a key defender at some stage in the draft.

Pick 46 – Carlton – Joeseph DAYE (02/02/90) 192/78
Bottom-age tall who has shown a lot of potential. His DC results were very good, especially speed which will throw him right into the mix. Has attracted interest of the Blues, Lions and Cats. This is the type of tall Wayne Hughes has looked at the in the past.

Pick 47 – Pies – Chris MAYNE (06/06/88) 187/80
Somewhat of a smokey. Over-age forward who has attracted a lot of interest from the Pies but also spoke to Melb, Freo and Brisbane at the DC. Pies may consider him at 31.

Pick 48 – Bulldogs – John McCARTHY (19/11/89) 189/80
Played school footy this year but excelled when played in the TAC, despite playing injured. Hard and quick at an attractive height, could easily go earlier.

Pick 49 – Geelong – Scott THOMPSON
Tall defender who has shown good form in the VFL. Cats reportedly very keen to get him and sure up their tall stocks.

Round 4

Pick 50 – Richmond– Dean PUTT (23/04/89) 203/90
Smokey who could go a lot earlier given his testing results at his state screening. Not really a ruckman at this stage but has the elements to be a very handy AFL player. Rumour that the Tigers looking at taking someone ‘from left field’ at this pick, Putt could be the man.

Pick 51 – Brisbane – Hugh SANDILANDS (07/03/89) 191/82.
Top-age defender/midfielder who has attracted the interest of Saints, Lions and WC.

Pick 52 – Melb – John McDONALD (17/07/89) 181/75
Played a lot of school footy this year but has shown promising signs.

Pick 53 – Ess – Ashley ARROWSMITH (12/04/89) 189/82
Top-age forward/midfielder who had a strong end to the year.

Pick 54 – Fremantle – Tom BELLCHAMBERS (09/07/89) 201/100
Ruckman who has attracted interest of Freo and Essendon, may slide given pace and other issues.

Pick 55 – Brisbane – Harry TAYLOR (12/06/86) 193/91
Tall defender who had a very impressive state screening and has attracted the interest from WC, Brisbane and Sydney. Could be a chance to go a lot earlier, possibly to the Swans at 26.

Pick 56 – St Kilda – Brent CONNELLY (24/02/89) 202/83
Ruckman who has attracted significant interest from the Saints as well as Freo and Cats. Has grown 4cm since last year.

Pick 57 – Adelaide – Nick SALTER (30/07/07) 189/94
Forward who showed strong form in the SANFL, the Crows are reportedly keen on him and that looks likely to eventuate given all their selections this year.

Pick 58 – Sydney – Craig BIRD nsw

Pick 59 – Geelong – Adam DONOGHE f/s

Pick 60 – Collingwood – Jaxson BARHAM f/s

Pick 61 – Western Bulldogs – Easton WOOD 189/78
Looks like being the regulation Clayton smoky. Relatively unheard who has focused on cricket until recently.

Pick 62 – Richmond – Pass

Pick 63 – Carlton – Pass


Pick 64 – Melbourne – Guy O’KEEFE (05/12/89) 185/76
Played a lot of school footy this year but has shown promising signs

Pick 65 – Western Bulldogs – Pass

Pick 66 – Essendon – Clayton HINKLEY (21/02/89) 186/74
Defender who had a brilliant DC and can find a lot of the ball. Kicking is the question mark but could go a lot earlier.

Pick 67 – Fremantle – Kepler BRADLEY

Pick 68 – St Kilda – Cruize GARTLETT (18/03/89) 174/77
Diminutive small forward who has slid under the radar this year. Should provide pace and crumbing which is lacking from the Saints side.

Pick 69 – Adelaide – Taylor WALKER nsw

Pick 70 – Melbourne –Pass

Pick 71 – Fremantle – Pass


 

Log in to remove this ad.

Always a great read

It's just the West Coast picks are just such polar opposits to what we have looked so hard for over the past 6 or so drafts.

Yep, I know. But as I said, I aligned clubs with who I heard they were interested in. The WC picks were very hard. I could easily see us taking Cotchin, Ward, Grimes and Vez.

If I had my time again I would tweak my order, especially from pick 6 to 12.
 
