Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. philthy05

    Who will be better in 2024? Crows or Port?

    You’re talking to a fan base that rates the showdown as a grand final. If they beat port they’re happy.
  2. philthy05

    Who will be better in 2024? Crows or Port?

    Ask him how Schoenberg “the next big thing” or scholl “the next big thing” or Sam berry “the next big thing” or gallant “the next big thing” or Milera “the next big thing” and all the others before that. How many players did they give McLeods number to and proclaim the next McLeod? Every...
  3. philthy05

    Can Port win a premiership under Ken Hinkley?

    How many superstars do we need to do the basics right? It’s obviously not the players. Our gameplan is ****ed and it hampers our players. I’m not sure why it’s not more heavily talked about, I think the vic based media half don’t give a shit and are half just incompetent boys club knobs...
  4. philthy05

    Player Watch Nick Daicos - Can he be the GOAT?

    You might have a point if thread title was “Nick Daicos, can he have a good game?” Instead of asking if he can be the goat.
  5. philthy05

    Player Watch Nick Daicos - Can he be the GOAT?

    If anything Daicos performance against port further confirms hes the king of downhill skiing. Our mids were completely switched off, the set ups totally wrong. Pies mids just had zero pressure on them at all. Daicos might as well been playing against nobody, just the way he likes it.
  6. philthy05

    Player Watch JHF - Jason Horne-Francis

    Lol “if zuurhaar triggered band 1.” What a fantasy. The afl is a corrupt organisation, and morons. I’m not sure there’s a level 8 galaxies below corrupt morons but that’s what they would be.
  7. philthy05

    Player Watch Nick Daicos - Can he be the GOAT?

    All the players that were better than him you sad troll.
  8. philthy05

    2024 Rolling ALL-Australian Team

    Yes. I provided the stats to back it up. As I said it’s only 2 games in but he’s shown he’s capable of this for a while now and he’s really coming into his own.
  9. philthy05

    2024 Rolling ALL-Australian Team

    Todd Marshall right now has his hands up for the chf spot At the pointy end of most of if not all the forward stats. 25th goals 2nd shots at goal 5th goal assists (1st kf) 7th score involvements (1st kf) 16th contested 1 on 1s 6th contested offensive wins 3rd marks (1st kf) 1st marks on lead...
  10. philthy05

    Adelaide's decline

    How on earth would anyone find that offensive? They spoke about cats fitness , ability to use stewert how they like and impact of a coach.
  11. philthy05

    Adelaide's decline

    I’m a spine believer but gee Sydney are looking very good and on paper that spine has some average names not too mention google wouldn’t even know their kpps on the list outside their 22.
  12. philthy05

    Player Watch Nick Daicos - Can he be the GOAT?

    It’s also disrespectful and ignorant of the players that came before daicos. There are special once in a generation players that aren’t even (or maybe barely) in the discussion to be the goat and daicos isn’t within 13 galaxies of those players. Guys like Andrew McLeod. Micheal Voss. Simon...
  13. philthy05

    Adelaide's decline

    One ? Port is currently rolling with rozee , butters , jhf, wines , boak , drew Brisbane - Dunkley , Neale zorko mcluggage Lyons Freo - serong Brayshaw young Fyfe Sydney - Warner rowbottom mills Heeney gulden Giants - green Kelly coniglio The crows are way more than one high end...
  14. philthy05

    Adelaide's decline

    Rachele and rankine make perfect sense. McHenry and pedlar with high draft picks are the odd ones out.
  15. philthy05

    Adelaide's decline

    I do think curtain has the capability to turn into one of the big hits for them though. Has the earmarks of a top chb in the league. And won’t they need it with that plodding midfield
  16. philthy05

    Who's closer to a flag? Adelaide, Port Adelaide or Fremantle?

    Dixon isn't our most important kf, Marshall is, tho lord going down is a massive blow for us. hes interchangeable with Dixon and we could have picked between them on form / kept Dixon fresh by giving him some weeks off. instead Hinkley will run him into the ground by finals. I reckon were...
  17. philthy05

    Who's closer to a flag? Adelaide, Port Adelaide or Fremantle?

    at no point have I ever said every sa star is going to return. ive simply said throwing money at the many sa kids around the league is one way the crows might be able accelerate their list build
  18. philthy05

    Who will be better in 2024? Crows or Port?

    I did miss those 2 (pedlar and thilthorpe) meant to write them down but forgot. Didn’t bother noting guys who haven’t had much exposure to afl like I skipped guys like Jackson Scully for port. Still not a clear gap between the two groups.
  19. philthy05

    Adelaide's decline

    They picked an era where they bungled a bunch of draft picks in. It’s relevant and highlights a problem with the crows current list. Also, how the hell is it “port goggles” Crows fans themselves lament those draft choices. Again, what a bizarre hill to die on.
  20. philthy05

    Adelaide's decline

    What are you talking about? Poster pointed out the crows made a series of draft bungles picking draft busts with high picks Which is true Poster pointed out that there were good to great players available at those picks all teams hit and miss on draft picks, but crows obviously missed...
  21. philthy05

    Who's closer to a flag? Adelaide, Port Adelaide or Fremantle?

    Huh? Did you even read 1. I’ve made no assumption that players are going to do what ever 2. “Your rebuild”? I wasn’t talking about port, I was talking about the crows. Read ffs.
  22. philthy05

    Who will be better in 2024? Crows or Port?

    21 and under Curtain Michealanny Rachele Soligo Borlase Burgoyne Horne-Francis Lachie jones Sinn Visentini I’m not sure that is accurate to say you’ve got more 21 and under as if it’s clearly a better group.
  23. philthy05

    Adelaide's decline

    I’m not sure what you’re talking about. They obviously made a series of draft bungles in drafts where good to star players were available around their picks.
  24. philthy05

    Who's closer to a flag? Adelaide, Port Adelaide or Fremantle?

    where have I said anything of the sort? 'there is a bunch of young south Aussies in the league developing who might be available to come back to Sa via trade or free agency' still sore about Jason leaving eh.
  25. philthy05

    Who's closer to a flag? Adelaide, Port Adelaide or Fremantle?

    the saving hope for the crows is that there is a bunch of young south Aussies in the league developing who might be available to come back to Sa via trade or free agency and cause of ports fairly stacked list the crows have some chance to be able to get them by throwing money at them
  26. philthy05

    Adelaide's decline

    lol what? Geelong and gcs are not top 6 sides, at best either might sneak into finals. more likely to be 8th-14th. both teams also played poorly and were very beatable.
  27. philthy05

    Who's closer to a flag? Adelaide, Port Adelaide or Fremantle?

    crows highest rated players last night were crouch, obrien laird and Dawson , all aged between 26-30. these guys are going to be gone or end of the careers by the time the next gen are close to ready. for instance by the time rankine , soligo, thilthorpe , rachele curtain etc are around that...
  28. philthy05

    Player Watch Nick Daicos - Can he be the GOAT?

    Saying dumb things and getting called out for saying dumb things isn’t some big win
  29. philthy05

    Player Watch Nick Daicos - Can he be the GOAT?

    Yeah that’s not what is happening at all. your behaviour is outright ludicrous.
  30. philthy05

    Player Watch Nick Daicos - Can he be the GOAT?

    “The most exciting young player in the competition” Literally every team you’ve played so far this year has arguably had a better exciting young player” Pies fans don’t even have an other eye to open. Hell no. The way he’s performed this year when Collingwood aren’t winning games has shown...
Back
Top