Thought you had one of the better phantom's last year TOA, so I was keen to see your selections this year. Interestingly you were one of the few who had Brisbane taking Leuenberger with their first pick last year and you've again gone with a bit of a different selection in Henderson.
 
Thought you had one of the better phantom's last year TOA, so I was keen to see your selections this year. Interestingly you were one of the few who had Brisbane taking Leuenberger with their first pick last year and you've again gone with a bit of a different selection in Henderson.

Brissie along with the Hawks pick were very hard to call. I have been changing my mind on that for ages. For alot of the time I have had Myers going at 8 to the Lions and also Ebert in the mix. I settled on Hendeson mainly becuase you guys have a history of going tall with your first pick and more importantly you pick the best available. Henderson could be pretty special he was rated in a similar class to Kreuzer 18months ago.
 
What a great read. Well done mate, Dam youve got alot of sources :p Dodoro has already said we would not be using pick 66 and i hope the toss up goes Palmers way :thumbsu:
 
Note:
-Pick 17 – Cats – Jack GRIMES (11/05/89) 186/82
Grimes is an inside midfielder who is very strong in the contest and shows leadership potential. He has very good endurance (recoded beep of 15.10 earlier in the year) and although he may not look quick, his testing times were above average for a midfielder over the shorter distances. The Cats will probably look to draft the best available with this first selection and then look to replenish their tall stocks as the draft progresses. Grimes would have to be in the mix if this was the case as he is the safe, solid pick that the Cats have preferred over past seasons with their early selections. If not Grimes, then smalls like Selwood, Veszpremi and Dangerfield would be in the mix. If the Cats decide to go tall then Gourdis (if available), Rance, Pears or Notte will be in their thinking.

could he get down to pick 19, he seems to be what would fit the dogs the best, inside midfielder with real leadership i'd love if we pick him up.
 
A really great read.

- I really hope that we get a David Myers at pick 13 ( but its looking like that would be some kind of miracle).

- I am surprised to see Selwood at 15, I thought he was not that highly rated.
 
Great stuff. Like the emphasis on info from the clubs, and recruiting styles.

As we know though even the best phantom drafts only predict maybe 10-12% correct picks. So when people get nit picky about things, it really doesnt matter that much.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Nice read TOA - like the fact you have mixed it up a bit. Bold for Grant to go at 5 and cannot see him ahead of Palmer but you never know! Interesting that you have Gourdis dropping to 16. Port would love it if he was in the mix for them.

Quite like the Collingwood selection of Mayne, albeit I cannot see us taking 3 mids. At least one will be tall or a ruckmen unless they plan for that in the first round of the rookie but I doubt it.

Dogs would be rapt to get Simpson and Reid so late as well.
 
Thanks TOA , a good read, interested to hear about someone I hadnt even heard of ...Tayte ? (bogan stock? ) Pears

Can you PM me where you get this info from :)

Any love for Patrick Vespremi (sp) ...we have one or two posters on our board who have full on rogers for this guy.

Dangerfield I havent heard of either but will be interested to see

Once again cheers
 
Thanks for the encouragement guys.

As I said, I'm not really happy with the end result. Some guys and clubs are not aligned how I would have liked. I could have changed it up everyday until the draft and I would still be wrong :p So I decided to cut my losses and post what I'd done.
 
good draft picks from brisbanes perspective

but i would be pretty pissed off if brisbane did take a tall with pick 8

especially after brisbane have said they will more than likely take a midfielder and the fact that brisbane have plenty of talls
 
good draft picks from brisbanes perspective

but i would be pretty pissed off if brisbane did take a tall with pick 8

especially after brisbane have said they will more than likely take a midfielder and the fact that brisbane have plenty of talls

Know where you are coming from and as I said that Brissie pick at 8 was hard to call. I went with Henderson because I know you were had talked with him. Whereas I didnt know if you had shown interest in Ebert or Myers. You probably have but when doing a phantom draft I had to balance the fact a club had shown interest against guys who seem a better fit for that pick. Most of the time I went with guys who I know clubs were interested in because it reduces the unknown variable.

The reality is that the draft this year will be raffle. It will be all over the shop. My PD wont even be close, I just do it for abit of fun and hopefully it gives people a guide.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

TOA's Phantom Draft (long post)

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top